26 Best Italian Restaurants near Reynoldsburg

1
Scali

Scali Italian • $$
1903 OH-256, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta
Lasagna and Shrimp Oreganata
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Linguini with Clams
Vitello Saltimbocca
Stuffed Mushrooms
Penne Arrabiata
Chicken Alfredo
Artichoke Salad
Vitello Marsala

“Came here for a family birthday with an infant. We made reservations a week in advance. Everything was delicious! They are busy, but staff was friendly and informative. We had the peasant tortellini with chicken, ravioli special, chicken parm, and veal saltimbocca. We enjoyed their featured wine and cheesecake, gelato, and lemon cake for dessert. We would definitely come back. Considering how delicious and homemade everything is prices were reasonable.Kid-friendliness: We had an infant and used a high chair. The high chair was clean.“

4.5 Superb63 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
2439 Taylor Square Dr, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti & Meatballs with Meat Sauce 680 Cal
Shrimp and Chicken Carbonara
Classic Shrimp Scampi Fritta
Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Spinach-Artichoke Dip
Bread Sticks and Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Stuffed Mushrooms

“We always get a good meal and amazing service at this Olive Garden!!! Autumn Cossin is my most favorite server. She always a smile and anticipates our needs! My favorite bar tender is Eden! She is amazing!! The manager John Pompa runs a clean restaurant and is a bad @ss!! I highly recommend!!!“

4 Good119 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
6830 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Sampler Platter Alfredo Spaghetti and Meat Sauce Lasagnas
Pumpkin Cheesecake from the Cheesecake Factory Bakery
Cheesecake Factory Bakery Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
New Pepperoni & Bacon Flatbread
Cinnamon Swirl Breadstick Bites
Cheesy Double-Stack Lasagna
Philly Cheesesteak Ravioli
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Garlic Chicken Ravioli

“I've gone thru drive thru before fairly late.. food wasn't very good so I was hesitant. I was pleasantly surprised.. the food, service and lunch special were all wonderful! Would have gotten 5 stars but they have the parking lot blocked off for what seems to be no reasonParking: Parking lot is mostly blocked off for what looked to be no reasonKid-friendliness: Brought extra plate for toddler to share our food, booster seats available and clean“

3.9 Good59 Reviews
Lola & Giuseppe's Trattoria Italian • $$
100 Granville St, Columbus - 5.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bread Pudding with Whiskey Sauce
Shrimp & Lobster Ravioli
Cup Sicilian Onion Soup
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Italian Wedding Soup
Eggplant Parmigiana
Fresh Garlic Bread
French Onion Soup
Mushroom Ravioli
Chicken Parmesan

“Money well spent. Best tasting, best value meal in the city IMO. The service was unbelievably fast! Couple fun facts, don’t expect to walk in, have your reservation made. We saw multiple people get turned away (even single diners). It took me a month to get a reservation at the time I wanted (reservations online only). It’s important to level set yourself, you’ll need to plan to eat here. It’s also important to share you can order take out starting at 4:30 and will go as long as they can keep up. ( expect to go orders to fill up quickly and not be available later in the day). The only way you will be able walk in will be during patio season- may the odds be ever in your favor.“

4.8 Superb101 Reviews
Rubinos Pizza Pizza • $
2643 E Main St, Columbus - 6.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Onion Green Pepper & Double Pep
Pepperoni Sausage and Black Olives
Large Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Thin Crust Pizza
Large with Pepperoni and Peppers
Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Large Extra Cheese Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Ravioli Marinara
The Pizza for Me

“We love this place. The pizza is so good. It’s very thin crust, so….it doesn’t go as far as you would think. It’s pretty easy for 2-3 people to eat a large.Parking: The actual parking lot is very small. You can park free in the side streets.“

4.6 Superb74 Reviews
Little Italy Ristorante Pizza • $
480 Main St, Groveport - 8.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Wings with Ranch Dressing
Sicilian Pepperoni Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatball
Fettuccine El Forno
Meatball Mozzarella
Homemade Spaghetti
Extra Cheesy Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Italian Dressing
Chicken Parmesan

“My family has ordered from Little Italy since I was a kid, though I haven’t had their food in a long time.I haven’t had their food since their recent transfer to the new building, so I was excited to see that this was the choice for dinner tonight.Looking over the menu that was brought home, it’s obvious that Little Italy has made a big shift from that delightful hole-in-the-wall vibe that I remember.I’m looking forward to checking out more of the menu options.Tonight’s pizzas were delicious. Just right. No complaints!“

4.5 Superb111 Reviews
Giuseppe's Ritrovo Italian • $$
2268 E Main St, Columbus - 6.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Whole Wheat & Gluten Free Pizza
Beef Short Rib with Gnocchi
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Smoked Chicken Ravioli
Short Rib and Gnocchi
Classic Caesar Salad
Fettucine Calabrese
Giuseppes Tiramisu
Asparagus Ravioli
Linguine Vongole

