Mehaffies Pies
$ • BakeryAbout Mehaffies Pies
Customers' Favorites
Cheesecake on a Stick
Strawberry Rhubarb
Fresh Strawberry
Sweet Potato Pie
Sugar Cream Pie
Strawberry Pie
Lemon Meringue
Chocolate Chip
Pie Selection
Apple Crunch
Mehaffies Pies Reviews
262 ratings
Share your opinion about Mehaffies Pies
GREAT PIES AND GREAT PRICES.AND LOCATION LOCATION,LOCATION IS EASY NO MATTER WHERE YOU LIVE.
Always stop here for pies when in the area
If you want the best of the best pies, cookies and carrot cakes, come here! All made from scratch! I'm so surprised at the good prices, given how expensive everything is! The key lime pie and peanutbutter but cream are top tier! This place is a gem, that needs to be protected at all cost :)
Hours
| Monday | 8AM - 5PM |
| Tuesday | 8AM - 5PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 8AM - 5PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 5PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Mehaffies Pies is well known for its delicious Butterscotch Pie and is the only place to get them in the area. The prices are reasonable, and the staff is friendly and helpful. Customers often praise the variety of pies, including the popular Dutch Apple pie, which is recommended to reserve ahead for holidays due to high demand. The menu also features pineapple pie, which many find amazing. Fresh pies are available for purchase, and people have been buying pies and cheesecakes here since they were young. The pies are highly appreciated by visitors from different areas, and the desserts are considered some of the best in Dayton and surrounding areas. Parking is ample, except for the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, when the place gets very busy. Customers also enjoy the punch card system, offering a free pie after every 12 purchases. However, some may find the tip prompt when paying a little uncomfortable.