“Buffalo cauliflower: slightly crispy, spicy buffalo sauce, big cauliflower pieces, good for sharing, good ranch sauceMushroom pizza: soggy in the middle, good crust, plenty of mushrooms, good flavorsGarlic pizza: garlicky good, not soggy in the middle, crust was a bit burnt“
“This is hit or miss depending on if you order delivery. The good is always good but delivery drivers (Door Dash) tend to stack orders for delivery and if you aren't first then it's cold. This is no fault of the restaurant. Just more reason to dine in. Dining in here is always a great experience. The staff and food are amazing.“
“My daughter wanted Stromboli instead of pizza for a change, and we found this place online. We were very happy with everything we ordered- Stromboli, lasagna, meatball sub, potato skins, and cheesy garlic bread. Everything tasted great! It was ready for pick up on time, even though they seemed to be short staffed they were making a huge effort to get everyone's food orders out at the time they promised. They work really hard for their customers and it shows.The only suggestion I would make is to maybe pare down the menu a bit. There are a LOT of choices and I think it would benefit them to focus on a theme, like just Italian American food while keeping the Halal versions also available for those who follow that diet (it's awesome that customers have this option. I don't think there are many around Columbus). For instance, the hamburgers stood out on the menu since they dont really fit in with a pizza place. Also, all the different types of pizza and Stromboli and such gets a little repetative. Slimming down the menu could keep both the customers and the staff from getting overwhelmed by too many items.Now that we know Luna is a short drive away, we will be definitely adding it to our restaurant list. The food was tasty and the serving sizes were large. I definitely recommend them.“
“Heard a lot about and decided to try even though all the way on the other side of town. I was there with 2 companions. Nice selection of soft drinks coke and Pepsi products which are served in a can with a glass of ice. I ordered a Bambino (7”) mushroom and my companions ordered a medium sausage and pep. The pizza didn’t do it for me but just because it was t my style doesn’t mean it’s a bad pizza. My pizza came pie cut which I prefer. Thin and crunchy. I prefer thicker softer and doughier. Cheesy . What sauce I could taste be each the cheese wasn’t sweet - which was another positive for me. My companions said that the sausage and pep had no taste. One didn’t even want to take the leftovers home. Again a lot of people have rated this place very high - personal taste. Service was good but server not very personable. Also on the menu were salads, subs and homemade pasta dishes.. I’m glad we ventured out to try . If you’re in the area definitely check it out .“
“HUGE shoutout to the guy working tonight, Friday, February 9! He was the only person working and still took the time to give a pleasant greeting despite the crazy busyness, phone ringing off the hook, etc. He was clearly cranking out a ton of pizza, and my very large order was hot and ready to go when I arrived. THANK YOU for all of your hard work.“
“I ordered takeout online yesterday for the first time and I have definitely become a long term customer! Everything was great, from the ease of ordering, to the friendliness of the staff, to the quality of the food.I have been trying several different pizza restaurants around the Columbus area since moving here and this is by far my favorite place.The pizza is phenomenal. I love the sauce, flavorful, but not acidic, and not too sweet. The cheese tastes like it is higher quality, and the pepperoni was amazing. I also absolutely loved the thin crust! It has a nice crunch, but is also slightly chewy. It's exactly how I want my pizza to be.Their salad was also very good. Tons of toppings and the house made ranch dressing is very good! It's so much better than prepackaged vinegary ranch that a lot of places use.Overall, I can't wait to come back and try more of the menu!“
“My first time at this place. I was in town for an appointment. I've never had crust on a pizza be so fluffy and fresh. This pizza was delicious. It doesn't taste like any other pizza that I've tried here in Ohio. I wish this place was closer to me.“
“We ordered 4 cornered Veggies pizza in the store. We hardly wait for 15 mins before getting delicious pizza in hand. Service was prompt and we got all the information we asked from friendly person at the counter. Pizza was too good! We tried first time and we will definitely try it again.“
“We've had Brenz several times from different locations and are never disappointed! One of the best pizza places in Columbus. The crust is so flavorful, and I love that they have a wide variety of unique specialty pizzas! The Heater is a family favorite. We tried their cookies for the first time, and they were fabulous! They're soft-baked, which I prefer.There's not much seating at this location - just counters and two small tables - so keep that in mind if you plan to eat in.The service was fantastic! The staff is super friendly, and our food came out very quickly, especially considering we hadn't ordered ahead.“
“I come here once a week because the pizzas and strombolis are always good and consistent. My normal a slice of pepperoni and if they have the spinach ricotta stromboli out, i always get it. Staff here are really friendly and know me by my name. If you're around the area and are craving a quick bite, this is the place to visit. It is inside a turkey hill though, but that shouldn't matter.“
“They have completely changed this location its really clean and some cool add on things are the screen on the floor that reacts to who walks on it had chucky all dressed up and on the floor great place take yr family there for a party i did and will againKid-friendliness: Great place for kids“
“I was looking for something remotely healthy to eat in the bridge park north market and saw that the pizzeria offered salads. I got the Mama G’s salad. Nothing special, however it was freshly made and came with vinaigrette that I thought was good! The salad was $12.95.“
“Fantastic food. My ONLY complaint is that pricing is a little aggressive: a medium 1-topping, a medium 3-topping and a garlic cheese bread came to over $46.00. Don't get me wrong... it was fantastic, but the price just seemed a little strong.“
“I ordered a large fry, disappointed at first because the price was $6.44... but then when received the order my mind changed right away. It was a full size plate full of amazing fries that I can’t stop thinking about now lol ? also had halal pepperoni pizza which was very yummy also.“
“Ordered a pizza and cheese bread shortly before closing during the week, but they didn't seem bothered by the late order. Ordered a thin Works pizza and Garlic Asiago Cheese Bread. I enjoyed how thin and crispy the crust was made. There was a nice mix of ingredients that were generously spread over every inch.“
“Mouth watering pizza if I wasn't so full I'd get some more. Adam went above and beyond to make sure the pizza was made the way I wanted. A good spot to be in, conveniently located and if you wanted to enjoy it there they even have a spot to sit down. I'll definitely be back!Thanks again Adam!!“
“This might be our favorite pizza place, and this location is top notch! They are always fast and the pizza is always perfect. We also love grabbing a bottle of ranch with our order too. Not only the pizza is always perfect, but their boneless wings are also always fantastic!“
Recommended
“We came across Missing Jimmy's while walking around historic Dublin, but the shopping area they are located in does have its own parking lot. Fun place full of TVs showing sports, a foosball table, and some nice Christmas decor for the season. They serve up Meatball Mafia food, and it smelled great in there. We got the Nicky Santoro meatball subs to go. It was well packaged. The food was great - so flavorful, great kick from the hot giardiniera. Service was quick. We will definitely stop by again.“