35 Best Italian Restaurants near New Albany

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants near New Albany.

Showing 35 of 35 restaurants

  • New Albany 9880 Johnstown Road, New Albany Pizza · $

    1 New Albany

    4.0 Good 112 Reviews

    9880 Johnstown Road, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Not Just Pizzas Sbarro Offers Stuffed Strombolis Too
    • Pepperoni Pizza Slice and Italian Sub
    • Single Topping Pizza & 10 Wings
    • Individual Pepperoni Stromboli

    “Traveling through from Michigan where we have very few Sbarro locations outside of malls. Delicious food, very clean restaurant, and an employee with a wonderfully positive and friendly demeanor. Kudos to him (and whoever hired him). This young man deserves a raise. Talked about their freshly shredded cheese and the freshness of the entire process. He sold me on an old favorite! A+ visit, thanks for having us!”

  • Marco's Pizza 5310 North Hamilton Road, Columbus Pizza · $

    2 Marco's Pizza

    3.6 Good 162 Reviews

    5310 North Hamilton Road, Columbus

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pepperoni Magnifico Pizza
    • Steak & Cheese Bruno Sub
    • Fiery Pepperoni Pizza
    • The Big Cheese Pizza

    “Always hot! Always cooked to perfection! Our household favorite!! :)”

  • Lola & Giuseppe's Trattoria 100 Granville Street, Columbus Italian · $$

    3 Lola & Giuseppe's Trattoria

    4.8 Superb 456 Reviews

    100 Granville Street, Columbus · 5.72 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Bread Pudding with Whiskey Sauce
    • Chicken Marsala with Risotto
    • Spaghetti & Meatball
    • Shrimp & Lobster Ravioli

    “My family had the pleasure of dining at Lola & Giuseppe's last evening, and it truly was a pleasure! We began with wedding soup (some of the best I have ever tasted), a Guiseppe's Salad, and spinach-artichoke dip. Two of our group had the meat lasagna which was delicious and a huge serving. Other entrees included egg plant parmigana and chicken marsala. All were excellent, large servings, and very reasonably priced. The surprise (and a good one) was the Creme de Limocello that was bursting with lemon flavor and a nice little nip. Service was excellent and the owner stopped by to chat on two occasions thanking us for dining there. It was undoubtedly one of the most enjoyable dining experiences we have had in quite a while. Highly recommend!”

  • Pasqualone's 5766 Emporium Square, Columbus Italian · $$

    4 Pasqualone's

    4.8 Superb 208 Reviews

    5766 Emporium Square, Columbus · 7.38 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Veal Loaf Heavy on the Mushrooms
    • Spaghetti & Meatballs
    • Spaghetti & Meatballs
    • Lemon Cake of the Day

    “This is our happy place. When there is a special family celebration, we come here. Love walking in, as David greets us at the door every time. It’s like visiting your Nonna and Nonno’s house and seeing all of your cousins and knowing that you’re in store for the best meal ever. Look forward to a leisurely feast with good wine, warm bread and some of the best Italian dishes we’ve found. The entire staff is incredible. Be sure to make a reservation because every time we go it’s a full house.”

  • Scali 1903 OH-256, Reynoldsburg Italian · $$

    5 Scali

    4.6 Superb 275 Reviews

    1903 OH-256, Reynoldsburg · 9.48 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta
    • Lasagna and Shrimp Oreganata
    • Spaghetti and Meatballs
    • Vitello Saltimbocca

    “Oh my.. fantastic food and service, best linguini and clams or penne with sausage!! Have to complement Michelle on great service! Nice wine list!! Carryout or dine in five stars!!!!”

  • Toni's Trattoria 19 West Columbus Street, Galena Italian · $$

    6 Toni's Trattoria

    4.7 Superb 101 Reviews

    19 West Columbus Street, Galena · 9.97 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Mushroom and Roasted Garlic
    • Spaghetti and Meatballs
    • Lemon Blueberry Bread
    • Seasonal Bruschetta

    “Fabulous food, great wine selection, excellent service, atmosphere friendly & warm!”

