Meatball Mafia
5354 Center St, Hilliard
(614) 564-7251
Customers' Favorites
Nicky Santoro Meatball Sub
Large Meatball Bowl
Hot Peppers in Oil
Pepperoni Pizza
Briarhill Pizza
Satriale Bowl
White Pizza
Menu
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My husband and I were looking for something to eat for lunch and decided to swing by the market that the Meatball Mafia is located. We decided on pizza. We were not disappointed. Best pizza we’ve had by far since moving to Columbus. Loved the thick yet crispy crust and the amount of cheese was outstanding!! All they serve are 12” but they load the pizzas up that all I could have was two slices. Definitely returning.
It's a walk-up booth inside a market. Service was quick and I got a pizza with onion and banana pepper.
Overall the pizza was pretty good - you can anchor a boat with the cheese of these pizzas. I underestimated the density and cheesiness - you definitely get your money's worth. Massive quantities of cheese is not personally my preference, so if I go back I'll probably see if they can scale that back a bit.
I liked the onions...
Overall the pizza was pretty good - you can anchor a boat with the cheese of these pizzas. I underestimated the density and cheesiness - you definitely get your money's worth. Massive quantities of cheese is not personally my preference, so if I go back I'll probably see if they can scale that back a bit.
I liked the onions...
Meatball Mafia is amazing!! I had their Big Fat Antnee and I was not disappointed. I heard good things and I was a little surprised by the size but after the first bite I was glad I got it for sure. I went to the location inside of Crooked Can and with a few beers, a great pizza, and the game on I can’t think of a better afternoon. I would try Meatball Mafia again, 10/10!!
You May Also Like
Coffee Connections at Center Street Market - 5354 Center St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Popcorn Shops, Brewery
The Cheesecake Girl - Hilliard - 5354 Center St
![]()
Bakery, Gluten-Free
Pitabilities Street Food - 5354 Center St
![]()
Mediterranean, Food Trucks, Caterers, Fast Food