Tony's has been our 'go to' Italian spot downtown for many years. Tried the steak special, which was excellent and cooked to medium rare perfection. Loved the garlic bread and wedding soup, too.
Eric
Food was very good and such a good value for the quality of the atmosphere and ingredients. The pesto was flavorful without overpowering everything else. The Alfredo sauce did what it should do which is add texture and flavor without overpowering the chicken or pasta (tortellini). The wife said the shrimp was plump and juicy. Hard to believe their prices with the quality of everything you get for every one of the 5 senses. Wide variety of wine selections.
leb
Tony’s is a wonderful place to eat if you’re feeling fancy and want to be downtown. It’s located right off of Broad Street, but it doesn’t feel too too crowded or busy. We were part of a wedding party and everything was prepared beautifully and the service was excellent. Tony himself was there to greet us and take care of everything we needed. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan
Always a pleasure dining here love the atmosphere and Tony is always greeting people. Food, service etc is always stellar!
Jo Ellen
Everything was fantastic from the time we entered the restaurant, to the server, the food. Fantastic!
Ardi
Overall experience was quite enjoyable. The pasta dishes and the Salmon were flavorful and well-prepared, and the sides complemented the mains beautifully.
Unfortunately, I found the lasagna’s flavor did not resonate as I had anticipated, it was dry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Baylee Walling
My partner and I tried Tony's Italian Ristorante for the first time last night. The service was excellent, and our waitress was amazing. She went above and beyond to make our experience the very best it could be. We tried the sausage pasta and chicken Marsala. Both of us really enjoyed our meals. The atmosphere is very relaxing and beautiful. The interior is stunning. We were encouraged to sit and enjoy the atmosphere, food, and each others company. These are the kinds places I love to go for date nights. On top of everything, they have designated parking for the restaurant. We will definitely be coming back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Bowers
Great food and service!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandra
Food was good maybe a little too much Salt. Atmosphere was pleasant and service was really good
Traci
Wonderful service and classic Italian vibe. Food was good but we did not like it as well as some of our other favorites around town. Personal preference, maybe. Spaghetti was better than the lasagna, which seemed out of balance with too much meat and the pasta in the middle was a bit mushy. Definitely willing to go back and find something more to my taste.
Tony's was great. Excellent food and great service. The host even pulled the chair out for my daughter. I would go again.
Marla
Enjoyed a wonderful dinner with friends at Tony's Ristorante this weekend. We were all very well pleased with the overall dining experience. We will return. We felt very catered to by Chuck and Tony. Thank you.
Michael
The waiter - never intro's himself so I don't know his name. Not very friendly and everything seemed to bother him, he may as well rolled his eyes when we asked for anything. The 1 dinner roll sliced into 4 pieces was a nice touch (sarcasm).
Beth
Tony's has been in Columbus for 43 years, so they must be doing something right! It was our first visit, and we had a lovely evening- food, atmosphere, but our server Lorenz made it an exceptional night. We visit our daughter regularly and we are now adding Tony's to our list of local favorites.
Kylie
Great overall experience. Friendly, welcoming staff, attentive waiter, phenomenal food (for reference my husband got the chicken parmesean and I got the salmon). There were a few small things that could have been better, but for the quality of the entrees, the ambiance, and the staff, we had a very nice time and would definitely go here again if ever back in the area
Tony's has been our 'go to' Italian spot downtown for many years. Tried the steak special, which was excellent and cooked to medium rare perfection. Loved the garlic bread and wedding soup, too.
Food was very good and such a good value for the quality of the atmosphere and ingredients. The pesto was flavorful without overpowering everything else. The Alfredo sauce did what it should do which is add texture and flavor without overpowering the chicken or pasta (tortellini). The wife said the shrimp was plump and juicy. Hard to believe their prices with the quality of everything you get for every one of the 5 senses. Wide variety of wine selections.
Tony’s is a wonderful place to eat if you’re feeling fancy and want to be downtown. It’s located right off of Broad Street, but it doesn’t feel too too crowded or busy. We were part of a wedding party and everything was prepared beautifully and the service was excellent. Tony himself was there to greet us and take care of everything we needed. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a pleasure dining here love the atmosphere and Tony is always greeting people. Food, service etc is always stellar!
Everything was fantastic from the time we entered the restaurant, to the server, the food. Fantastic!
Overall experience was quite enjoyable. The pasta dishes and the Salmon were flavorful and well-prepared, and the sides complemented the mains beautifully.
Unfortunately, I found the lasagna’s flavor did not resonate as I had anticipated, it was dry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
My partner and I tried Tony's Italian Ristorante for the first time last night. The service was excellent, and our waitress was amazing. She went above and beyond to make our experience the very best it could be. We tried the sausage pasta and chicken Marsala. Both of us really enjoyed our meals. The atmosphere is very relaxing and beautiful. The interior is stunning. We were encouraged to sit and enjoy the atmosphere, food, and each others company. These are the kinds places I love to go for date nights. On top of everything, they have designated parking for the restaurant. We will definitely be coming back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and service!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was good maybe a little too much Salt. Atmosphere was pleasant and service was really good
Wonderful service and classic Italian vibe. Food was good but we did not like it as well as some of our other favorites around town. Personal preference, maybe. Spaghetti was better than the lasagna, which seemed out of balance with too much meat and the pasta in the middle was a bit mushy. Definitely willing to go back and find something more to my taste.
Restaurantji Recommends
Tony's was great. Excellent food and great service. The host even pulled the chair out for my daughter. I would go again.
Enjoyed a wonderful dinner with friends at Tony's Ristorante this weekend. We were all very well pleased with the overall dining experience. We will return. We felt very catered to by Chuck and Tony. Thank you.
The waiter - never intro's himself so I don't know his name. Not very friendly and everything seemed to bother him, he may as well rolled his eyes when we asked for anything. The 1 dinner roll sliced into 4 pieces was a nice touch (sarcasm).
Tony's has been in Columbus for 43 years, so they must be doing something right! It was our first visit, and we had a lovely evening- food, atmosphere, but our server Lorenz made it an exceptional night. We visit our daughter regularly and we are now adding Tony's to our list of local favorites.
Great overall experience. Friendly, welcoming staff, attentive waiter, phenomenal food (for reference my husband got the chicken parmesean and I got the salmon). There were a few small things that could have been better, but for the quality of the entrees, the ambiance, and the staff, we had a very nice time and would definitely go here again if ever back in the area
Loading...