  • Cardone's Restaurant & Bar 377 West Main Street, Westerville Italian · $$

    7 Cardone's Restaurant & Bar

    4.5 Superb 216 Reviews

    377 West Main Street, Westerville · 7.83 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Stuffed Portobello Mushrooms
    • Cacio E Pepe with Shrimp
    • Spaghetti and Meatballs
    • Osso Buco Di Cardone

    “Food was great . Had spaghetti with meatballs and short rib ragu all I have to say is wow. David was very nice and had really nice suggestions and was new a lot about the wines we were interested in definitely will be back soon”

  • Fazoli's 807 South State Street, Westerville Italian · $

    8 Fazoli's

    4.4 Superb 371 Reviews

    807 South State Street, Westerville · 6.4 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • 12 Signature Garlic Breadsticks with Large Dipping Sauce
    • Small Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
    • New York Style with Strawberries
    • Pepperoni Pizza Breadsticks

    “Had a filling and delicious meal! We planned our stops on a trip south and back so we could eat at Fazolis’ since there are none where we live. Wish they would expand north into New York State!”

  • TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia 1210 South James Road, Columbus Italian · $$

    9 TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia

    4.4 Superb 357 Reviews

    1210 South James Road, Columbus · 10.85 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Cacciatore with Spaghetti and Tomato Sauce
    • Homemade Spaghetti with Meatball
    • Breast of Chicken Parmigiana
    • Triple Layer Chocolate Cake

    “I brought 14 travelers in on a bus trip with 1018 Travels this morning. Called last minute and we had a beautiful table set for us when we got there. The food was amazing but the server was so sweet! We asked about the history and he answered . What a great place, will be back for sure”

  • Giammarco's Italian Restaurant 6030 Chandler Court, Westerville Italian · $$

    10 Giammarco's Italian Restaurant

    4.3 Superb 610 Reviews

    6030 Chandler Court, Westerville · 7.77 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Italian Bread and Seasoned Olive Oil
    • Chicken Parmesan Sub
    • Fettuccini Alfredo
    • Italiano Stromboli

    “Beautiful atmosphere. Jessica was a super friendly, timely and attentive waiter. Had six totally different dishes and each was hot and delicious. Particularly loved the stromboli w/spicy sausage, seared shrimp in Alfredo, the (light) calamari and delicate gnocchi.”

  • Piada Italian Street Food 4025 Easton Station, Columbus Italian · $

    11 Piada Italian Street Food

    4.3 Superb 380 Reviews

    4025 Easton Station, Columbus · 5.98 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Create Your Own Grilled Chicken
    • Blackberry Hibiscus Lemonade
    • Carbonara Pasta with Chicken
    • Italian Chop Chop Salad

    “Great place and food! I’ve been getting the Chefs Favorite w/chicken. Bomb every time! I prefer getting food here than getting Chipotle.”

  • Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen 6000 Westerville Road, Westerville Italian · $

    12 Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen

    4.3 Superb 323 Reviews

    6000 Westerville Road, Westerville · 6.2 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Carsonie's Ultimate Loaded Fries
    • Everyone's Favorite Stromboli
    • The Original Stromboli
    • Spaghetti & Meatballs

    “Delicious pasta! I ordered the carsonies pasta and an extra meatball. This was my first time ordering here and think meatballs and sauce really tell a lot about how good the meal will be. Also got the chicken carsonies. I would suggest more white sauce and better service”

  • Giuseppe's Ritrovo 2268 East Main Street, Columbus Italian · $$

    13 Giuseppe's Ritrovo

    4.3 Superb 238 Reviews

    2268 East Main Street, Columbus · 10.96 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Whole Wheat & Gluten Free Pizza
    • Beef Short Rib with Gnocchi
    • Spaghetti and Meatballs
    • Penne Pollo Fiorentino

    “We were very impressed. Their Gluten free options were amazingly delicious, they took it seriously and everything was fresh, seasoned to perfection, and we will be going back. The portions were large, the presentation was immaculate, the wine and cocktail list was the stuff of dreams and legends. The restaurant was cozy and comfortable in a sexy Italian style. It could have come to life off the page of Conde Nast Traveler. Hidden jewel of Ohio worthy of the drive. The staff was professional and very welcoming. We loved it!”

