Well worth the walk from the hotel. Good pizza, cool staff, chill tunes. You do NOT get shorted on the toppings here. Good experience all around. Recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jesse Brandow
I was very disappointed by the bottom crust of the pizza, which was limp and floppy. The photos made me excited to try this restaurant, hoping for a slightly crispy crust similar to what you get from a brick oven pizza. Nope! It’s so limp that I couldn’t even pick up a slice without it falling down and toppings spilling off. I also was put off by some of the toppings, especially the chicken chunks which were **dark** meat pieces that even had some pieces of cartilage mixed in! Are they using the chicken pizzas as a way to not waste unwanted chicken?? Overall a disappointing experience, sadly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Tim Haggerty
My favorite specialty pizza place. A little higher than I can afford regularly but well worth the price. Service has always been good and I love the new location more than the old one. They put some thought into the atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
maegan higgins
Hannah is the best. She deserves a raise and all her flowers. She’s so fun and the best server i’ve ever had. Will come here again just to see her because she’s amazing! Food was great too :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tobias Stoneking
Came here with family, it took about 40 mins for 1, 10 inch and 2, 14 inch pizzas. The food was phenomenal and unique. I ordered the dragon and both my eyes and tastebuds were pleased.Server had a spill on the table but was very polite and considerate. Overall a great spot that also has parking nearby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Alexandra Farnlacher
Some of the worst pizza I have had in Columbus. Pizza was an oily, greasy mess. We got red sauce on it and there was hardly any on our pizza. Cheese was tough, thick, and congealed. All together, the pizza had no flavor. For a $30 pizza, I was incredibly disappointed. My husband and I ate two slices of a 16inch pizza and ended up throwing the whole thing away. Save your money and go literally anywhere else
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Martha
YellowBrick Pizza on Rich St, Columbus, OH is a great place to enjoy unique combination pizzas or traditional. Good street parking, make sure you use the app and pay for parking. Also Art Galleries and some shops to explore!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian VanTilburg
I was craving a Chicago deep dish pizza & didn't want to drive all the way to Giordanos, so I did a search & it gave me this place. I'm glad it did. The pizza was amazing. I hadn't heard of this place & plan on coming back to dine in. The bartender who helped me was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Digit
Okay, they genuinely earned this good review. Hard.
I ordered a door dash. About 50 minutes later, a dasher arrives with the wrong order. I didn't notice right away because there was a pizza and a large garlic... something that I thought was mine. 30 seconds later, I realized it was wrong and called Door Dash who wanted to do very little. Door Dash doesn't have a big office with folks taking phone calls, so I was PISSED. Called this location to complain and was STILL pissed.
Threw everything in the car which is what I was trying to avoid since it was late in the day, and drove over to the Rich St one (the one I ordered from over at the Trolly closed for the day while it was being delivered). A manager came up and I started yelling. Hell, I would've started throwing napkins and straws and whatnot. But I encountered a decent manager that did everything he could to calm me down. I did because it was nice to have a person talking to me rationally after a long day.
He asks what my order was, lets me know he'll get it all taken care of. He did!
As for the food? FABULOUS. Large pizza, pie style cut with a thin crust (neapolitan style), well cooked, and a garlic bread. All of it quite worthy. I should go here more often, and given their attitudes and incredibly professional demeanor while looking quite casual is the type of local shop that deserves infinite respect!!
Sorry for giving anyone here a bad experience, and thank you endlessly for handling the Door Dash mistake with utmost respect and care. This is a business that is ready to do business. If it ain't right, they will strive to make it right! Classy, and damn good pizza.
Kitchen was behind both times I've ordered. The short guy bartender was rude and dismissive both times I've gone. First time I ever tried Chicago style pizza and it was about 80% cheese. Gross. Garlic knots were swimming in a literal pool of butter with little chunks of garlic. Calzone was good albeit very cheesy. Pizza was good! Ingredients are good quality in general. None of it was worth the money but that's what coupons are for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Fritz Shook
Legendary garlic knots. I tried a pizza with the worst possible topping combination ever and it was still delicious. Will be ordering from there again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Milo
One of the best pizza joints in Columbus, no doubt. Staff is beyond friendly- genuinely treated me like they’ve known me for years. The food is BOMB. Like Pearl Harbour level. Best pizza i’ve had in Columbus in a long time. The garlic knots had me reverting to Catholicism, shit was so heavenly. The place is so well put together & organized, clean, and chill. Felt like I could have a great time with a group, or enjoy a calm meal by myself. If you’re gonna eat anywhere, let it be here 10000%
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gae_cheems
this place is awesome and has a variety of toppings for your insatiable need of corned beef on pizza 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Rowan M.