“Sierra was an awesome server. The brushetta had two cheeses that were perfect choices to complement the generous amount of diced tomatoes. The meat lasagna melting in my mouth and was delicately delicious! Triple layer chocolate cake for dessert served with a candle for my birthday presentation was decadent and easily satisfied the three forks in our party, who all had little room left in their stomachs. Well done team Giuseppe!“

4.5 Superb66 Reviews
Pasqualone's Italian • $$$
5766 Emporium Square, Columbus - 11.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veal Loaf Heavy on the Mushrooms
Chicken Parmigiano
Chicken Parmesan
Veal Parmigiano
Veal Marsala
Escargot
Ravioli
Lasagna
Cannoli

“Is it fair to be more critical of an expensive restaurant than a mid-priced or inexpensive one? I think so. For a dinner for two that cost $190 (including the tip), I expect near perfection. First, I think they kind of forgot about us as we were a table of two in the corner. After we noticed that some folks who had come in after us were already getting their bread, my husband signaled someone and then we finally got ours, too, and his wine - which I think they also forgot about. He should've gotten that right away. It didn't have to bake. Then he got his Escargot which was bubbling hot and smelled delicious. Our salads came - nice and fresh but too salty for my taste. We both enjoyed our entrees (veal parm and a side of spag for him; a special of little pasta purses with a meaty sauce for me) but mine arrived lukewarm. His was nice and hot so maybe mine sat around for a while while they finished his. At some point he ordered more wine and then coffee and dessert and he was very happy but I felt like the experience left a little bit to be desired - especially considering the price. One thing I don't like at all is that the waiter rattles off the specials (and there are a LOT of them) and later on the desserts at light speed. It would be way better to be able to read them and think for a minute or two. It's a very comfortable small restaurant and my husband loves it but I don't.“

4.5 Superb55 Reviews
The Berwick Banquet & Catering Italian • $$
3250 Refugee Rd, Columbus - 6.02 miles

“We had a Xmas party there on Sunday. Let me tell you this is BY FAR the best food I have had in a while. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this place for your wedding or get together. I was told they can accommodate parties 10+. They are not a full service restaurant. The filet mignon was cooked perfectly, mushroom risotto was flavorful, stuffed manicotti was the best I have tasted and the stuffed chicken was almost over powering with flavor. I wish they were a sit down restaurant. High marks for the chef and staff..“

4.5 Superb55 Reviews
Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian • $$
1755 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan and Angel Hair Pasta
Chicken Penne Carbonara
Lobster Bisque Soup
Italian Wedding Soup
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Francaise
D Lobster Ravioli
Chicken Milanese
Chicken Marsala
Garlic Bread

“We recently dined at O’mezzo Italian Restaurant, a charming and unassuming eatery nestled among other shops in Pickerington. The small and quaint dining room exudes a cozy atmosphere. On a bustling Saturday evening, finding a seat proved a bit challenging amidst the crowd. While it wasn't clear whether we should wait for seating, we eventually approached the counter to inquire. Once seated, a prompt server attended to us.Exploring the menu, we opted for the chicken gnocchi, spaghetti and meatballs, and fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. It was a letdown to discover that bread and the starter salad came at an additional charge. While browsing the wine list, I found the red wine offerings somewhat limited.When our entrees arrived, our disappointment waned as the dishes proved to be truly delightful. The pasta boasted a perfect texture, and the meatballs accompanying the spaghetti were exceptional—among the best I've had in a restaurant. My fellow diners also raved about their choices. It's worth noting that the overall cost of the meal, considering the absence of included salad or bread, leaned toward the higher side for a non-chain, family restaurant.Despite these limitations, I would gladly return for dinner, now armed with this information. O’mezzo Italian Restaurant offers a worthwhile dining experience, especially for aficionados of Italian cuisine. The delicious entrees and cozy atmosphere make it a destination worth considering, despite a few minor shortcomings.“

4.4 Superb57 Reviews
Pizzeria New York Pizza • $
833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 4.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Sticks
Stuffed Shells
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Breadsticks
Meat Pizza
Pinwheels

“Just came to say the customer service here is wonderful. I had a small issue with a charge on my credit card and the owner of the business gave me her personal cell phone number, told me to message her the details, and even replied to my texts when she was on vacation out of the country!!“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews
Pizza Hot On The Spot Italian • $
Treehouse Ln, Canal Winchester - 3.26 miles

