24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Westerville

“Best pizza I have ever had“

“This is the best pizza in the Westerville area! We have been ordering from here for over 10 years. Today we had the first mistake ever with our pick up order. I called to explain and the manager Ryan was quick to offer many solutions and wanted to make sure they made it right. Mistakes happen. How you handle mistakes matters. One mistake by a busy pizza place in 10 years is best in the industry.
Great pizza and great customer service!“

“I wanted to try a new pizza joint and Brenz had good reviews on Uber Eats so I tried it and the reviewers did not steer me wrong! Except they forgot some of my order. The pizza was great, the bread sides were ok. The Heritage Hot Honey- a MUST try!!!! Top 3 pizza's I ever tasted. I was worried it would be too spicy because I am a whoosie but it was not. Portion sizes are great also. Just wish my full order arrived.“

“We had a pizza party with 17 difference pizzas and Cardinals was voted the best pizza! Pizza came from all over central Ohio. Figured I would leave this review so everyone knows that it’s just that good!“

“Great food and the employees are awesome! You need to try the Zaks sweet meat pizza!“

“delivery in NC coast awesome pizza grew up with Massey pizza“

“So glad to find this place. The pizza is excellent. I love the crust. Based on reviews I asked for extra sauce ( I love sauce more than cheese) and my pizza was perfect. Pepperoni mushroom with extra sauce all day every day for me!“

“Absolutely yummy!!!! Almost forgot to get a pic!!! Thank you for delivering tonight!!!“

“my family was amazed at the pulled pork and bacon pizza with the sweet baby Ray's sauce tonight! will definitely be ordering next time!“

“Best tacos in Westerville! Chips and salsa are excellent! Service is friendly and fast! You can taste the difference when the food is made with love!“

“Great food! We had a party of 15 and they were so accommodating and so friendly. Highly recommend!!! Thanks for being so awesome!“

“Not from Columbus but every time I go there I try to stop in at Anges pizza Polaris. I have tried almost everything on the menu and I haven't had any complaints, the customer service is also great.“

“Had a filling and delicious meal! We planned our stops on a trip south and back so we could eat at Fazolis’ since there are none where we live. Wish they would expand north into New York State!“

“Beautiful atmosphere. Jessica was a super friendly, timely and attentive waiter. Had six totally different dishes and each was hot and delicious. Particularly loved the stromboli w/spicy sausage, seared shrimp in Alfredo, the (light) calamari and delicate gnocchi.“

“If you enjoy a great mom and pop shop feel with great family friendly service, with ties to the “Youngstown” area stop for a feeling of the steel valley. The meatball sliders are great, the buffalo cauliflower has to be the best in city I’ve every had run there to try both“

“We stop here every time we come through back to Cincinnati. Pizza is always perfect and reminds me of back home. I’ve never had an issue and we will always make the trip off the highway to make time to support this business and enjoy amazing DiCarlo’s Pizza. If you aren’t getting this pizza Ohio Valley Style, you are missing out.

This last time I called in and ordered ahead. I was an hour out. I got there and the pizza was not ready. The guys working said “I didn’t know being an hour out that you would be here in an hour and I didn’t want you pizza just sitting on the stove”. I was 100% appreciative of this. I would have waited 30 minutes more to have a hot fresh pizza, with nice cold toppings as it was designed. Great costumer service and knowledge on how the DiCarlo’s pizza should be served. My kids also gave the pizza 10/10!“

“Sadie.....this young lady is a Rockstar sweetheart. She remembered me from a few weeks ago to start and shes very patient and friendly. The entire store seems to have a wonderfully happy amd down to earth atmosphere. Food is always what you expect!!! Yum!“

“Our first time eating here, we enjoyed our meals and the ser ice was very good. Our server Preston was very nice and recommended to my wife to order from kids menu to get a single patty burger, it was still a pretty big burger. The fries were fresh hot and many, I had the tots, they were OK but I liked the fries better. Fish and chips very good, a large piece of breaded fish well seasoned. Over all I would give them a very good rating.“

“These are the kindest employees. I placed an order online then got held up and arrived for my pizza over an hour late. They were making a new pizza for me when I got there. It was my fault that the pizza wasn’t fresh, I would never have expected them to remake it. What thoughtful people.“

“We ordered pizza Saturday night from our local Donatos Pizza Shop, and were tickled to see a friendly note from the employee who made our pizza. I thought that was a nice touch! So to return the favor, I thought I’d post a nice review on the Westerville Donatos Facebook page. Thanks, Andrew Jones!! You make a delicious pizza! We did enjoy it, and thanks to you, we will be back often. Keep up the good work!!!“

“First time using this location, traffic sent my wife around 270, we usually use the Gahanna location in Hamilton. Pizza was a bit elevated, but y’all shorted me one of damn garlic butter cups, which means, I didn’t get one! 😁 Pizza was great!“

“Love this restaurant!! Must try!“

“Good is always done well and the staff has always been very pleasant, only downfall which I’m unsure is with the staff or the app, is that expect the wait time to be 15-30 minutes longer than what is told to you on the app. If you already know that though, then you can plan accordingly.“

“"I recently had the pleasure of receiving a pizza delivery from Charles Brumlow, and the experience was notably commendable. Charles ensured the pizza arrived not just in a timely manner but also in perfect condition, capturing the essence of freshness one would expect straight from the oven. His proactive communication regarding the delivery status was a highlight, providing accurate updates that set the stage for a seamless experience. The care taken in handling the pizza was evident, with every topping in place, underscoring Charles's attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction. He displayed professionalism and courtesy that enhanced the overall experience, making it both pleasant and memorable. While the service was exceptional, one area for improvement would be refining the contactless delivery process to better adhere to safety protocols, ensuring customer peace of mind. Charles's dedication to delivering not just a product but an exceptional service experience shines through, making me look forward to future deliveries from him and confidently recommending his service to others."“