genuinely super awesome amazing pizza and the workers are awesome 10/10 would recommend :3
Great food and friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Well worth the walk from the hotel. Good pizza, cool staff, chill tunes. You do NOT get shorted on the toppings here. Good experience all around. Recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was very disappointed by the bottom crust of the pizza, which was limp and floppy. The photos made me excited to try this restaurant, hoping for a slightly crispy crust similar to what you get from a brick oven pizza. Nope! It’s so limp that I couldn’t even pick up a slice without it falling down and toppings spilling off. I also was put off by some of the toppings, especially the chicken chunks which were **dark** meat pieces that even had some pieces of cartilage mixed in! Are they using the chicken pizzas as a way to not waste unwanted chicken?? Overall a disappointing experience, sadly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
My favorite specialty pizza place. A little higher than I can afford regularly but well worth the price. Service has always been good and I love the new location more than the old one. They put some thought into the atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hannah is the best. She deserves a raise and all her flowers. She’s so fun and the best server i’ve ever had. Will come here again just to see her because she’s amazing! Food was great too :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came here with family, it took about 40 mins for 1, 10 inch and 2, 14 inch pizzas. The food was phenomenal and unique. I ordered the dragon and both my eyes and tastebuds were pleased.Server had a spill on the table but was very polite and considerate. Overall a great spot that also has parking nearby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Some of the worst pizza I have had in Columbus. Pizza was an oily, greasy mess. We got red sauce on it and there was hardly any on our pizza. Cheese was tough, thick, and congealed. All together, the pizza had no flavor. For a $30 pizza, I was incredibly disappointed. My husband and I ate two slices of a 16inch pizza and ended up throwing the whole thing away. Save your money and go literally anywhere else
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
YellowBrick Pizza on Rich St, Columbus, OH is a great place to enjoy unique combination pizzas or traditional. Good street parking, make sure you use the app and pay for parking. Also Art Galleries and some shops to explore!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was craving a Chicago deep dish pizza & didn't want to drive all the way to Giordanos, so I did a search & it gave me this place. I'm glad it did. The pizza was amazing. I hadn't heard of this place & plan on coming back to dine in. The bartender who helped me was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Okay, they genuinely earned this good review. Hard.
I ordered a door dash. About 50 minutes later, a dasher arrives with the wrong order. I didn't notice right away because there was a pizza and a large garlic... something that I thought was mine. 30 seconds later, I realized it was wrong and called Door Dash who wanted to do very little. Door Dash doesn't have a big office with folks taking phone calls, so I was PISSED. Called this location to complain and was STILL pissed.
Threw everything in the car which is what I was trying to avoid since it was late in the day, and drove over to the Rich St one (the one I ordered from over at the Trolly closed for the day while it was being delivered). A manager came up and I started yelling. Hell, I would've started throwing napkins and straws and whatnot. But I encountered a decent manager that did everything he could to calm me down. I did because it was nice to have a person talking to me rationally after a long day.
He asks what my order was, lets me know he'll get it all taken care of. He did!
As for the food? FABULOUS. Large pizza, pie style cut with a thin crust (neapolitan style), well cooked, and a garlic bread. All of it quite worthy. I should go here more often, and given their attitudes and incredibly professional demeanor while looking quite casual is the type of local shop that deserves infinite respect!!
Sorry for giving anyone here a bad experience, and thank you endlessly for handling the Door Dash mistake with utmost respect and care. This is a business that is ready to do business. If it ain't right, they will strive to make it right! Classy, and damn good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Kitchen was behind both times I've ordered. The short guy bartender was rude and dismissive both times I've gone. First time I ever tried Chicago style pizza and it was about 80% cheese. Gross. Garlic knots were swimming in a literal pool of butter with little chunks of garlic. Calzone was good albeit very cheesy. Pizza was good! Ingredients are good quality in general. None of it was worth the money but that's what coupons are for.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Legendary garlic knots. I tried a pizza with the worst possible topping combination ever and it was still delicious. Will be ordering from there again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
One of the best pizza joints in Columbus, no doubt. Staff is beyond friendly- genuinely treated me like they’ve known me for years. The food is BOMB. Like Pearl Harbour level. Best pizza i’ve had in Columbus in a long time. The garlic knots had me reverting to Catholicism, shit was so heavenly. The place is so well put together & organized, clean, and chill. Felt like I could have a great time with a group, or enjoy a calm meal by myself. If you’re gonna eat anywhere, let it be here 10000%
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
this place is awesome and has a variety of toppings for your insatiable need of corned beef on pizza 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
genuinely super awesome amazing pizza and the workers are awesome 10/10 would recommend :3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...