22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Westerville

“Best pizza I have ever had“

“We had a pizza party with 17 difference pizzas and Cardinals was voted the best pizza! Pizza came from all over central Ohio. Figured I would leave this review so everyone knows that it’s just that good!“

“What a great joint to grab a pie & a drink. First of all, probably the best cauliflower pizza I’ve ever had. You honestly can’t hardly tell the difference between that and the regular crust, it’s that good. We got both today, just to test things out and we are sold on the cauliflower crust. So, keto peeps and if you’re watching carbs, definitely treat yourself to a Classics pizza. The bar is SO CLEAN and the bartender was so friendly and pours a great drink. Prices are fair and the service is unmatched. The owner, friendliest guy in the world and dedicated to making this place the best it can be. Vibes are immaculate. Truly cannot say enough good things about this location- I only wish we lived closer to make it a regular staple in our delivery rotation.“

“Their pizza is as good as it always has been. The shop is very tiny, you're walking into the kitchen when you go in for pickup. But the staff is very friendly, the pizza is reasonably priced, and we've never had an issue making an order online or not getting what we paid for. Excellent Columbus style pizza.“

“Oh...my...gosh. The pizza is DELICIOUS. We've had quite a few different pizzas over the years living in Ohio but this was the best we've had. The pepperoni rolls were also amazing. Whatever they're doing explains the awards they've won for their pizzas. It was a long wait for pick up this evening but well worth it. I highly recommend this place!“

“So glad to find this place. The pizza is excellent. I love the crust. Based on reviews I asked for extra sauce ( I love sauce more than cheese) and my pizza was perfect. Pepperoni mushroom with extra sauce all day every day for me!“

“Their pizza, Veggie Subs, and service are outstanding!“

“Had a filling and delicious meal! We planned our stops on a trip south and back so we could eat at Fazolis’ since there are none where we live. Wish they would expand north into New York State!“

“Thanks for delivery at the exact time of our request. The pizza was hot and fresh. We appreciate the great service! :-)“

“Beautiful atmosphere. Jessica was a super friendly, timely and attentive waiter. Had six totally different dishes and each was hot and delicious. Particularly loved the stromboli w/spicy sausage, seared shrimp in Alfredo, the (light) calamari and delicate gnocchi.“

“We just had the Birria tacos, dorado burritos & steak fajitas. Everything was excellent! Highly recommend!“

“Great food! We had a party of 15 and they were so accommodating and so friendly. Highly recommend!!! Thanks for being so awesome!“

“This is one of the best pizza restaurant and Italian food restaurants I’ve been to since I moved from NYC to Columbus Ohio. The food is great and so is the atmosphere and the service. The best part is I live less than ten mins away from here.“

“Not from Columbus but every time I go there I try to stop in at Anges pizza Polaris. I have tried almost everything on the menu and I haven't had any complaints, the customer service is also great.“

“We ordered pizza Saturday night from our local Donatos Pizza Shop, and were tickled to see a friendly note from the employee who made our pizza. I thought that was a nice touch! So to return the favor, I thought I’d post a nice review on the Westerville Donatos Facebook page. Thanks, Andrew Jones!! You make a delicious pizza! We did enjoy it, and thanks to you, we will be back often. Keep up the good work!!!“

“I’m from the valley originally, grew up on DiCarlos pizza. I used to get $2 a day for lunch as a kid when I was in school. It was always a foot race to DiCarlos, at that time you could get 3 slices and a can of pop outta the machine for $2. It’s no where near as cheap as it was but it still tastes the same. The Westerville DiCarlos reminds me of those days, and that’s a good thing. Keep up the good work and keep on pumping out delicious pizza. Thank you.“

“Exactly what you think it is but exceeds expectations!!!“

“The za is always fresh and hot. There is always a healthy amount of toppings. The employees are friendly(greet every customer) and take care of pick up orders quickly. Lava cakes were overcooked or sat for a moment. Prefect for a busy weekday that you’ve ran out of time to cook.“

“They have great workers and delivery drivers. You have to know what to order though because you can be disappointed here. The subs are solid, if you get pizza only get the thin crust (thick and hand-tossed are consistently doughy and have too much sauce), and avoid the calzones.“

“"I recently had the pleasure of receiving a pizza delivery from Charles Brumlow, and the experience was notably commendable. Charles ensured the pizza arrived not just in a timely manner but also in perfect condition, capturing the essence of freshness one would expect straight from the oven. His proactive communication regarding the delivery status was a highlight, providing accurate updates that set the stage for a seamless experience. The care taken in handling the pizza was evident, with every topping in place, underscoring Charles's attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction. He displayed professionalism and courtesy that enhanced the overall experience, making it both pleasant and memorable. While the service was exceptional, one area for improvement would be refining the contactless delivery process to better adhere to safety protocols, ensuring customer peace of mind. Charles's dedication to delivering not just a product but an exceptional service experience shines through, making me look forward to future deliveries from him and confidently recommending his service to others."“

“Love this restaurant!! Must try!“

“I used the website to order the cheese puffs. The website is easy to use. It gives you time when your order will be ready. You go into the store, and they have a kiosk where you oder it. You are given a 3 digit number to open your drawer. The Puffs were hot and tasty. Parking is limited.

Parking: Parking is limited because of the stripmall section.“