Heavenly Creamery

264 Sandusky St, Conneaut
(440) 593-6080

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Sweet Corn Ice Cream with Raspberry Swirl

Color Changing Dish of Ice Cream

Apple Turnover Sunday

Mango Habanero

Ginger Snap

Strawberry

Cheesecake

Large Cone

Cannoli

Gelato

Photos

+33 photos

+32 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I was visiting my sister's family down in PA with my mom and they decided to take us to Heavenly Creamery just across the border into Ohio. First off, it's a very cool renovation of an older church and it still has an altar area and stained glass, as you can see in some of the photos. I'd rather see a building get used and serve a purpose than slowing decaying and becoming a dilapidated eyesore. The interior itself was clean and had a ma and pop feel to it.

The...

July 2025

They have the best ice cream, hands down. Unique, delicious flavors. Always great service. I’m counting down the days til July so I can get more of their corn & raspberry flavor and my teen is obsessed with cereal milk. So glad to have them!

September 2024

The ice cream is great. So many choices. However the customer service from Ava and Sydney were TOP NOTCH. it has been awhile since I've witnessed service above and beyond like that (probably pre pandemic) these ladies were helpful and friendly to each customer. They were just genuinely happy people. Making awesome suggestions to people, helping them to choose items, offering other item suggestions. The owner should be very proud.

August 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Conneaut, OH

Heavenly Creamery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Heavenly Creamery