Mehaffies Pies

$ • Bakery

Hours:
3013 Linden Ave, Dayton
(937) 253-1163

Customers' Favorites

Mehaffies Pies Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
3.9 (92)
Restaurantji Rating

I went to get two pies for Pi day. They have added individual slices and half pies as well as little individual sized pies. They have a great variety of fruit and cream pies, as well as cheesecake and cookies. The person who waited on me was friendly and cheerful. I got a lemon meringue pie and a banana cream pie as well as an individual cherry crunch pie. They were all delicious! Great selection and good value! Nice local business.Parking: Plenty of parking and easy to...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

This place has the best pies I have ever had. All made by hand. And the prices are reasonable like $10 a pie give or take. They also have individual slices, cheesecakes, and “haffies” these bite sized gems that are tiny pie bites. Yep I’ll have to make a pie run soon!

Restaurantji Rating

This place is INCREDIBLE! Everything we have tried so far has been a solid 10/10. On top of that, they have the kindest staff around. So far we have had the apple pie, coconut creme, peanut butter pie, and sugar cream! Highly recommend to anyone. The prices are also unbeatable! This is the perfect thing to pick up and bring to an event if you want to be the hit of the party! Love supporting this amazing local shop.

More Reviews(227)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu

Hours

Monday 8AM - 5PM
Tuesday 8AM - 5PM
Wednesday 8AM - 5PM
Thursday 8AM - 5PM
Friday 8AM - 5PM
Saturday 8AM - 5PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: