17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Westerville

Cardinal pizza Pizza • $
10 E Main St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

NY Style Cheese Pizza
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Siracha Dry Rub Wings
Garlic Cheese Bread
House Salad
Pizza Meat
Pizzas
Gov

“Amazing pizza. I ordered online and it was ready at the exact time given.Service was quick and friendly and I was able to just run in and pick it up fast.I was impressed by the flavor. Crust, sauce, toppings... everything was delicious. The NY style crust is amazing. I'm so glad I decided to try it.I will definitely be back soon.“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House Pizza • $
558 W Schrock Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with a Side of House-Made Marinara
Pepperoni Sausage Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Large Calzone
Cheese Pizza
Italian Sub
Garlic Knots
Meat Lovers
Lasagna

“If you live close to this place and haven't tried it, shame on you!! We were looking for pizza and pasta for lunch from somewhere we had never been before. That is always a little scary!! We fortunately picked Pasquales. We ordered the garlic knots. They are Huge, Crispy where they need to be and chewy not doughy. And so cheap!! We decided to try the Meat Lovers Pizza and the Penne and Meatball too. Neither dish disappointed. The crust is so thin and crispy but not burnt at all and the amount of toppings was very generous. We have a lot of leftovers to take home. We both decided we would make the 45 min drive to eat here again and again. The server Makayla (sp?) was very friendly and the speed of service was Great!! Then there is the dessert case. We brought home a cannoli, a cream puff , a cinnamon roll and the peanut butter cookie sandwich with chocolate. So excited to try them too!“

4.4 Superb84 Reviews
Giammarco's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
6030 Chandler Ct, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Italian Bread and Seasoned Olive Oil
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Fettuccini Alfredo
Italiano Stromboli
Sausage Arancini
Chicken Marsala
Fried Ravioli
Pizza Pillows
Caesar Salad
Garlic Bread

“We went there for my Wife's Birthday and were treated well. They even gave her a Birthday gift of sugar coated puff pastries.Their Sausage and peppers was good but their marinara sauce is a killer.When I go back I'm gonna have the spaghetti and meatballs which should be wonderful.“

4.1 Good201 Reviews
Gionino's Pizzeria Pizza • $
103 Westerville Plaza, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

JoJos and 4 Piece Fried Chicken with Slaw
Pepperoni Pizza with Banana Peppers
Garlic Butter Sauce
White Pizza Small
Pepperoni Pizza
Mushroom Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“My husband and I are from the Ohio Valley and have longed for some good fried chicken and jojos since we moved to Columbus in 2005. I'm telling you this place is the REAL DEAL! The chicken and jojos were just like back home and the coleslaw was fantastic as well. I can't wait to try their pizza next!“

4.3 Superb63 Reviews
Antonio's Pizza • $
7001 Sunbury Rd # C, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Individual Pizza Ready
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
All the Way Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Parmesan
Garlic Bread
Meatball Sub

“Excellent pizza! We have always gotten great service, food and value. This is a hand tossed crust style. Lots of toppings and a delicious sauce.Spectacular community business!They always support local events and initiatives-It's a really fun place to take kids and have them make their own pizza.Vegetarian options: Salads are good.veggie pizza are delicious.Dietary restrictions: Numerous optionsParking: Plenty of parking.Kid-friendliness: Super fun make your own kids pizza- friendly kids menu.Wheelchair accessibility: Standard accessibility“

4.5 Superb38 Reviews
Classic Pizza Pizza • $
742 N State St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Taco Pizza

“I have been looking for a good pizza since moving north from Clintonville and I have finally found it! I judge on pepperoni pizzas - it was thin, crispy and the pepperoni was perfectly cooked! Will drive to Westerville from Delaware Alum Creek area anytime! Also loved the Boneless Wings - very little breading and quality chicken.“

4.4 Superb33 Reviews
Classic Pizza Pizza • $
906 S Sunbury Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Classic Supreme Pizza
Italian Sub Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Boneless Wings
Bone in Wings
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread
Italian Sub

“Why did I wait 9yrs to try CP?The phone recording encourages online ordering, but this first timer had questions. After friendly, helpful ordering, our order was delivered by their own delivery people. Prompt, and friendly service again. Pizzas arrived still over 130° hot. Thin crust that had a golden brown bottom, with just enough crisp to avoid limp or brittle. The dough was NOT over-mixed to create that gummy/chewy bite. Sauce was right on point with flavors of garlic and herb, rather than sugar.Cheese has a nice gooey pull without that rubbery snap-back. The enzo pepperoni and sausage was vividly flavored, and paired well with the sauce. We tried the recommended Italian sub pizza which uses the creamy Italian dressing for the sauce base. I’m so glad we did. It was a big hit. Our second visit we did carryout. Small place with a small grab & go private parking lot. Again with the friendly staff. No tables, no chairs. You pay, you go. Small interior for customers to loiter. I did like that they had the touchless TapPay machine to use your phone. Added a sub this visit. Worried the sub didn’t even measure out to 7” was for not. The double meat & cheese Italian sub did not suffer a loss of contents. Well worth the price. I do require more than 2 slices of tomato, so I will order extra next time. Lastly, I always recommend people bring an insulated bag to carry your food home. You want that food as hot and delicious as the way they prepared it for you. Hope this helps. #UpCloseSavor“

4.3 Superb41 Reviews
Ange’s Pizza - Polaris Pizza • $
515 Lazelle Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

“I bought a meat ball sub Recently it was Not good The meat ball wasn't in season. The cheese fries were okay. The customer was great and everyone was always friendly. Now the pizza here is always on 100% .In my opinion Not the subs and wings.“

4.1 Good31 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
807 S State St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Baked Sampler Platter
Chicken Parmigiano
Chicken Carbonara
Ultimate Sampler
Chicken Alfredo
Two Breadsticks
Baked Spaghetti
Lunch Special
2 Breadsticks

“Food was mediocre. Super runny pasta sauce. Got food super fast but it was so incredibly scalding you could tell it was high power microwaved. The bread sticks and Alfredo sause were the most exciting things about the meal. Service was great however.“

3.9 Good74 Reviews
Taqueria El Girasol Vietnamese • $
30 Westerview Dr, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Queso Taco Asada
Birria Tacos
Quesadilla

“Taqueria El GirasolTaqueria El Girasol is a recent addition to the Westerville dining scene and is one of my new favorites. Owned by a family originally from Mexico City they offer traditional Mexican food from a slightly abbreviated menu. The abbreviated menu doesn’t bother me because it is a small restaurant and I would rather they do a few things well than have to cut corners with a larger menu. One thing Taqueria El Girasol offers that is usually missing from local Mexican menus is breakfast dishes.Doing my due diligence I read several previous reviews of the establishment and I will now address some of the earlier concerns in one sentence or less. The chips were warm, the salsa was thick, the horchata was cold and the food was deliciously seasoned.The FoodToday I chose Huevos A La Mexicana. Eggs scrambled with tomato, onions and Jalapeños. It was cooked perfectly and not overcooked as is easy to do. It was well seasoned and served hot. It was in my opinion a good value for the money spent. I have never ordered a dish here that once finished left me hungry. Speaking of good values the desserts here are easily large enough for two servings and are absolutely delicious.The FacilityThe signage in front makes the restaurant easy to find even though it is situated almost in the corner spot of a small strip. Once inside the dining is nicely decorated with artworks that pay homage to both Mexico and Central Ohio. The table arrangement is nicely laid out and not cramped. Overall the dining room and restrooms are very clean and neat in appearance.The PeopleThe people who represent your business can make or break your business. The people I have talked to at Taqueria El Girasol are some of the nicest I have met in a while. They have always welcomed me in or welcomed me back and have always made me feel truly welcome. They have also always thanked me for my visit. Not just one of my favorite restaurants but also some of my favorite people.Personal observations and preferencesNot much I would change about Taqueria El Girasol. Would like the option of flour or corn tortillas with some dishes but to be fair it may be something that all I had to do was asked for. Also business hours of 10:00AM-10:00PM are not conducive breakfast dining and the breakfast dishes on the menu. I understand this is a family business and the importance of balancing life with work, but I’d be interested to see whether they would be more busy between say 8:00AM to 10:00AM or 8:00PM-10:00PM.Final thoughts and recommendationsOverall I would have no reservations recommending Taqueria El Girasol to a friend or family member, or for that matter taking a friend or family member there to eat.“