“Awesome & reasonably priced. Reminds me of Cassanos, for my fellow Dayton natives - just without salt on the crust. Nice little char on it if you’re into that sorta thing. Dangerous thing to have so close by ?Vegetarian options: Cheese pizza is available.“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Omezzo pasta bowl + Rice & Curry Halal Bistro Italian • $$
1757 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.19 miles

“Had dinner at Omezzo. Very homely and excellent food. Lobster ravioli (we took the appetizer version) was amazing! Lobster bisque was good. We also had Trio Omezzo which is a selection of three types of pastas on one plate (better to share as the portion is quite big). Overall delicious!“

4.5 Superb22 Reviews
TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia Italian • $
1210 S James Rd, Columbus - 5.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Spaghetti with Meatball
Breast of Chicken Parmigiana
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
The All Meaty One Pizza
Italian Wedding Soup
Eggplant Parmigiana
Homemade Cannoli
Special Lasagna
Salad Dressing
Dinner Salad

“Passing through the area and was craving Italian of which Columbus seemingly has 97 Italian restaurants...Settled on TAT Ristorante due to cozy look and have we have a 10yr old. Wow, so glad we did.This place is a throwback to traditional, Italian Sunday family eating.Calamari- light, tender with a homemade marinara.Wedding soup to die for. Salads in a chilled bowl with the light, crisp and bright vinegarette not to be skipped!I had a seafood lasagna special that l'll have dreams about, the cheeses were all crusty on the edges giving this texture beyond amazing.Aaaaaand we simply couldn't pass on dessert, the tiramisu was traditional comfort but.... The lemon cream cake is a light, airy lemony confection that I'll compare all future desserts to. Service was provided by someone I felt was family by the end of our meal! Lots of locals here, they know what's up. Hope to be back here again if I'm ever in Ohio again....!“

4.2 Good91 Reviews
The Corner: A Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
1751 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Jalapeno Burger
Italian Sandwich
Fresh Cut Fries
Italian Sub

“Got wings and mini-burgers. Both solid. Wing flavors are really good and seem like they're made in-house.Service from Byron was on point. Will definitely be back.Kid-friendliness: Never seen it too rowdy where I'd think there would be a problem. Maybe football games.Wheelchair accessibility: Ground level entrance, no stairs in the building.“

4.1 Good36 Reviews

16
Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza • $
9880 Johnstown Rd, New Albany - 9.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Not Just Pizzas Sbarro Offers Stuffed Strombolis Too
Pepperoni Pizza Slice and Italian Sub
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
NY Pepperoni Slice
Roman Pizza

“Amazing service, they always treat me like one of the homies. It's gas station pizza, so nothing out of this world but it'll do in a pinch, cheap and fulfilling. Typical gas station spot but the service is why I keep going back for late night pizza.“

4.1 Good32 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
1745 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico
Steak and Cheese
Build Your Own
Chicken Wings
Cinnasquares
Deluxe Pizza
Italian Chef
Cheezybread
Italiano

“I love me some Marco's Pizza. The subs are absolutely my favorite. I haven't had a bad pizza from here at all. Marco's provide quick service and my food is always hot and fresh every time. Hands down my one of my favorite spots. You will not be “

4 Good48 Reviews
Piada Italian Street Food Italian • $
4697 Morse Rd, Gahanna - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Alfredo Pasta with Parmesan Cheese
Steak Pasta Bowl with Alfredo and Red Sauce
Power Bowl with Grilled Salmon
Crispy Chicken blt Piada
The Farmers Market Salad
Italian Chop Chop Salad
Pepperoni Piada Stick
Vegan Build Your Own
Mediterranean Piada
Carbonara Pasta

“Stopped in for a quick, stress free dinner after work. Staff were upbeat, friendly and very accommodating for a picky eater. Kaleb and Eian were welcoming and engaging as we went through the line! Definitely will be going back to this location!Kid-friendliness: Our kid is very picky with what he will eat. They offered him a create your own kid size bowl that was perfect!“

4 Good96 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
4860 N Hamilton Rd, Columbus - 7.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Eggplant Parmigiana Breadstick Sandwich
Never-Ending Soup Salad & Breadsticks
Grilled Chicken Margherita
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Sicilian Cheesecake
Famous House Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Olive Garden Salad

“As good of olive garden experience as you can get. The hostess was positive, upbeat and friendly. Our server was fun and attentive. We never lacked for salad, drinks or breadsticks. Right on with providing to go boxes and nice suggestions for dessert. Very enjoyable.“

4 Good98 Reviews
Angelina's Villa Pizza • $
5450 E Livingston Ave, Columbus - 2.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Sticks and Garlic Bread with Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza w Xtra Cheese and Sauce
Angelina's Homemade Lasagna
Kid's Pepperoni Pizza
Beef Pepperoni Pizza
Philly Steak Pizza
Meatball Sub
Cheese Pizza
Italian Sub
Angelina

