Outstanding pizza! One of the best I’ve had in Ohio yet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Sausage and Mushrooms and a Smokey Robinson' Speciality Pizza
Nick Willis
Waited for over an hour (online said 30 minutes) for the pizza which tasted great. No phone number can be found anywhere, how are you supposed to talk to anyone for customer service???
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Bob Morrris Jr
Best pizza in Columbus. There is a review below where someone says "The crust was perfect" and then gives 3 stars on their review. This place is epic. Don't pay attention to the South Park Yelper reviews giving anything less than 4 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
brian mcknight
If you don't know now, you know. I was very skeptical of that type of pizza. Initially, I thought it was a brick oven, burnt pizza. Based on barstools review. Going into that pizza place, I was a fan of soft greasy pizza. However, now I am a changed man. The crunch that it has is just enough to make it interesting, but not too much to be overpowering. The flavor profile that the brick oven char Gives to the pizza is now my new favorite. I will 100% be back to try the other type pizzas. I had the one with fresh mozzarella and fresh basil. They haven't marked their prices up based on the Review either. If you're wondering, if it's worth the drive, I'm here to tell you it is.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Roger Garland
Pizza was great. Nice char perfect amount of toppings, ( though would like more basil on ricotta pizza). Server was friendly and efficient.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Kevin Bacon
Joshua Connor
Just ordered two pizza’s to go as my family was really excited to try this place. Unfortunately, my wife found a hair baked into her piece of cheese pizza. The worst part is we spent $41 on two pizzas and this place doesn’t even have a phone number to contact about a possible refund. $41 down the drain.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gregory Zahn
Very friendly environment. Very busy. Great tasting pizza. Wings were pink on inside and not even tossed in the sauce. Could use better communication between staff or customers coming in(host/host stand).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bee Bee Q, Chicken Wings
Mike H
The pizza was great, perfectly baked with the cheese to sauce ratio on point! This was our fourth trip in the last few months and we will definitely continue to go back. If you're looking for New York style pizza, this is the place to go! It's a must visit, so don't miss out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: East Village Pepperoni, Cheese Pizza, Pizza Margherita
VeganLens
Sexton's has delicious vegan options, including vegan cheese and faux meats. They have customizable options and designated vegan pizza on the menu. They also have a vegan sub sandwich option. The location is really cool and they have nice seating and a nice patio!
Darin Thatcher
Barstool had it right 8.1 pizza was great.Smaller than I thought and loud inside...Will be back.
The pizza was amazing and the service was good. Food came out really fast. People will complain about absolutely anything so don't give the 1-star reviews too much merit. It's wood-fired pizza. The ovens are SUPER hot and the pizza is *supposed* to have some spots of char.And people complaining that the food is greasy or not very healthy???? It's pizza, everyone knows it's not healthy. What in the world is wrong with people?!?!?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Finy
Good food. Would be nice if they had a phone number.
Food: 5
Service: 3
Vanessa S.
Best pizza I've ever had in Columbus area (Hilliard). NY style is to die for crunchy crispy "10" ⭐
Unfortunately overhyped. I don't think this was near worth the $32+ I paid for a 3 topping pizza. Ordered extra cheese and it didn't seem like anything more than a normal amount. Cut awkwardly too. It was fine. Despite the pictures on this Yelp page, there are no sides, salads, appetizers or drinks, at least not able to be ordered ahead. They also charge $1.25 for a single side of ranch, which they forgot to include with my order.Nothing special and won't be going back.I hate so much to give a poor review or make anyone feel bad. I just want to get what I pay for and be able to support local businesses genuinely. I really hope they can improve service and quality and at least keep prices where they are and not raise them.
Alexandra S.
i genuinely feel bad for leaving a 3 star review because this pizza is good, however, never have I experienced such difficulty ordering food. They don't have a phone number, you have to order it through an app 'toast'. On multiple occasions, I have ordered through said app, and my pizza is never ready at listed time. Tonight, I ordered a pizza through the app, to find that my order time had changed to 2.5 hours upon checkout, no way to call and cancel, no way to cancel through the app. Why not take phone orders?? Or at least have a line of contact listed for assistance?? Like I said, the pizza is good if you can jump through the hoops to actually get one, but the inconvenience leaves more to be desired.