4.2 Good22 Reviews
Ange’s Pizza - Polaris Pizza •
515 Lazelle Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

“Food is awesome every time I order. My pepperoni cheese extra sauce was out of this world tonight. Avery is the best, and all of the customer service people are amazing and get my order correctly every single time. They go the extra mile. Great job I really appreciate it.“

4 Good38 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
642 N State St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Large Deep Dish
Corner Pizza

“The pizza is really good and they're really friendly! The only thing I would say is the pizza is a little greasy but hey it's pizza you know!Vegetarian options: Pizzas are always fully customizable!Dietary restrictions: They're really happy to try to meet your restrictions the staff is very nice and friendly!“

4 Good25 Reviews
Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Italian • $
6000 Westerville Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Everyone's Favorite Stromboli
The Original Stromboli
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Garlic Cheese Bread
Chicken Carsonie
Italian Stallion
Italian Fries
Lasagna

“We met family (with 2 young-uns—one 5 yo, the other one 6 mos old) for dinner. Our server was awesome! She was very attentive and loved the kids! We had mozzarella sticks to start, then the guys split a pepperoni pizza and the gals had Stromboli—one chicken, one veggie. And my grandson had spaghetti and meatballs and steamed broccoli. The mozzarella sticks were good. The pizza was very greasy. We’ve had it before and that was not the case. The Stromboli was picture perfect, but very bland—as if there was no seasoning at all. My daughter-in-law suggested putting Italian seasoning in with the filling, then mixed with the butter/oil that was brushed on top. The dipping sauce was also rather bland. But the star of the show was the broccoli followed by the spaghetti and meatball. The portions were generous and most of the spaghetti went home with us.“

3.8 Good71 Reviews
Beerhead Bar & Eatery Pizza • $
6294 E Dublin Granville Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Downeast Cider House Original Blend
Bourbon Trail Meatballs
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Street Corn Pizza
Chicagoland Pizza
Nashville Sliders
Garlic Parm Fries
Barbarian Pretzel
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Pizza

“Stopped in here for some beers mid afternoon on a Saturday. they have a great selection of beer, and the servers are attentive and friendly. For such a great place i was surprised it wasn't very busy. they have a nice patio area but it was a little too cold for that when we were there. i can't speak for the food, but what we saw looked good.“

3.8 Good67 Reviews
Massey's Pizza Westerville Pizza • $
399 S State St, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni Pizza
Massey's Pizza
Taco Pizza
Supreme
Sausage

“When the Masseys closest to our home closed, the search was on to fined a new location. Westerville wins hands down. This is our 5th trip. As a person doing Keto-- the cauliflower crust here is a great cheat option. There are very few pizza places that have a low carb version of a cauliflower crust, Masseys is one. But any how-- regarding the Westerville Massey's - consistency!!!! The staff is friendly. Adam has taken our order a few times now, and he's very nice, and always comes out to check on us.The pizza comes out hot, with lots of toppings every time we have been here. We learned today this location has been here for 30 years.The dining room is older but comfortable and very large!! Great place.Dietary restrictions: Great cauliflower crust“

3.8 Good43 Reviews
Time & Change Bar & Grill • $
1186 County Line Rd, Westerville

“My family and I were in Columbus visiting friends and looking for a place to eat dinner. We came across Time and Change and had a great experience. Traci was our server and she was so accommodating to our toddler. She brought her dinner out even before our own entrees so our hangry toddler could start eating asap.Music wasn't too loud, but we could tell it would be a great hangout to watch The Buckeyes when they're playing. Looks like they do trivia nights too.The owners even came out and talked with us as one point. Sounds like they just purchased the restaurant and are working hard at make some changes for the better, including rolling out a new menu. The wings were AWESOME. They mentioned they are bringing out some new sauce flavors soon.Will definitely visit again next time we're in town!“

3.8 Good22 Reviews
Minico's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
1180 County Line Rd, Westerville

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatball
Italian Sub
Onion Rings
Side Salad
Lasagna
Pizza
Todd

“We ordered a four serving spaghetti and meatballs meal and an Italian sub. Bread and salad accompanied the spaghetti dinner. The portions were great and the food was all very fresh and tasty. You can’t beat the value considering the quality and convenience. My kids and I are extremely grateful and will certainly be ordering more often.“

3.6 Good28 Reviews
Loading...
map Map