9 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

Brenz Pizza Co New Albany Pizza • $
4963 E Dublin Granville Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Half Pepperoni and Half Meatball
Bread Sticks w Marinara Sauce
Brenz Bomber with Pepporoni
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Heritage Honey Pizza
Homemade Cookies
Mushroom Pizza
Plain Wings

“Today was my first day at a Brenz Pizza Co. I got the chicken bacon ranch. This is definitely my absolute favorite pizza! Godfathers in Chillicothe back in the early 2000s, Cristy's Pizza in Chillicothe now, both amazing and loved them both! But those taste like Pizza Hut Little Caesars comparatively speaking! and any bigger chain of pizza shops like Donatos or any others, they obviously don't compare to Brenz Pizza Co. If those 2 classics don't.
I cannot believe I've never heard of this place until driving around looking for places to eat. Such a nice staff! Such a clean and uncluttered environment! No 50 flyers and adds all over the place, no gimmicky characters. And let me tell you right now! If you like cookies, you cannot leave without one! I had the chocolate chip and it was so huge and cooked to absolute perfection! That chocolate was so sweet! I also loved their salad, I just had the simple house salad and it looked and tasted fresher that any salad I've gotten at a restaurant let alone a pizza shop! I could go on and on but I'll just end it here by saying... GO TRY IT!

Dietary restrictions: My wife is gluten free and and that had amazing options for that! And her pizza there was a few bucks cheaper than the cauliflower crust at Donatos!“

4.5 Superb131 Reviews
The Eagles Villa Pizza Pizza • $
2 N High St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Extra Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Barbecue Chicken Pizza
Pep Extra Cheese Pizza
All the Way Pizza
Baked Spaghetti
Fried Mushrooms
All Meat Pizza
Boneless Wings
Chicken Salad

“Great pizza , meatballs and salad customer service is Great and very professional. I will always come back!!“

4.5 Superb115 Reviews
Zero's Pizza Pizza • $
5535 New Albany Rd W, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

B B Q Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“Zeros is amazing. Their delivery man was so kind and the food was fantastic. It’s a Friday night and they’re super busy but the food was still delivered steaming hot. I wanted a sub that wasn’t on their menu and they went out of their way to build it for me and it tasted amazing. The wings were incredible and the meat just fell off the bone. I recommend zeros any day!“

4.7 Superb37 Reviews
Beerhead Bar & Eatery Pizza • $
6294 E Dublin Granville Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Downeast Cider House Original Blend
Bourbon Trail Meatballs
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pico Just in Queso
Nashville Sliders
Garlic Parm Fries
Chicagoland Pizza
Street Corn Pizza
Barbarian Pretzel
Pepperoni Pizza

“Great bar and outdoor patio. Staff was great!“

4.1 Good69 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
5310 N Hamilton Rd, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico Pizza
Steak & Cheese Bruno Sub
Fiery Pepperoni Pizza
The Big Cheese Pizza
Deluxe Pizza Bowl
Italiano Sub

“Love Hamilton road branch. So far, we haven't had a single complaint from this location. Every other location had messed up our order several times. I had one location a few mins from my home, but I drive 20-30mins to Hamilton instead.
Keep up the great work. ??“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
6

Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza • $
9880 Johnstown Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Not Just Pizzas Sbarro Offers Stuffed Strombolis Too
Pepperoni Pizza Slice and Italian Sub
Individual Pepperoni Stromboli
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Individual Spinach Stromboli
Spaghetti with Meatballs
NY Pepperoni Slice
Meatball in Sauce
4 Cheese Pizza
Roman Pizza

“I was in this morning about 10:15 and got a piece of pizza and a Stromboli and both were super fresh and absolutely delicious 10/10 will definitely be back I left out before updating this how the crew was super friendly and super enthusiastic“

4.1 Good36 Reviews
Mellow Mushroom New Albany Pizza • $
260 Market St Ste A, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Calzone
Spinach Artichoke Dip
GF Kosmic Karma Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Holy Shiitake Pie
Buffalo Chicken
Bruschetta
Craft Beer
Pretzels
Cloud 9

“Love the handcrafted pizzas“

3.9 Good128 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $$
7356 Fodor Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Pizza

“Love the lunch special! Great food and fast & friendly delivery! My office orders lunch from here at least once a week!“

3.4 Good25 Reviews
Roosters Chicken Wings • $
5511 New Albany Rd W, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken Sandwich
Onion Feathers
Boneless Wings
Dumpster Fries
Fried Pickles
Chicken Wings
Curly Fries
Dressing
Burger
Nachos

“First time visit. I'm from Virginia and my Columbus family told me this was their fav place to eat out. My waitress was Very Nice, and polite with a sincere, pretty smile. She suggested that the wings are their specialty and are better if ordered "well done" so I did and they tasted great!!“

4 Good72 Reviews

You May Also Like