The ambiance is sophisticated and comfortable. The seating is spaced nicely so that conversation can be quiet and private. Our server was very accommodating and pleasant and the food was stellar! The NY strip was juicy, good quality and well seasoned. The steak and potato soup was outstanding! The swordfish entree was delicious and the fish was a thick, generous portion. Highly recommend!
Leslee
Rasheem, our waiter was great and we will definitely be returning and requesting him again.
Meghan
Fantastic food, for most of us. When something wasn't right with an order, nothing was suggested-not taking it back, bringing something else, wasn't taken off the bill. It was dark in the restaurant. Lots of drinks/wine to choose from, food was great though. Much larger portions that I was expecting as well.
Andrea
First the good: our bartender did an amazing job taking care of us and the food was great! Cocktails mixed to perfection and we appreciated the wine selection. Now, the room for improvement: please stop *forcing* guests to cut into their steak when you bring it out. You can suggest, but telling me when I say I'd prefer not to that “this is the only chance you'll have to send it back if it's not cooked to your liking” is rude and unprofessional. This was NOT the bartender to be clear, a middle aged blonde lady not wearing service dress, possibly a manager. I prefer not to cut into the middle of a large steak when it gets to the table because I'm a slow eater and it'll get cold. Please don't force or threaten me and stand behind your delicious product with service that matches it.
Kyle
At the end of a long day of travel, we enjoyed one of the best meals in a long time. My Filet was perfect and my husband very much enjoyed his NY Strip! We rarely eat red meat these days but knew That Mancey's steakhouse would make this deviation well worth it, and they did!
Brad
We had a nice meal at Mancy's in the Hancock Hotel. Being from Toledo, we are familiar with the wonders of the Mancy family establishments. This did not disappoint. our server, Scott, took great care of us. He was knowledgeable and attentive. Next time we come to town, we'll be back!
Cheryl
Loved everything about Mancy's! Food was great, tenderloins cooked perfectly, delicious baked potato and Caesar salad!
Doug
Had the New York Strip 14oz. Best steak anywhere, no exaggeration. My wife had the filet, also the best anywhere. Service was perfect. We big fans of Mancy's at the Hancock Hotel
Erich
Celebrated our anniversary and it was very nice. People at the bar were a bit loud but overall everything was great.
J P
Food was great. People were great. Seemed to be getting avoided at the bar for some reason. Only 2 people there. Kept walking to tables, walking right past me, asking the person next to me if they were good, until I stopped them trying to be polite and asked for a drink. Other than that, the waiter was super fast and attentive and the food was fantastic!
My husband and I came for dinner and everything was excellent! We had a great time. I was so thrilled about the little strawberries cut to look like roses lol!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Allan
A few months ago we went to the original Mancy's in Toledo. Had a wonderful experience and a perfectly cooked prime NY strip steak. We recently were in Findlay and we had dinner at the Findlay Mancy's. Unfortunately we didn't have a very good experience. The server was unexperienced, but was trying her best. However, they way overcooked my NY strip steak. I normally never return food. I don't like to waste food. But this steak was so overcooked I couldn't eat it. And the broccolini was so overcooked it was literally charcoal. I spoke to the server and asked my food to be remade. As I waited and waited, I told my wife that this is a bad sign that it is taking so long. Finally my remade meal arrived. I checked the steak and it was even more overcooked than the first one. I spoke to the manager and they offered to remake the food again, but I had no confidence in it being right. They offered a free dessert, but I'm not a dessert person. They did take off half the price of the meal, but that really wasn't the point. I just wanted a properly prepared steak. I could excuse the first steak, but when remaking an overcooked steak, they overcook the second one? There's no excuse for that and we won't be going back.
Mark Scheid
Quiet and outstanding steaks
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Niki
We've eaten at Mancy's before but brought our son (for his bday) & his girlfriend (& was their 1st time). Everyone enjoyed their food & drinks & our waiter Cole (may have been spelled differently..) was excellent!
