12 Best American Restaurants near Crestline

“Great atmosphere. The staff is very friendly and efficient. They have good food, and book live music every weekend. We enjoy this place!“

“Very nice place. However I had to wait for over an hour for an omelette. It appears to me that the kitchen is the problem, they have plenty of wait staff, but I got a peek into the kitchen and I saw only 4 workers in there. Not matter how good the food is, if the customer doesn’t get it in a reasonable amount of time, then the whole place suffers from poor service. I don’t think I will ever be going back there again anytime soon.“

“This is my new favorite place for the wine, cocktails, and all the food is amazing! My husband and I will definitely be returning!“

“No wait time, friendly service, and our food was cooked correctly. We see no reason for a low review!“

“Great service. Fun atmosphere. A great place to have a drink with friends.“

“I know it is hard working on Christmas but when you make reservations you expect to be seated at your reservation time. When bringing up my party had waited over 20mins over our reservation time, and seeing another party who had just come in be seated, I was told by the hostess with an attitude that they couldn't keep up with times and which party should be seated before the other! When being seated we waited over an hour for food, steak was over cooked, lobsters and baked potatoes cold and seafood boil too spicy. When we told the waitress the seafood boil was too spicy we were told that maybe next time we should stick to the no spice level and the order could not be fixed. My son ended up not eating the seafood boil. This was a bad Christmas food experience, never will dine at Red Lobster on a holiday!“

“Everything I have had here is amazing! 🤩 The cheese wedges and macaroni bites are out of this world same goes for their ranch dressing. The young man who served us last was wonderful very polite and kept checking on us A+ to the server! The chicken strips were a little less meaty and the coating a lot more crunchy than I like, but to each their own. Hand cut fries were good 👍“

“Food so good“

“I love having my kiddos parties here. They set up. They tear down. They treat you like family. Cupcakes are always amazing and pizza was awesome! Can’t wait to come back!“

“My buddy and I stopped in on a Friday evening to have the fish n fries and were not disappointed. We sat at the bar and it turned out, the company in the bar was as friendly as the staff. The fish dinner was spot-on fries and all, and at a good value. I'll certainly be going back for more before too long. Jay“

“First time going and everyone is work with told me about this place being better than Texas roadhouse. Well let me tell you it is by far better. People are vary polite. Food came out fast and hot. New York strip 14oz with bubba's Texas rice and salad was amazing. Keep up the good work I will definitely be coming back. Oh yeah my wife and I was there for our anniversary dinner. Well worth the price.“

“We got to this restaurant frequently and the service is always good and the food is usually delicious .
Today (11/25/2025 @ around 7:40 was in the order was placed) we ordered a to go order, and since we had never had an issue until tonight. My daughter gives us our food (we live in Galion) and the wings are way over cooked. When my husband opened his box you could SMELL the burnt.

However, when I called the manager was very nice, understanding and offered me a refund. I declined the refund and requested to have the wings remade and we would bring back the food (minus the 1 my husband attempted to eat. No clue why he tried with the smell, but whatever)
When we got there, this blonde haired lady came out with a to go bag ready for us, she even had them remake our fries.
I gave her our old order and she apologized and was friendly!
To me the staff making it right (remaking the food) was so much better and the best possible customer service option (in my opinion)

I will come back here, not because we love the food (we do) but because the staff was super friendly and willing to acknowledge a mistake made and they made it right by remaking the food.“