“Had the 6" meatball sub. Only had 2 meatballs. Easily room for 3. Not enough cheese. Alot of sauce. Sauce was good, but it's out of balance with the rest. Also had the 7" children's pepperoni pizza. It was good. It's not overcooked like many places. Prices are excellent. No indoor seating. Photo misleading. Children's meals come with a pop and an Otis Spunkmeyer cookie. Stale. Would return for the pizza.“

3.9 Good56 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
5310 N Hamilton Rd, Columbus - 8.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Big Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Magnifico
Steak

“Wow - the Philly cheesesteak pizza is a new favorite. We also love the pizza crust here. We've driven by for 14 years and finally ordered after our Texas family introduced us to Marcos in Houston. We said, hey we have a Marcos close to us. We will definitely be ordering here more often!“

3.8 Good32 Reviews
Piada Italian Street Food Italian • $$
2585 E Main St, Columbus - 6.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Fried Chicken w Spicy Tomato Sauce and Extra Pesto
Carbonara Pasta with Grilled Chicken
Crispy Chicken blt Piada
The Farmers Market Salad
Create Your Own Pasta
Chef's Favorite Piada
Mediterranean Piada
Parmesan Piada Stick
Crispy Chicken Bowl
Basil Pesto Pasta

“My boyfriend and I absolutely love coming here. We are here probably more than we should be but the food really is that good. It is more of a healthier option for your regular pasta craving. The pepperoni sticks are a great complement to your entree and it has something for the whole family. No doubt we will be back.“

3.9 Good90 Reviews
Massey's Pizza - Gahanna Pizza • $
261 Lincoln Cir, Columbus - 5.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cauliflower Crust
Specialty Pizzas
Meat Pizza
Meatball
Sausage
Supreme
Family
Wings
Side

“First time here.Four of us had a lunch buffet. After getting our food there were no tables available to sit since the back dining area was blocked off. So we sat at the first table where I was blocked off. One of the employees came out and told us you're not allowed to sit here we have a meeting in 45 minutes that's why it's blocked off. So he was pretty rude about it but what are you supposed to do stand up and eat your lunch? The food was good. The employee was not so good.“

3.8 Good47 Reviews
Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Italian • $
6000 Westerville Rd, Westerville - 11.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Everyone's Favorite Stromboli
The Original Stromboli
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Garlic Cheese Bread
Chicken Carsonie
Italian Stallion
Italian Fries
Lasagna

“We met family (with 2 young-uns—one 5 yo, the other one 6 mos old) for dinner. Our server was awesome! She was very attentive and loved the kids! We had mozzarella sticks to start, then the guys split a pepperoni pizza and the gals had Stromboli—one chicken, one veggie. And my grandson had spaghetti and meatballs and steamed broccoli. The mozzarella sticks were good. The pizza was very greasy. We’ve had it before and that was not the case. The Stromboli was picture perfect, but very bland—as if there was no seasoning at all. My daughter-in-law suggested putting Italian seasoning in with the filling, then mixed with the butter/oil that was brushed on top. The dipping sauce was also rather bland. But the star of the show was the broccoli followed by the spaghetti and meatball. The portions were generous and most of the spaghetti went home with us.“

3.8 Good71 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza • $
55 McNaughten Rd, Columbus - 2.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Mushroom and Sausage Pizza

“Ever since I moved to Columbus 10 years ago. I have ordered from Jet's Pizza. I love their salads! The new popcorn chicken salad is AMAZING! Everytime I have ordered from there, everything has always been fresh and very well put together! If anyone is looking for a filling fresh salad, definitely check out their different types of salads, they won't disappoint! I recommend the popcorn chicken salad or the antipasto salad! Mmmm Delicious!“

3.6 Good41 Reviews
Milano's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
6916 E Broad St, Columbus - 2.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

House Salad with Italian Dressing
Homemade Cheese Manicotti
Chicken Parmigiana
Prime Rib Dinner
Liver and Onions
Extra Breadstick
Chicken Parmesan
Veal Parmigiana
Delmonico Steak
Italian Sampler

“I ordered takeout for my wife's birthday from Grubhub. 4 items at about $25 a pop. Only 3 of the items showed up, and 2 of the 3 were wrong. I went to the Grubhub app to complain, and they offered me a $5 credit. So I called the restaurant and spoke to the manager (also the owner). He patiently listened to my rant, thanked me for calling him, and promised to make it right. He showed up personally at my door in 20 MINUTES with the correct order, and a slice of cake for my wife.I can't tell you how long it's been since I experienced actual customer service. I am slightly ashamed for the state I was in when I called but he handled it like a professional.This place is a Columbus legacy with great food and I would definitely order again!“

3.7 Good95 Reviews
Loading...
map Map