Rotolo's Pizza
1749 W 5th Ave, Columbus
(614) 488-7934
Customers' Favorites
Medium Pizza with 1 Item
Chicken Parmigiano
Home-Made Lasagna
Everything Pizza
Original Calzone
Additional Items
Tuesday Special
With Meat Sauce
Banana Peppers
Family Lasagna
Menu
Photos
+47 photos
+46 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The best pizza in Columbus since I was a little boys. They have the best sauce and the best pepperoni—just a little bit spicy—and they put plenty of cheese and cook it until it’s golden brown. There is no better pie in Columbus. Sorry I didn’t take any pictures this time, it’s too good to waste time taking pictures.
I flew 1,100 miles from Tampa for the absolute best Pizza ever. I have been a customer for over 40 years. Even after moving to Florida, I still look forward to the best Pizza ever @ Rotolos!!!
I often order spaghetti and lasagna (bread and salad) for business meetings, and non profits groups of 25 to 50 people. I have made Rotollo’s my go to for delicious Italian food when I need to feed large groups. The feedback is always the same;
This food is amazing! Where did you get it?
For bigger catering orders, give them a couple days notice. They are very nice, and easy to work with. They have always come through for me for all these years.
This food is amazing! Where did you get it?
For bigger catering orders, give them a couple days notice. They are very nice, and easy to work with. They have always come through for me for all these years.
You May Also Like
Red Door Tavern - 1736 W 5th Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Dive Bar, Venues & Event Spaces, Vegetarian
Jimmy V's Grill & Pub Grandview - 1788 W 5th Ave
![]()
Sports Bar, Greek, Mediterranean, Pubs, Vegetarian
QDOBA Mexican Eats - 1689 W 5th Ave
![]()
Mexican, Fast Food, Pet Friendly