This was the highlight of my trip to Columbus so far. The wings are superb, and the Buffy Mac was exactly what you want when you want a vegan indulgence. And the peanut butter pie was yummy!!
Elaine525
We got the reuben and classic with curly fries and slaw. Very fast and friendly
MidwestMuncher
This place is incredible. I’ve eaten here numerous times over the course of several years; I have quite literally eaten everything on the very large weekly menu. The horror decor/theming is great, but the food is what matters most, and it is excellent here. The food is all incredible, but I think a few standout options on the regular menu include the cheesesteak, the Notorious BBQ, the Dude Ranch, the mozzarella sticks, the jalapeño poppers, and the peanut butter pie. However, they also really shine on the creativity shone in their weekly specials/rotating options. Quite possibly the best thing I’ve had here is the anarchy crunchwrap, which consisted of two burger patties, lettuce, onion, cheese, pickles, thousand island, and a tostada all wrapped in tortilla, grilled, and served with additional thousand island. Life is beautiful, as I am continuously reminded by this restaurant. Other standout weekly options include their banh mi, their barbacoa taquitos, their Italian beef sandwich, and their beef stroganoff, to name just a few of the many amazing options here. It should also be noted that they have an incredible weekend brunch menu as well. Plenty of savory options like the chicken biscuit sandwich and biscuits & gravy, but they also have donuts if you have more of a sweet tooth. If you can think of it, this place likely has a vegan version of it, and it’s always sure to be delicious.
Updated from previous review on 2025-10-29
Katie Riedinger
Food was delicious. It's not a good value. With tip, $30 for 2 sandwiches (no fries) and 2 fountain drinks. The counter person during the afternoon of 10/23/25 didn't seem to want to be there. I wanted to love this place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Virginia Neuhauser
The food was great. Like amazing. I had the beef and cheddar and curly fries. So good!! It would be 5 stars if I hadn't had to use the restroom. I was in town for medical treatment and the restroom was down a steep flight of stairs, which I had a very difficult time navigating. But hell, I'll go back for the food. I just know I'll just have to stop off elsewhere if nature calls.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seasoned Curly Fries, Sauce
vanattaboy
I absolutely LOVED my Cain Raiser! I got some for my non-vegan brothers and they loved it too. I also loved the vibe and decor, I can’t wait to dine in!
Rhiannon Morich
We were in Columbus for 5 days and just had to eat here twice. It was incredible food, just the type of meal that warms your twisted soul. ☺️😈 The artwork was killer as well. Just a wonderful experience overall.
Chandler Moyer
my favorite vegan spot in columbus!
Evan Tribley
Excellent all vegan menu, absolutely love eating here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
suezenp
Love this place so much! Food is always top notch! Love the atmosphere! Great location! Love the horror movie memorabilia all over!
The Mac n cheese is so good but everything they serve is great!! My fave place.
Amanda Smith
This was my first time eating here and I will definitely be back. It was so nice being able to eat anything on the menu and the food was absolutely delicious. It's a bit on the pricey side, but the portions are huge and the food is great, so it's worth it. We had the Notorious BBQ and the Cheezestake. I tried both and loved them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Notorious BBQ
Tommy
My wife and I absolutely loved the food here at Seitan's Realm. It's our first time here too and we're just visiting the area, but when we come back through this place will be our first stop! I highly recommend this place to anyone in the nearby area or those who are visiting this area. 10/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Grace Lamparyk
so delicious! inside is so spooky and cool, decorated in horror movies and merch! the buffalo wings are SOOO GOOOOOD and this place is #1 for getting ur veganized traditionally animal based foods in! i love buffalo sauce and missed fried pickles, and they got both!!!!
This was the highlight of my trip to Columbus so far. The wings are superb, and the Buffy Mac was exactly what you want when you want a vegan indulgence. And the peanut butter pie was yummy!!
We got the reuben and classic with curly fries and slaw. Very fast and friendly
This place is incredible. I’ve eaten here numerous times over the course of several years; I have quite literally eaten everything on the very large weekly menu. The horror decor/theming is great, but the food is what matters most, and it is excellent here. The food is all incredible, but I think a few standout options on the regular menu include the cheesesteak, the Notorious BBQ, the Dude Ranch, the mozzarella sticks, the jalapeño poppers, and the peanut butter pie. However, they also really shine on the creativity shone in their weekly specials/rotating options. Quite possibly the best thing I’ve had here is the anarchy crunchwrap, which consisted of two burger patties, lettuce, onion, cheese, pickles, thousand island, and a tostada all wrapped in tortilla, grilled, and served with additional thousand island. Life is beautiful, as I am continuously reminded by this restaurant. Other standout weekly options include their banh mi, their barbacoa taquitos, their Italian beef sandwich, and their beef stroganoff, to name just a few of the many amazing options here. It should also be noted that they have an incredible weekend brunch menu as well. Plenty of savory options like the chicken biscuit sandwich and biscuits & gravy, but they also have donuts if you have more of a sweet tooth. If you can think of it, this place likely has a vegan version of it, and it’s always sure to be delicious. Updated from previous review on 2025-10-29
Food was delicious. It's not a good value. With tip, $30 for 2 sandwiches (no fries) and 2 fountain drinks. The counter person during the afternoon of 10/23/25 didn't seem to want to be there. I wanted to love this place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
The food was great. Like amazing. I had the beef and cheddar and curly fries. So good!! It would be 5 stars if I hadn't had to use the restroom. I was in town for medical treatment and the restroom was down a steep flight of stairs, which I had a very difficult time navigating. But hell, I'll go back for the food. I just know I'll just have to stop off elsewhere if nature calls.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seasoned Curly Fries, Sauce
I absolutely LOVED my Cain Raiser! I got some for my non-vegan brothers and they loved it too. I also loved the vibe and decor, I can’t wait to dine in!
We were in Columbus for 5 days and just had to eat here twice. It was incredible food, just the type of meal that warms your twisted soul. ☺️😈 The artwork was killer as well. Just a wonderful experience overall.
my favorite vegan spot in columbus!
Excellent all vegan menu, absolutely love eating here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place so much! Food is always top notch! Love the atmosphere! Great location! Love the horror movie memorabilia all over!
Restaurantji Recommends
The Mac n cheese is so good but everything they serve is great!! My fave place.
This was my first time eating here and I will definitely be back. It was so nice being able to eat anything on the menu and the food was absolutely delicious. It's a bit on the pricey side, but the portions are huge and the food is great, so it's worth it. We had the Notorious BBQ and the Cheezestake. I tried both and loved them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Notorious BBQ
My wife and I absolutely loved the food here at Seitan's Realm. It's our first time here too and we're just visiting the area, but when we come back through this place will be our first stop! I highly recommend this place to anyone in the nearby area or those who are visiting this area. 10/10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
so delicious! inside is so spooky and cool, decorated in horror movies and merch! the buffalo wings are SOOO GOOOOOD and this place is #1 for getting ur veganized traditionally animal based foods in! i love buffalo sauce and missed fried pickles, and they got both!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cool little theme restaurant 😎
Food was decent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...