Sexton’s Pizza
$ • PizzaAbout Sexton’s Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Sausage Pepperoniabd Mushrooms Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks and Fried Pickles
Pepperoni Bacon Banana Pepper Pizza
East Village Pepperoni
Coliflower Crust Pizza
Paisano Pepper Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
In Queso Emergency
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pizza Margherita
Sexton’s Pizza Reviews
216 ratings
Share your opinion about Sexton’s Pizza
I can’t say enough about this great place. We’re so happy to have this business in our area . We were there for its opening day in Hilliard. Great crust , fresh toppings, great size and price. It is consistently made each time. Now we found out they deliver to my neighborhood ! Damnn ! You folks rock
Great vibes, our food came out quickly, and the pizza was delicious. There’s a bar if you want to sit and grab a drink, or tables if you want to go with a larger group. They have many different types of pizza, as well as build your own. We got the 614 which has pepperoni, sausage, and banana peppers. The staff is attentive and kind. Definitely recommend stopping in if you’re looking for a slice in the Old Hilliard area.
Love their pizza but super disappointing delivery service/process every time. I really wish they’d invest in their own delivery drivers because the 3rd party delivery via their website absolutely sucks. I paid $31 last night for a large cheese at 6:45PM and it arrived at 8:45PM. That’s fine because they let me know ahead of time. My order was picked up from the restaurant at 8PM though and it apparently took the drivers 45min to travel the 3.9 miles to my house (no...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 3 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 3 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 3 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 3 - 9PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
Sexton's Pizza is a popular spot for delicious pizza, particularly Detroit-style and vegan options. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is low-key. The pizza is cooked to perfection, with a nice char, and is highly recommended. The "Mike" pizza is a standout. The tiny dining area has a cozy feel, but may be noisy when busy due to echoing acoustics. Despite this, it remains a top spot for enjoying great beer, pizza, and wings in Hilliard. Recent visits have shown that the quality can vary; some customers found the pizza overdone or ingredients not as well-prepared as before, while others enjoyed the NY style dairy air, praising the good crust and great service. Vegan cheese is available for most pies, but some found the selection and BYO options limited and overpriced, and a few felt the vegan pizza options are better elsewhere. Overall, Sexton's continues to be a favorite for good pizza, especially when the quality is on point.