I've seen this pizza numerous times as I've walked through the market. I've always avoided it, despite how good it looks, due to my stomachs issues with eating bread...I finally convinced myself yesterday that this pizza would be worth the cramping, pain, and multiple 30 minute trips to the toilet, and boy was I right.Hands down one of the best slices of pizza I have ever had in my life.I'll likely get a slice everytime im in Colombus now.Don't pass on this pizza, you're robbing yourself from experiencing greatness.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Daniel Jones
Worst chicken parm sub ever. The chicken tender must have been at least a week old, it was very tough and was a bit brownish on the inside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice, Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Brian Morris
Excellent pizza slicesThin crust, little
Food: 4
Service: 3
Mr. Branham
Man, this was a pretty fun place. You can see the pizzas out which will of course make you want a slice and you can just go talk to him and get your pizza. They say it's New York style and I think it's only because his sliced large. It's really not New York tasting pizza. It's more of a New York slice of pizzaParking: Parking is absolutely horrible presently it will get better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Kris Gaul
Probably the best quick slice around downtown so far that I've had. Subs are good too. Been stopping here a few times a week now for a couple weeks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
jim albers
Spent $20 for a take and bake pizza. Overpriced.Followed the instructions to bake and the instructions resulted in an incinerated inedible pizza. It went into the trash.I will never go back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Margaret Mary Murphy (Margo)
I’ve been a loyal customer at Sarefino’s for a few years now. As an East-Coaster I can confidently say their pizza is the best New York slice in Columbus and the stromboli is sooo delicious! The owners and their staff are very dedicated and personable. They always remember my name when I stop by! Love Sarefino’s!
Jenna Norman
Great pizza and even better customer service!
J Norman
Great pizza and even better customer service!
Charles Tyroler
The pizzas sit in a rack on the front counter & have a lot of eye appeal. I ordered 2 slices from the fresh looking pizzas on top. Apparently that was intolerable to Sarafino's employees, who denied me ordering selected slices and stated it was a health code violation to serve that way! They wanted to serve me the remaining slices from earlier in the day, which may have been ok but I preferred the newer. They made a big stink about it & resentfully & rudely ended up complying with my request. I asked for a simple refund of my purchase, which had not been served yet, but they ignored my requests. Employees kept walking over & asked what's going on & then insisting it's a health code violation to choose your slices! I never raised my voice or used foul language, but I was rudely tossed my order. As I was walking away, yet another employee accosted me for daring to select my slices & told me not to come back!! I said "Are you drunk?" I heard her & the employees forcing a laugh at my expense as I walked away, trying to add insult to injury. The pizza itself is always plain but I buy a slice now & then anyway. But with rude service like this I might as well find another pizzaria.
0 people in line and wouldn't cut us any meat....very rude laughed in our faces about it.
Jeffrey Rodman
Pizza was not very good, the staff was not friendly and the pizza was not heated up enough.
Alison B.
Extremely rude employees. Asked if they had any gluten free options and was laughed at & received multiple eye rolls. Disappointing especially when the North Market in general is extremely allergen friendly. Would not recommend to anyone.
RM P.
Just came from here, don't know if the food is good but we ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza and the kid pulling it out of the oven let out a large burp, in my husband's face. Albeit, he was behind the counter - but we could smell that he had some Gatorade before hand. We cancelled the slice, the chef in the back looked mortified and the kid, said, "really? For an accident?" Yeah man, when we can smell snack time from some other kids guts we don't want to try the food. The kids' mother was salty when she was returning our $4.50- I only gave it two stars because of the mortification of the cook. Maybe we will try it again at some point. But not today Satan.
Steven Spratt
Worst pizza my family has ever had … Sunday labor weekend ordered a whole cheese pizza 40 minutes before market closed … got it with extra cheese but didn’t appear to have extra cheese … crust was burnt …. Cheese was burnt … had over abundance of whatever they sprinkle on it … sauce was sparse without much taste … worst pizza we’ve ever had … my family and I, when we travel always try to seek out pizza shops to try. Over the years we have never had a pizza that we just threw in the trash because it was so bad. Doesn’t even deserve one star.
