Sexton's Pizza
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
This place what makes it bad is the workers, front guy at counter, uses phone and takes his sweet time. Called in for pick up and i took while to get to the location almost 30 minutes so that when i get there my food will be ready to go, when i got there they didnt even start to make my order, he forgot about it and i had to wait another 30 minutes. The pizza turned out to be bad because he rushed it. I will not recommend this place.
Had heard great things and was really disappointed . . .
Ordered three times from Harrison West location:
1. As soon as I picked up, the girl working there (super nice) immediately apologized and told me that the pizza was burned and gave me a gift card because it was the end of the night and too late to make another pizza. The pizza was a little burned, but by no means would I have complained. I thought it was pretty good! Zero complaints about this order . . . mistakes happen.
2. Happily tried them again . . . staff couldn't be bothered to help (whatever, teenagers . . .), but when I got home I realized the pizza was REALLY burned. Major bummer.
3. Walked in and staff walks away, call out your name and they sigh, eye roll and turn around just to dramatically hand you a pizza that's already paid for . . . you literally just have to hand the customer a box. Half the pizza was burned and barely any sauce.
Bad service at a takeout pizza place, whatever . . . you want to miserable at work, that's on you.
Consistently being unable to make a not burned pizza is another issue.
Food is good no complaints there. Service is horrible. we ordered takeout and we waited a hr longer for a pizza then the time they told us. . They gave us a 30.00 gift card to make up for it. Great Right??? we gave the gift card to my daughter who just had her second child. she ordered a pizza drove over to pick it up only to be informed the gift card was for dine in only. she paid for the pizza and as shes leaving with pizza and my grandaughter in her hands the staff just stands there and watches her. i will never give one dollar to this place ever again . The one bite review has gone to there head . Pizzas good but i will take little ceasers over a place that could care less about its customers
Service: 1
okay here's what went down when I came in here the other day, I walk in and there's a teenager eating a pizza at the register. I ignore it and order a Kevin bacon which didn't even come with the drizzle it was said to come with, and it was so burnt. the only reason I am giving this place more than one star is because they had this hot white boy working at the time and I had to do everything in my power to not ask for his number or even a name but give that man a raise he makes the whole atmosphere just way better
Delicious pizza!!! The crust was amazing, and the cheese and topping ratio and taste were perfect. It's a little bit hard to find because there's just a small neon sign in the window and no big sign on the building. I circled the block a couple of times with my GPS yelling at me before I saw it. It's in the same plaza as the drive through alcohol place. I will get pizza from here again and soon.
Pizza was really good! Only 1 star off because it was kinda burnt.
Best pizza in Columbus. Great staff and up beat vibes.
Okay, so the pizza is amazing. There’s no debating that. It did take 1 1/2 hours for the single pie to be ready. It was delicious. It was $25. Amazing pizza. 1 1/2 hour wait. $25.
Probably won’t order again, but will always tell people it’s delicious.
Staff was rude. Pizza was burnt. Had to wait 15 minutes longer than expected
I am a truck driver and ordered to the rest area on 33 through uber eats. This pizza is fuggin AWESOME. I will make a special trip to your physical location to get it hot and fresh sometime. Thanks for making excellent pizza!
Restaurantji Recommends
Their excuse for Detroit Pizza must be from Detroit Minnesota. Not even close to real Detroit pizza, terrible. This place should thank the lord for Dave Portnoy, he must have had a really bad cold when he rated this place. You're better off buying a frozen pizza from the grocery store and staying home.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Had high hopes for this place and looked really good online I was more than looking forward to getting good authentic pizza and was sad when I had my first bite of the NY East Village style. It was one of the WORST pizzas I've EVER had in my life. The fact Dave gave them a 8.1 is mind blowing! Will not be back.
Food: 1
Best pizza in the city for sure. Placed order earlier in the day and was ready right on time. Would be nice if they offered more than one size though
It's good pizza, NY style crust. It's for take out, who needs atmosphere?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great crust because that’s about all we got. Almost no toppings and one in our order that wasn’t even on the pizza. Absolutely a terrible value and I will never order it again nor suggest anyone else should. Don’t believe their rankings
Food: 1
Loading...