  • Fazoli's 6830 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg Italian · $

    14 Fazoli's

    4.2 Good 272 Reviews

    6830 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg · 8.72 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sampler Platter Alfredo Spaghetti and Meat Sauce Lasagnas
    • Pumpkin Cheesecake from the Cheesecake Factory Bakery
    • Cheesecake Factory Bakery Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake
    • Breadsticks with No Garlic Butter

    “This was our first time trying this place last week, and we had such a great experience! The tall girl with black hair working the drive-thru was absolutely amazing. She was so friendly, patient, and genuinely wanted to make sure we got something we would enjoy. She took the time to help us decide and really went above and beyond to make our first experience a good one. Customer service like hers definitely makes a difference! We’ll definitely be coming back! ❤”

  • Piada Italian Street Food 4697 Morse Road, Columbus Italian · $

    15 Piada Italian Street Food

    4.2 Good 394 Reviews

    4697 Morse Road, Columbus · 3.57 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Grilled Chicken Alfredo Pasta with Parmesan Cheese
    • Steak Pasta Bowl with Alfredo and Red Sauce
    • Power Bowl with Grilled Salmon
    • The Farmers Market Salad

    “Great food for lunch and the patio area is a plus. 😊”

  • Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 4860 North Hamilton Road, Columbus Italian · $$

    16 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

    4.2 Good 403 Reviews

    4860 North Hamilton Road, Columbus · 3.33 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
    • Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
    • Eggplant Parmigiana Breadstick Sandwich
    • Never-Ending Soup Salad & Breadsticks

    “Our waitress was Shauna and she was incredible!!! Give her a raise! She was the reason our experience was a 10/10. She was quick and efficient with our order but never made it feel like a rush. Very kind and attentive and quickly brought any refills we asked for. She truly was so great and had a fun personality. :)”

  • Piada Italian Street Food 2585 East Main Street, Columbus Italian · $

    17 Piada Italian Street Food

    4.2 Good 456 Reviews

    2585 East Main Street, Columbus · 10.7 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hot Fried Chicken w Spicy Tomato Sauce and Extra Pesto
    • Carbonara Pasta with Grilled Chicken
    • The Farmers Market Salad
    • Crispy Chicken blt Piada

    “I already love Piada, but I especially love this location! I’m a creature of habit, so I usually order my same wrap or pasta bowl online and hit the pickup window. But every now and then I go inside, and the team is always so friendly and my food is consistently great. If there’s a Customer of the Year award, I feel like I should be a strong contender.”

  • Minico's Italian Restaurant 1180 County Line Rd, Westerville Italian · $

    18 Minico's Italian Restaurant

    4.0 Good 64 Reviews

    1180 County Line Rd, Westerville · 5.56 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Garlic Bread and Marinara Sauce
    • Spaghetti and Meatball
    • Breaded Mushrooms
    • Chicken Parmesan

    “Love this restaurant!! Must try!”

  • Milano's | Italian Restaurant 6916 East Broad Street, Columbus Italian · $$

    19 Milano's | Italian Restaurant

    4.1 Good 343 Reviews

    6916 East Broad Street, Columbus · 6.74 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Prime Rib Au Jus Friday & Saturday with One Side Dish
    • House Salad with Italian Dressing
    • Homemade Cheese Manicotti
    • Chicken Parmigiana

    “I dined here for the first time yesterday and order the Fettuccine Alfredo w/chicken and a Caesar salad…both were absolutely delicious, the flavor was amazing and so was the Moscato wine which had the perfect amount of sweetness that I like! The breadsticks were amazing, they melt in your mouth. My server Aaron, was excellent, great personality with a wonderful sense of humor! I will definitely be back and will be making Milanos a regular place to have dinner! If you’ve never been here, I totally recommend giving Milano’s a try!!!”

  • Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House 558 West Schrock Road, Westerville Pizza · $

    20 Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta House

    4.5 Superb 288 Reviews

    558 West Schrock Road, Westerville · 7.53 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Garlic Bread with a Side of House-Made Marinara
    • Spaghetti and Meatball with Garlic Twist Bread
    • House-Made Garlic Twists
    • Pepperoni Sausage Pizza

    “Best pizza I have ever had”

  • Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli 4434 Westerville Road, Columbus Pizza · $

    21 Buckeye Pizza & Stromboli

    4.5 Superb 282 Reviews

    4434 Westerville Road, Columbus · 6.77 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Build Your Own Stromboli - Small 10
    • Chicken Veggie Stromboli
    • 2 Large Pepperoni Pizza
    • Build Your Own Pizza

    “Great food and people would Definitely go back”

  • Center Village Pizza 3699 OH-605, Galena Recommended Pizza · $

    22 Center Village Pizza

    4.5 Superb 211 Reviews

    3699 OH-605, Galena · 5.85 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • House Pizza S 15 99 M 18 99 L 22 99
    • Taco Pizza S 14 99 M 17 99 L 20 99
    • Large Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
    • Homemade Italian Wedding Soup

    “Fracssos Hot Honey pizza is incredible, you have to try it!!”

