The pizza is fantastic. Thin crust, crispy good char on the bottom. Lives up to its 8.1 ranking on the Portnoy scale. The bar, service and vibe at Hilliard location is excellent. Gahanna location has a few tables and two beers on tap more of a pick up location.
Lucas Gerken
Pizza is great, what would be even greater is if they were ever open/accepting orders during their posted business hours.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Lee Mueller
Pizza is okay. Service is below expectations.
Food: 3
Service: 2
Lala
Pregnant and constantly craving pizza. I have been eating my way through the city and Sexton’s is by far is my favorite in regard to NY-style.Staff was super friendly and worked efficiently.As a New Yorker my pizza standards are high and I will become a regular :)Thank you for giving me a little piece of home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 16 Pepperoni
Michael Anthony aka Tony Tanner
Awesome pizza. Hilliard store has seating and a great bar. Be sure to get bacon on the pizza - supplied by us at The Butcher & Grocer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Stephenson
This is my favorite local Place in Columbus. Definitely should give it a try if you live in the area. The Candied Bacon is really
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 16 Kevin Bacon
M
Pizza was mostly burnt, they should turn the heat down for the dough type. Dough needs crust flavor, very bland and dry. Ordering was not well set up. Website needs professional set up/not user friendly. Phone number not available on google or site.. almost didn’t order. Website doesn’t show all toppings like veggies. No drinks at a pizza shop? Also floors dirty. Overall pizza was okay, nothing to write home about.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
megan boyce
I had a truly unpleasant experience with Sextons despite the raving review from Dave Portnoy. My boyfriend found a screw in his pizza, which is completely unacceptable. This not only ruined our meal but also raised serious health and safety concerns. I hope the restaurant takes immediate action to prevent such incidents in the future. I cannot recommend this place based on this disturbing experience.
Ryle
Although a very limited menu in comparison to their Hilliard location with the pizza offering being solely a 16" cheese, pepperoni, & banana peppers it is still at the top if not the best pizza in the Short North. Slightly sweet sauce, quality pepperoni that shows, and a slightly charred crust that puts it over the top.Parking: If picking up there's a free lot right out front.
For anyone who visited when this outpost first opened and they only had cheese or pepperoni pizzas for sale, you need to come back. They've added the Kevin Bacon and 614 to the menu! These 16 inch pizzas are perfect for two. The 614 had no shortage of toppings, perfect thinnish crust and everything tasted great. I'm coming for you next, Kevin Bacon!
l l
Owner was cute, and I don't wanna be the one to end their five star streak.
Sazid Hasan
Great pizza! Dave sent me here 8.2/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ranch Jar
Jonathan Toland
All the other reviews are accurate, this is the best pizza in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ash Taghavi
Easily the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus. Just by the quality and service it is noticeably different to the other pizzerias.
The pizza is fantastic. Thin crust, crispy good char on the bottom. Lives up to its 8.1 ranking on the Portnoy scale. The bar, service and vibe at Hilliard location is excellent. Gahanna location has a few tables and two beers on tap more of a pick up location.
Pizza is great, what would be even greater is if they were ever open/accepting orders during their posted business hours.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Pizza is okay. Service is below expectations.
Food: 3
Service: 2
Pregnant and constantly craving pizza. I have been eating my way through the city and Sexton’s is by far is my favorite in regard to NY-style.Staff was super friendly and worked efficiently.As a New Yorker my pizza standards are high and I will become a regular :)Thank you for giving me a little piece of home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 16 Pepperoni
Awesome pizza. Hilliard store has seating and a great bar. Be sure to get bacon on the pizza - supplied by us at The Butcher & Grocer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my favorite local Place in Columbus. Definitely should give it a try if you live in the area. The Candied Bacon is really
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 16 Kevin Bacon
Pizza was mostly burnt, they should turn the heat down for the dough type. Dough needs crust flavor, very bland and dry. Ordering was not well set up. Website needs professional set up/not user friendly. Phone number not available on google or site.. almost didn’t order. Website doesn’t show all toppings like veggies. No drinks at a pizza shop? Also floors dirty. Overall pizza was okay, nothing to write home about.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
I had a truly unpleasant experience with Sextons despite the raving review from Dave Portnoy. My boyfriend found a screw in his pizza, which is completely unacceptable. This not only ruined our meal but also raised serious health and safety concerns. I hope the restaurant takes immediate action to prevent such incidents in the future. I cannot recommend this place based on this disturbing experience.
Although a very limited menu in comparison to their Hilliard location with the pizza offering being solely a 16" cheese, pepperoni, & banana peppers it is still at the top if not the best pizza in the Short North. Slightly sweet sauce, quality pepperoni that shows, and a slightly charred crust that puts it over the top.Parking: If picking up there's a free lot right out front.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absurd that this is sent out.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
For anyone who visited when this outpost first opened and they only had cheese or pepperoni pizzas for sale, you need to come back. They've added the Kevin Bacon and 614 to the menu! These 16 inch pizzas are perfect for two. The 614 had no shortage of toppings, perfect thinnish crust and everything tasted great. I'm coming for you next, Kevin Bacon!
Owner was cute, and I don't wanna be the one to end their five star streak.
Great pizza! Dave sent me here 8.2/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ranch Jar
All the other reviews are accurate, this is the best pizza in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Easily the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus. Just by the quality and service it is noticeably different to the other pizzerias.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Sauce