Yellow Brick

212 Kelton Ave, Columbus
(614) 725-5482

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Clear Water Prowash

Very expensive but good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jill Frost

Didn't get to try the pizza. After the scolding I received for not knowing their process for baking and serving slices of pizza, I opted not to eat here. Not interested.

Brionna Mendoza

Always delicious!

Nomadic Flavors

Dave Portnoy would be disappointed in this place. A score of 53

Nathan Rohner

Great pizza and awesome flavors. The kids loved it too.

Jeff Gaither

Pizza is delicious New York style, and staff are friendly and care about their customers. My order was scheduled to be ready at closing time, but the ched expected I might be there early and had it ready at 9:50, cooked extra crispy as requested. These folks take pride in their pizza, and you can taste the difference.

Ryan Laganson

Food is pretty consistent and tasty, however they are often out of pizza by the slice on weekends.

Fawn Marie

Pizza was just ok . They were out of everything

Brina D

This establishment has been one of my favorites for the past 10 years when they were originally located on Oak street. Yellow Brick Pizza is now located in the East Market Food Hall off of Kelton Avenue. This pizzeria is known for its large NY style pizza slices and signature hand-tossed pizzas with amazing flavors.

I was strolling through trying to decide what to eat when I noticed a savory smell of cheese and pepperoni. There was a fresh pizza coming out of the oven. The pizzas are pretty much cooked to order but single slices are offered as well for $5.

I was with my best friend at the time and as you can see from the picture, she dug right in! This is a great spot to grab lunch or dinner when you’re in the mood for authentic pizza.

Jeff F

No idea how the food is and I never will. Ordered delivery (90 minute delivery time) and 3 minutes before it was supposed to be delivered they texted saying it was ready, an hour later, still no calzone. They don't answer the phone and Toast Tab is no help. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE! THEY SUCK!

David Antonucci

Service was good. Piazza was ok for the price. A fresher slice would have been nice. I could taste that they use frozen dough and not freshly made. I would give it a 6.5 out of 10 score.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Zachary Jessup

I have never been disappointed by the pizza here, it's great, and easy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 10 the Elliot

luv huh

We frequented the original location, and I mentioned an unforgettably delicious pizza called 'the big O' to the man taking my order. He offered to make one, said it's not on the menu, but they still make it, which made my day. fantastic!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 14 Build Your Own Pizza

Josh Plandowski

This was easily the best pizza I've ever had. The flavor was impeccable!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D W

I love the pizza! The prices are reasonable too. I miss when they had pinball machines at their original location in old town east.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...