Outstanding pizza! One of the best I’ve had in Ohio yet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Sausage and Mushrooms and a Smokey Robinson' Speciality Pizza
Waited for over an hour (online said 30 minutes) for the pizza which tasted great. No phone number can be found anywhere, how are you supposed to talk to anyone for customer service???
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Best pizza in Columbus. There is a review below where someone says "The crust was perfect" and then gives 3 stars on their review. This place is epic. Don't pay attention to the South Park Yelper reviews giving anything less than 4 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you don't know now, you know. I was very skeptical of that type of pizza. Initially, I thought it was a brick oven, burnt pizza. Based on barstools review. Going into that pizza place, I was a fan of soft greasy pizza. However, now I am a changed man. The crunch that it has is just enough to make it interesting, but not too much to be overpowering. The flavor profile that the brick oven char Gives to the pizza is now my new favorite. I will 100% be back to try the other type pizzas. I had the one with fresh mozzarella and fresh basil. They haven't marked their prices up based on the Review either. If you're wondering, if it's worth the drive, I'm here to tell you it is.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza was great. Nice char perfect amount of toppings, ( though would like more basil on ricotta pizza). Server was friendly and efficient.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Kevin Bacon
Just ordered two pizza’s to go as my family was really excited to try this place. Unfortunately, my wife found a hair baked into her piece of cheese pizza. The worst part is we spent $41 on two pizzas and this place doesn’t even have a phone number to contact about a possible refund. $41 down the drain.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Very friendly environment. Very busy. Great tasting pizza. Wings were pink on inside and not even tossed in the sauce. Could use better communication between staff or customers coming in(host/host stand).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bee Bee Q, Chicken Wings
The pizza was great, perfectly baked with the cheese to sauce ratio on point! This was our fourth trip in the last few months and we will definitely continue to go back. If you're looking for New York style pizza, this is the place to go! It's a must visit, so don't miss out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: East Village Pepperoni, Cheese Pizza, Pizza Margherita
Sexton's has delicious vegan options, including vegan cheese and faux meats. They have customizable options and designated vegan pizza on the menu. They also have a vegan sub sandwich option. The location is really cool and they have nice seating and a nice patio!
Barstool had it right 8.1 pizza was great.Smaller than I thought and loud inside...Will be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza was amazing and the service was good. Food came out really fast. People will complain about absolutely anything so don't give the 1-star reviews too much merit. It's wood-fired pizza. The ovens are SUPER hot and the pizza is *supposed* to have some spots of char.And people complaining that the food is greasy or not very healthy???? It's pizza, everyone knows it's not healthy. What in the world is wrong with people?!?!?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food. Would be nice if they had a phone number.
Food: 5
Service: 3
Best pizza I've ever had in Columbus area (Hilliard). NY style is to die for crunchy crispy "10" ⭐
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Pizza Margherita
Unfortunately overhyped. I don't think this was near worth the $32+ I paid for a 3 topping pizza. Ordered extra cheese and it didn't seem like anything more than a normal amount. Cut awkwardly too. It was fine. Despite the pictures on this Yelp page, there are no sides, salads, appetizers or drinks, at least not able to be ordered ahead. They also charge $1.25 for a single side of ranch, which they forgot to include with my order.Nothing special and won't be going back.I hate so much to give a poor review or make anyone feel bad. I just want to get what I pay for and be able to support local businesses genuinely. I really hope they can improve service and quality and at least keep prices where they are and not raise them.
i genuinely feel bad for leaving a 3 star review because this pizza is good, however, never have I experienced such difficulty ordering food. They don't have a phone number, you have to order it through an app 'toast'. On multiple occasions, I have ordered through said app, and my pizza is never ready at listed time. Tonight, I ordered a pizza through the app, to find that my order time had changed to 2.5 hours upon checkout, no way to call and cancel, no way to cancel through the app. Why not take phone orders?? Or at least have a line of contact listed for assistance?? Like I said, the pizza is good if you can jump through the hoops to actually get one, but the inconvenience leaves more to be desired.