I've seen this pizza numerous times as I've walked through the market. I've always avoided it, despite how good it looks, due to my stomachs issues with eating bread...I finally convinced myself yesterday that this pizza would be worth the cramping, pain, and multiple 30 minute trips to the toilet, and boy was I right.Hands down one of the best slices of pizza I have ever had in my life.I'll likely get a slice everytime im in Colombus now.Don't pass on this pizza, you're robbing yourself from experiencing greatness.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Worst chicken parm sub ever. The chicken tender must have been at least a week old, it was very tough and was a bit brownish on the inside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice, Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Excellent pizza slicesThin crust, little
Food: 4
Service: 3
Man, this was a pretty fun place. You can see the pizzas out which will of course make you want a slice and you can just go talk to him and get your pizza. They say it's New York style and I think it's only because his sliced large. It's really not New York tasting pizza. It's more of a New York slice of pizzaParking: Parking is absolutely horrible presently it will get better
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Probably the best quick slice around downtown so far that I've had. Subs are good too. Been stopping here a few times a week now for a couple weeks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Spent $20 for a take and bake pizza. Overpriced.Followed the instructions to bake and the instructions resulted in an incinerated inedible pizza. It went into the trash.I will never go back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
I’ve been a loyal customer at Sarefino’s for a few years now. As an East-Coaster I can confidently say their pizza is the best New York slice in Columbus and the stromboli is sooo delicious! The owners and their staff are very dedicated and personable. They always remember my name when I stop by! Love Sarefino’s!
Great pizza and even better customer service!
Great pizza and even better customer service!
The pizzas sit in a rack on the front counter & have a lot of eye appeal. I ordered 2 slices from the fresh looking pizzas on top. Apparently that was intolerable to Sarafino's employees, who denied me ordering selected slices and stated it was a health code violation to serve that way! They wanted to serve me the remaining slices from earlier in the day, which may have been ok but I preferred the newer. They made a big stink about it & resentfully & rudely ended up complying with my request. I asked for a simple refund of my purchase, which had not been served yet, but they ignored my requests. Employees kept walking over & asked what's going on & then insisting it's a health code violation to choose your slices! I never raised my voice or used foul language, but I was rudely tossed my order. As I was walking away, yet another employee accosted me for daring to select my slices & told me not to come back!! I said "Are you drunk?" I heard her & the employees forcing a laugh at my expense as I walked away, trying to add insult to injury. The pizza itself is always plain but I buy a slice now & then anyway. But with rude service like this I might as well find another pizzaria.
Restaurantji Recommends
0 people in line and wouldn't cut us any meat....very rude laughed in our faces about it.
Pizza was not very good, the staff was not friendly and the pizza was not heated up enough.
Extremely rude employees. Asked if they had any gluten free options and was laughed at & received multiple eye rolls. Disappointing especially when the North Market in general is extremely allergen friendly. Would not recommend to anyone.
Just came from here, don't know if the food is good but we ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza and the kid pulling it out of the oven let out a large burp, in my husband's face. Albeit, he was behind the counter - but we could smell that he had some Gatorade before hand. We cancelled the slice, the chef in the back looked mortified and the kid, said, "really? For an accident?" Yeah man, when we can smell snack time from some other kids guts we don't want to try the food. The kids' mother was salty when she was returning our $4.50- I only gave it two stars because of the mortification of the cook. Maybe we will try it again at some point. But not today Satan.
Worst pizza my family has ever had … Sunday labor weekend ordered a whole cheese pizza 40 minutes before market closed … got it with extra cheese but didn’t appear to have extra cheese … crust was burnt …. Cheese was burnt … had over abundance of whatever they sprinkle on it … sauce was sparse without much taste … worst pizza we’ve ever had … my family and I, when we travel always try to seek out pizza shops to try. Over the years we have never had a pizza that we just threw in the trash because it was so bad. Doesn’t even deserve one star.