Jeanine Huttner
Steak itself was delicious but it was much too salty
The ambiance is sophisticated and comfortable. The seating is spaced nicely so that conversation can be quiet and private. Our server was very accommodating and pleasant and the food was stellar! The NY strip was juicy, good quality and well seasoned. The steak and potato soup was outstanding! The swordfish entree was delicious and the fish was a thick, generous portion. Highly recommend!
Rasheem, our waiter was great and we will definitely be returning and requesting him again.
Fantastic food, for most of us. When something wasn't right with an order, nothing was suggested-not taking it back, bringing something else, wasn't taken off the bill. It was dark in the restaurant. Lots of drinks/wine to choose from, food was great though. Much larger portions that I was expecting as well.
First the good: our bartender did an amazing job taking care of us and the food was great! Cocktails mixed to perfection and we appreciated the wine selection. Now, the room for improvement: please stop *forcing* guests to cut into their steak when you bring it out. You can suggest, but telling me when I say I'd prefer not to that “this is the only chance you'll have to send it back if it's not cooked to your liking” is rude and unprofessional. This was NOT the bartender to be clear, a middle aged blonde lady not wearing service dress, possibly a manager. I prefer not to cut into the middle of a large steak when it gets to the table because I'm a slow eater and it'll get cold. Please don't force or threaten me and stand behind your delicious product with service that matches it.
At the end of a long day of travel, we enjoyed one of the best meals in a long time. My Filet was perfect and my husband very much enjoyed his NY Strip! We rarely eat red meat these days but knew That Mancey's steakhouse would make this deviation well worth it, and they did!
We had a nice meal at Mancy's in the Hancock Hotel. Being from Toledo, we are familiar with the wonders of the Mancy family establishments. This did not disappoint. our server, Scott, took great care of us. He was knowledgeable and attentive. Next time we come to town, we'll be back!
Loved everything about Mancy's! Food was great, tenderloins cooked perfectly, delicious baked potato and Caesar salad!
Had the New York Strip 14oz. Best steak anywhere, no exaggeration. My wife had the filet, also the best anywhere. Service was perfect. We big fans of Mancy's at the Hancock Hotel
Celebrated our anniversary and it was very nice. People at the bar were a bit loud but overall everything was great.
Food was great. People were great. Seemed to be getting avoided at the bar for some reason. Only 2 people there. Kept walking to tables, walking right past me, asking the person next to me if they were good, until I stopped them trying to be polite and asked for a drink. Other than that, the waiter was super fast and attentive and the food was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband and I came for dinner and everything was excellent! We had a great time. I was so thrilled about the little strawberries cut to look like roses lol!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A few months ago we went to the original Mancy's in Toledo. Had a wonderful experience and a perfectly cooked prime NY strip steak. We recently were in Findlay and we had dinner at the Findlay Mancy's. Unfortunately we didn't have a very good experience. The server was unexperienced, but was trying her best. However, they way overcooked my NY strip steak. I normally never return food. I don't like to waste food. But this steak was so overcooked I couldn't eat it. And the broccolini was so overcooked it was literally charcoal. I spoke to the server and asked my food to be remade. As I waited and waited, I told my wife that this is a bad sign that it is taking so long. Finally my remade meal arrived. I checked the steak and it was even more overcooked than the first one. I spoke to the manager and they offered to remake the food again, but I had no confidence in it being right. They offered a free dessert, but I'm not a dessert person. They did take off half the price of the meal, but that really wasn't the point. I just wanted a properly prepared steak. I could excuse the first steak, but when remaking an overcooked steak, they overcook the second one? There's no excuse for that and we won't be going back.
Quiet and outstanding steaks
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We've eaten at Mancy's before but brought our son (for his bday) & his girlfriend (& was their 1st time). Everyone enjoyed their food & drinks & our waiter Cole (may have been spelled differently..) was excellent!
Steak itself was delicious but it was much too salty
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...