The Buckeye Lady and her team are amazing women who make magical buckeyes and support their community. The variety of buckeyes is mind blowing and she offers vegan options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
chad whitney
What can I say? Seriously, what can I say? I'm just gonna say it. Delicious! Respect to the Buckeye Lady.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole B.
These buckeyes are out of this world! Unexpected flavor combinations that will keep you going back for more! They are the perfect special little treat to share with family, friends, work colleague, caregivers.... anyone! I'm always looking for an excuse to go back here LOL! The last time I was there I got to meet Alicia, The Buckeye Lady herself, and she expressed such gratitude for my support. I'm a customer for life!
Marc R
Stopped in today after passing the store on the way to grab some chipotle next door and decided to drop in to check it out. I got the 6 pack, and i just ate the red velvet buckeye, and it was incredible! If I work in the area again I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Lemmon
These buckeyes are absolutely fantastic! My favorite flavors are the Black Raspberry Cheesecake and Italian Rainbow Cake. I am sure you can see by some of the container being empty (before we even left the lot) that me and my family enjoyed them. We are looking forward to coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Macklehaney C.
Amazing assortment of Buckeye flavors. Great service too! Will definitely try it again!
Tom Sappington
Best Buckeyes in the State of Ohio. The traditional and the bourbon are OMG!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Dotson
Absolutely delicious!!! Out of town and wanted to try a buckeye. The bartender at a restaurant suggested we try this place. So many flavors and they were all so good. Sweetest lady helped us out too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Kim
I never had a buckeye, but if you love peanut butter then this is the place!! We bought four of them and they were all delicious!!!!! Definitely recommend. Also the shop attendant was very polite as well.
Kyle W.
These are the BEST buckeyes in Columbus without a doubt. The staff is very sweet and part of the money goes to a great cause.
She is not kidding when she says she is the buckeye lady! My mom and aunt were visiting from out of town and I knew I needed to stop here and get some buckeyes. The amount of different fillings she has is just amazing. You wouldn't think that all of these different flavors would mesh well with peanut butter, but they really do. I wish I had more of the chai ones - they might be my new favorite! I make buckeyes at Christmas time but they are nothing like these! If you are on the fence about trying them out, get off the fence and run to the store, you won't regret it!
Marissa C.
We've been spoiled by The Buckeye Lady carts showing up at farmers markets around town and getting our fix that way, but we finally made our way into the cute little storefront they now have! I wanted to share the goodness with some friends and family and opted to pick up the tailgate dozen to share - it was a nice collection featuring six traditional buckeyes with scarlet and gray sprinkles and six puppy chow buckeyes. They were much enjoyed! Little Yelper couldn't resist getting some cheesecake buckeyes for home, which were a huge winner and will definitely be a variety we will be getting again.
Sara Jo Hobson
Very nice owner. Buckeyes are amazing worth a trip there. Lots to choose from I highly recommend trying them out .
Rachael Lewis
Always love their buckeyes! I love the rotating flavors. Recently ordered some platters for my wedding dessert grazing table and they were gone in minutes. The number one question we got asked at the wedding and since was where the buckeyes were from. Happily gave them the Buckeye Lady name. Will definitely order again!
C V
Exceeded expectations! The cheesecake was my favorite. Lots of gluten free options, and some vegan buckeyes.
The Buckeye Lady and her team are amazing women who make magical buckeyes and support their community. The variety of buckeyes is mind blowing and she offers vegan options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What can I say? Seriously, what can I say? I'm just gonna say it. Delicious! Respect to the Buckeye Lady.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
These buckeyes are out of this world! Unexpected flavor combinations that will keep you going back for more! They are the perfect special little treat to share with family, friends, work colleague, caregivers.... anyone! I'm always looking for an excuse to go back here LOL! The last time I was there I got to meet Alicia, The Buckeye Lady herself, and she expressed such gratitude for my support. I'm a customer for life!
Stopped in today after passing the store on the way to grab some chipotle next door and decided to drop in to check it out. I got the 6 pack, and i just ate the red velvet buckeye, and it was incredible! If I work in the area again I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
These buckeyes are absolutely fantastic! My favorite flavors are the Black Raspberry Cheesecake and Italian Rainbow Cake. I am sure you can see by some of the container being empty (before we even left the lot) that me and my family enjoyed them. We are looking forward to coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing assortment of Buckeye flavors. Great service too! Will definitely try it again!
Best Buckeyes in the State of Ohio. The traditional and the bourbon are OMG!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious!!! Out of town and wanted to try a buckeye. The bartender at a restaurant suggested we try this place. So many flavors and they were all so good. Sweetest lady helped us out too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I never had a buckeye, but if you love peanut butter then this is the place!! We bought four of them and they were all delicious!!!!! Definitely recommend. Also the shop attendant was very polite as well.
These are the BEST buckeyes in Columbus without a doubt. The staff is very sweet and part of the money goes to a great cause.
Restaurantji Recommends
She is not kidding when she says she is the buckeye lady! My mom and aunt were visiting from out of town and I knew I needed to stop here and get some buckeyes. The amount of different fillings she has is just amazing. You wouldn't think that all of these different flavors would mesh well with peanut butter, but they really do. I wish I had more of the chai ones - they might be my new favorite! I make buckeyes at Christmas time but they are nothing like these! If you are on the fence about trying them out, get off the fence and run to the store, you won't regret it!
We've been spoiled by The Buckeye Lady carts showing up at farmers markets around town and getting our fix that way, but we finally made our way into the cute little storefront they now have! I wanted to share the goodness with some friends and family and opted to pick up the tailgate dozen to share - it was a nice collection featuring six traditional buckeyes with scarlet and gray sprinkles and six puppy chow buckeyes. They were much enjoyed! Little Yelper couldn't resist getting some cheesecake buckeyes for home, which were a huge winner and will definitely be a variety we will be getting again.
Very nice owner. Buckeyes are amazing worth a trip there. Lots to choose from I highly recommend trying them out .
Always love their buckeyes! I love the rotating flavors. Recently ordered some platters for my wedding dessert grazing table and they were gone in minutes. The number one question we got asked at the wedding and since was where the buckeyes were from. Happily gave them the Buckeye Lady name. Will definitely order again!
Exceeded expectations! The cheesecake was my favorite. Lots of gluten free options, and some vegan buckeyes.