  • Brio Italian Grille 3993 Easton Station, Columbus Italian · $$

    23 Brio Italian Grille

    4.1 Good 1,055 Reviews

    3993 Easton Station, Columbus · 6.05 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Gorgonzola Crusted Beef Medallions
    • Strawberry Balsamic Chicken Salad
    • Mezza Grilled Chicken Marsala
    • Shrimp and Lobster Fettuccine

    “Everything we had was AMAZING!!! You gotta try it for yourself.”

  • Koble Grill 7 North State Street, Westerville Greek · $

    24 Koble Grill

    4.4 Superb 334 Reviews

    7 North State Street, Westerville · 7.21 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Italian Panini and Fries
    • Seafood Flatbread
    • Grilled Octopus
    • Stuffed Peppers

    “This was my first visit to Koble Grill and will not be my last. I plan on returning real soon. Lea was our server and she was FANTASTIC. We had a party of 4 and everyone loved their food. We got 2 bottles of wine because on Sunday the wine were marked down. We just had a wonderful time and Please thank Lea for us”

  • Antonio's 7001 Sunbury Rd # C, Westerville Pizza · $

    25 Antonio's

    4.5 Superb 140 Reviews

    7001 Sunbury Rd # C, Westerville · 5.92 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Italian Sub with Double Meat
    • Spaghetti and Meatballs
    • Individual Pizza Ready
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    “Oh...my...gosh. The pizza is DELICIOUS. We've had quite a few different pizzas over the years living in Ohio but this was the best we've had. The pepperoni rolls were also amazing. Whatever they're doing explains the awards they've won for their pizzas. It was a long wait for pick up this evening but well worth it. I highly recommend this place!”

  • Rubino's Pizza 2643 East Main Street, Columbus Pizza · $

    26 Rubino's Pizza

    4.4 Superb 307 Reviews

    2643 East Main Street, Columbus · 10.68 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Sausage Onion Green Pepper & Double Pep
    • Pepperoni Sausage and Mushroom Pizza
    • Pepperoni Sausage and Black Olives
    • Large Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza

    “Wonderful establishment. Wonderful staff. Delicious pizza. Anyone who says otherwise are clowns…”

  • Lola & Giuseppe's Bakery 104 Granville Street, Columbus Bakery · $

    27 Lola & Giuseppe's Bakery

    4.6 Superb 49 Reviews

    104 Granville Street, Columbus · 5.62 miles

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hummingbird Cake

    “Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.”

  • Massey's Pizza - Gahanna 261 Lincoln Circle, Columbus Pizza · $

    28 Massey's Pizza - Gahanna

    4.2 Good 227 Reviews

    261 Lincoln Circle, Columbus · 5.54 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Large Pepperoni Pizza and Parmesan Garlic Wings
    • Parmesan Cheese Breadsticks with Marinara Sauce
    • Garlic Cheese Bread
    • Mozzarella Sticks

    “Good food, fun family place!”

  • Angelina's Villa 5450 East Livingston Avenue, Columbus Pizza · $

    29 Angelina's Villa

    4.2 Good 234 Reviews

    5450 East Livingston Avenue, Columbus · 9.74 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheese Sticks and Garlic Bread with Cheese
    • Pepperoni Pizza w Xtra Cheese and Sauce
    • Oven Baked Hot or Honey BBQ Wings
    • Buffalo Chips with Cheese & Bacon

    “they been around for a very long time and there a family owned community pizza shop.”

