Cakes For Heaven's Sake

1201 N Main St, Findlay
(567) 525-5779

Recent Reviews

Star Baker

Lemon raspberry cupcake is one of the best cupcakes I've had in my life!! Love this place and the sweet lady who owns it! Definitely worth a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

H. Kent Edie

Ordered long distance…and Terri did s great job….cakes looked great and received great taste reviews…

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Jorgensen

Great cakes, nice people and the prices are reasonable.

Lisa Murphy

They are wonderful people who makes delicious cup cakes and try to do what you want if they can

Jenny Elchert

This bakery just did our desserts for our baby shower. They were all amazing! I showed Terry pic of the ideas I had and she nailed it. They looked identical to the pic I gave her. And they tasted delicious!! Highly recommended!!

Talisha B.

first let me say it takes a lot to "whooo" me! I'm a natural "Foodie!" I was scrolling through Facebook and seen pictures of these beautiful pupmkin cookies!! I ordered two dozen without even knowing what they were going to taste like. I'm overly glad I went ahead and ordered, they are absolutely amazing!! The prices are very affordable, very prompt responses from I'm assuming management, and they even carried them to my car with pleasure. The taste could be a little more "pumkiny," but they are rich and goodnes! this was my first time trying this local business. 5 stars so far from me!

Mick Jones

After being in contact with this bakery for over a week I was told my cake couldn’t be made due to them being over book even though I was never informed on how to solidify my order.

Jackie Gray

I lover their cakes!! i usually just show a picture of what my cake to look like ...I’m kinda picky on my cakes...and they look just like the picture if not better!! The cakes are always delicious!! Excellent prices for the superior quality!

Mike Tice

Awesome cupcakes and cookies. Owner is very nice and does a great job. Have always got the best sweets around.

David Trisel

These are easily the best pumpkin cookies I have ever tried!

Jamie R.

Working in town and wanted to shop local for a cake for my partner's birthday. Sent a message via Facebook messenger to CFHS Facebook page because the day I called they were closed. I had a response right away and they were able to make me a cake by the end of the week like I needed. I requested a Coca-Cola cake for my partner's birthday. The folks at CFHS sent messages about what I wanted in it and made sure we were on the same page about the cake. It was a two tier cake for around $20. I cannot remember the exact amount because I did not get a receipt and I added cupcakes to the order when I picked it up. They also wrote "Happy Birthday Tyler" in icing on it as well. The cake was delicious and a huge hit with my partner. The cake was moist without tasting undercooked and the icing was a chocolate dream. We couldn't have just one piece each. The variety of cupcakes I picked up were also very tasty, they were vanilla, pumpkin, maple, and chocolate peanut butter. The cupcakes are first come first serve and definitely worth stopping by for if you don't want to buy a whole cake. If you want a simple, tasty cake made locally with love then check out this place.

Darian Sanders-Tirado

They made me the most beautiful (and tasty) wedding cake. It’s exactly what i asked for! With Covid we weren’t able to have our wedding reception this year, but thanks to them we were still able to freeze cake for our anniversary next year, and have plenty left over to bring some cake to our parents. Thank you so much!

Shay Hampton

Definitely recommend, they made my sons first birthday cake to be shaped like a taco! Absolutely creative and delicious.

Mary K.

I ordered a cake for a friend's birthday over the phone. Was a bit dubious, having never dealt with this bakery before, but I was pressed for time. I should not have worried. The coconut cake was delicious! My friend, a true coconut cake aficionado, said it was "possibly the best ever." Lots of coconut, but not too much. Very moist. The frosting was sweet, but not too sweet, and in perfect proportion to the cake. I opted out of a birthday message in favor of more coconut on top. (Good choice.) Thanks for helping me celebrate a birthday in Pittsburgh :) A suggestion: Please have cake boxes in varying sizes. This small cake was put in a large box, which made it impossible for me to carry as it would not fit into large tote. ONLY issue: Lack of accessibility. There is a very high step into the building. The owners carried the cake out for me (and would have even collected payment outside), but that should not be necessary in this day. PLEASE consider adding a half-step or a ramp.

Susan Janczewski

Cakes for Heavens Sake did an amazing job recreating my parents wedding cake for their 50th anniversary party. my mom said it looked just like her original cake

Load More