22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Hilliard

“This place has been on my list for a while and I just tried it today. Everyone in the family and our son’s friend loved it! If you’re debating it, don’t. Go eat it.“

“Great family establishment with great food and great service!!“

“Great pizza! Friendly service! I highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza!“

“I love this place. Friendly staff and great pizza! Cute patio outside and also indoor dining.“

“Wow! On an overnight school bus trip from Centerville, Ohio, pizza and cheese curds were AWESOME!“

“Wow! On an overnight school bus trip from Centerville, Ohio, pizza and cheese curds were AWESOME!“

“So the pizza is really good here, but the staff actually cares and that makes all the difference! pep, mushroom extra sauce and well done 9/10“

“Loved this little place! Great food and the meatballs are definitely the best in central Ohio. Highly recommended!!“

“Bowling here is fantastic. If the lanes are full, they'll give you a free card for the arcade while you wait.

That's not even counting the generosity they'll show if something goes wrong with your lane. Free food and a time extension.

I can't think of a better place to bowl.“

“They serve a chipotle sauce with their chicken quesadillas that I swear is literal liquid crack. Freaking amazing!“

“We were just in here (leaving the lot as I type this) and I have to applaud the crew tonight. The food was hot and fresh with great taste. I also want to give a standing ovation to Emily who was running front cash and handled one of the most rude individuals I have ever encountered in food service. He was belittling, demanding, and arrogant from the start and she never once stopped smiling or offering him the best service.“

“You know how when you’re sick and you don’t eat for a week. Wheh you start feeling better, you want those comfort foods. Nothing healthy. Straight up, COMFORT. FOOD. Well. That’s all I wanted. After being bed ridden for days, my appetite returned and all I wanted was pizza and garlic cream cheese from Cottage Inn. Got a salad, too, because it’s all about balance. Our food arrived and… no garlic cream cheese. Just my salad and dressing in a bag all by itself. I’m devastated. I pout. I call, hoping that maybe my precious garlic cream cheese fell out in the drivers car. The wonderful gentleman on the phone remembered my order, and ended up sending the driver back to drop off my precious cream cheese. Normally, I’d just say “eh, whatever”. But when you’re sick, and you’ve craving something and you’re let down.. only to have some glorious person come in and save your day! Well, folks, that’s a story for the times. Thank you to my Cottage Inn Heroes, who saved this sickly, dramatic woman's day with garlic cream cheese. Which I inhaled in an embarassingly small amount of time.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Heard a lot about this place and gave it a go. My wife and I were very pleased with everything. Candy was a great bartender and the knowledge she provided about the food, concept, ingredients, sourcing and overall was phenomenal. Also she was training.and doing a killer job. The pizza we tried was paisano New York style and pesto mo town. New York was by far the closest thing to actual New York style. Great dough, does have a little flop but overall fire. Mo town isn't authentic style but it's still really good and using ezzo and caring about ingredients that they are utilizing shows it. Chill environment and everyone courteous. We also got wings to try, pretty good especially since the sauce is on the side and the wing itself doesn't even need any sauces. Not a wing guy by any means, but when a wing is good with nothing on it. You've accomplished the goal. Keep up the great work“

“We had a large event of more than 40 people on Saturday 8/16/25 and couldn’t have been happier. The kitchen manager came out when we arrived and clarified everything with us, they were careful to label the gluten free products and our servers, Ashley and Chloe were so attentive. The food was incredible, as it always is! They went above and beyond to make our event perfect! Thank you and we’re looking forward to hosting there again next year!“

“I had a really good experience with Donatos. The pizza tasted fresh, the crust was nice and crisp, and I loved how the toppings went all the way to the edge. Everything had great flavor, especially the sauce and cheese. It was a satisfying meal, and I’d definitely order from them again.“

“ordered a medium Pepperoni. got a cheese. not really a big deal but that was an extra 1.89“

“Delicious pizza!! Our go to spot!!“

“A nice neighbor bar. everyone was friendly helpful and great pizza from next door“

“I ordered a Mariachi Beef from DoorDash and realized we weren't able to put no tomatoes on the app. I called in a few minutes after we ordered and even though the pizza had already been started i think, the manager still corrected it and got us the pizza how we wanted. Kind of a pain in the butt request but he took care of me anyway with a nice tone. Excellent customer service skills. Oh and the pizza was fire per usual.“

“I would LOVE to thank Steven, for the amazing customer service he provided. Steven delivered a white glove service that I would never forget! He explained different options that I can order, even gave me the option to order the special. STEVEN YOU ROCK! And to the rest of the crew thank you for being clean while you fix our food. I’ll definitely be back at this location.“

“I'm a 15 year old who works In the fast food chain and in my honest opinion this place is the best pizza place around, they always get my order right, staff is friendly and if you use deals their food is super cheap. I love eatting here 10/10!“