  • Massey's Pizza Westerville 399 South State Street, Westerville Pizza · $

    30 Massey's Pizza Westerville

    4.0 Good 221 Reviews

    399 South State Street, Westerville · 6.72 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • 1 2 Italian Sub and Dinner Salad
    • Large Pepperoni Pizza
    • Massey's Pizza
    • Taco Pizza

    “delivery in NC coast awesome pizza grew up with Massey pizza”

  • Sbarro Cleveland Ave 6195 Cleveland Avenue, Columbus Pizza · $

    31 Sbarro Cleveland Ave

    3.4 Good 42 Reviews

    6195 Cleveland Avenue, Columbus · 7.62 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Individual Pepperoni Stromboli
    • NY Pepperoni Slice

    “Yummy Hawaiian pizza style I’ll buy more soon”

  • Creno's Pizza Johnstown 705 West Coshocton Street, Johnstown Pizza Delivery · $

    32 Creno's Pizza Johnstown

    3.8 Good 127 Reviews

    705 West Coshocton Street, Johnstown · 7.21 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheesy Garlic Flatbread Large
    • Deluxe Pizza Extra Large
    • Sugardale blt Pizza Large
    • Deluxe Pizza Large

    “I wanted to give it two tries before I posted a review because every pizza shop goes through its high and lows. As a person who grew up on the OG Crenos in Zanesville, this place has lived up to the expectations. Pizza is great, as always, but if you like a crispy crust, get it well done. This is something I do most places these days, though. But the main point is the Italian sub. It’s so simple but so balanced. I don’t know how else to explain it, it’s just very good. I’ve been to several different crenos locations, some that have not made it for whatever reason. So bravo to the manager of this store.”

  • Jet's Pizza 55 McNaughten Road, Columbus Pizza · $

    33 Jet's Pizza

    3.7 Good 210 Reviews

    55 McNaughten Road, Columbus · 7.2 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pepperoni Mushroom and Sausage Pizza
    • Pepperoni and Bacon 4 Corners
    • Cauliflower Crust Pizza
    • Chocolate Brownie

    “First time ordering delivery as I just moved in this area in May , Pizza was the best so far for me in this area, however I asked for extra cheese well , use to cheese being gooey and plentiful and I ordered a Sprite and got. Coca Cola, but overall I will definitely make this my go to. Pizza was delicious 😘😘”

  • Sbarro 160 Easton Town Ctr, Columbus Pizza · $

    34 Sbarro

    3.3 Good 117 Reviews

    160 Easton Town Ctr, Columbus · 6.02 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Not Just Pizzas Sbarro Offers Stuffed Strombolis Too
    • Individual Pepperoni Sausage and Bacon Stromboli
    • 17 XL NY 1 Topping Pizza 6 Breadsticks
    • Four Cheese White NY Style Pizza

    “Loved my food but staff was rude to.my friend and me both., did not really seem.to want to help.us or even be there 🤨😒😕😞☹”

  • Romeo's Pizza 5733 Maxtown Road, Westerville Pizza · $

    35 Romeo's Pizza

    3.2 Average 162 Reviews

    5733 Maxtown Road, Westerville · 7.54 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Italiano Deep Dish Pizza
    • Pepperoni Pizza
    • Italian Salad
    • Garlic Bread

    “Good is always done well and the staff has always been very pleasant, only downfall which I’m unsure is with the staff or the app, is that expect the wait time to be 15-30 minutes longer than what is told to you on the app. If you already know that though, then you can plan accordingly.”

Italian Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Una Pizza Napoletana Pizzeria Named Best in the World for 2024

    Una Pizza Napoletana Pizzeria Named Best in the World for 2024

    Una Pizza Napoletana, a popular spot in New York, has just been named the best pizza in the world by the 2024 Italian 50 Top Pizza ranking. This is a major victory for owner Anthony Mangieri, who has already earned the title of best pizza in the U.S. for three years in a row.

  • Italian Pizza Chain Rosso Pomodoro Makes Its American Debut in Denver

    Italian Pizza Chain Rosso Pomodoro Makes Its American Debut in Denver

    Naples-born Rosso Pomodoro has landed in Denver. The Italian pizza franchise just opened its first U.S. location in the city's Central Park neighborhood at 29th Ave Town Center. "It has long been a dream to introduce our brand of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza to every corner of America,” CEO Nicola Saraceno shared his excitement.

  • 100-Year-Old Pizzeria Seeks New Owner, Bans Pineapple

    100-Year-Old Pizzeria Seeks New Owner, Bans Pineapple

    Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, a 100-year-old Coney Island eatery, is looking for a buyer or partner to keep its legacy alive, but it has one important condition. Totonno's has made it through fires, floods, and even COVID, but there's one thing they'll never tolerate: pineapple on their pizza.