17 Best Italian Restaurants near Pickerington

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

“The best place to go for sports and good wings and pizza. The greatest service“

“I had been looking for a great pizza place since moving back to Ohio 11 years ago. I had settled on Marcos because when they 1st opened, it was wonderful. I guess they’ve become complacent, or they have so much turnover, that they can’t provide good service anymore. I don’t know what has happened to this place. I have stopped patronizing the restaurant because of messed up orders, pizza boxes stuck to the toppings, and just a general lack of attention to detail. The app is way too unreliable, and you miss out on half of your rewards. When I did order, it was always for delivery. I’m my wife’s caregiver, and we don’t go out much anymore.“

“My family had the pleasure of dining at Lola & Giuseppe's last evening, and it truly was a pleasure! We began with wedding soup (some of the best I have ever tasted), a Guiseppe's Salad, and spinach-artichoke dip. Two of our group had the meat lasagna which was delicious and a huge serving. Other entrees included egg plant parmigana and chicken marsala. All were excellent, large servings, and very reasonably priced. The surprise (and a good one) was the Creme de Limocello that was bursting with lemon flavor and a nice little nip. Service was excellent and the owner stopped by to chat on two occasions thanking us for dining there. It was undoubtedly one of the most enjoyable dining experiences we have had in quite a while. Highly recommend!“

“Very good pizza! Friendly, clean, and quick service. We highly recommend!“

“Oh my.. fantastic food and service, best linguini and clams or penne with sausage!! Have to complement Michelle on great service! Nice wine list!! Carryout or dine in five stars!!!!“

“We picked up two meals from here to eat at home. One was chicken margherita with pasta figioli soup and the other a Tour of Italy meal with an Olive Garden house salad. Ordering the food was seamless and done over the phone with a friendly, courteous associate. The meals were ready to pick up on time as promised. Both meals were delicious! We will definitely carry out meals from here again!“

“Im glad i reside close to this location so i can dine here often. The food is ALWAYS fresh and made to order. The employees are super friendly. A special mention to the older lady at the counter, and I apologize for not catching her name, she is SOOOO very nice and helpful and even told us to be careful as we were leaving cause it was starting to rain. Employees like that are few and far between.“

“I dined here for the first time yesterday and order the Fettuccine Alfredo w/chicken and a Caesar salad…both were absolutely delicious, the flavor was amazing and so was the Moscato wine which had the perfect amount of sweetness that I like! The breadsticks were amazing, they melt in your mouth. My server Aaron, was excellent, great personality with a wonderful sense of humor! I will definitely be back and will be making Milanos a regular place to have dinner! If you’ve never been here, I totally recommend giving Milano’s a try!!!“

“Very quiet!! Very polite atmosphere!!! No one hurling out F-Bombs!! Very peaceful.

I visited 6 - 10, 13 April 2026. My lunch destination for now on!!! I am a charter customer eating my first meals in 1979 prior to joining the US Army and a few times a week once my brother retired from the US Army in 1995.

This of course until the relocation to Main & College St.

The Lunch Special #1 is my mainstay!!!“

“Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.“

“The signature pizza is hands-down the best there is. People who quibble over curb appeal and cinnamon sticks are delusional. Pizza is not made from cauliflower-go eat a broccoli salad if this is your thing! Masseys pizza is the only place where the advertisement uses the actual product, and not some fake staged version. If you want the best, pay a few bucks more and don't whine about them being busy.“

“Good food, fun family place!“

“they been around for a very long time and there a family owned community pizza shop.“

“My Girlfriends order was completely wrong ordered pizza, bbq wings, & a 2-liter of Sprite. missed the wings yet put the bbq sauce on a cheese pizza, had to go back in and get my girlfriends wings order separately 25 more minutes of wait time.
Cierra the manager was super sweet and replaced everything with a credit. Bbq cheese pizza, was not my Girlfriend's thing, I tried a wing and they were pretty dang'on good.
Cierra showed great professionalism in making it right. We're going to try a veggie pizza next weekend. Thanks ya'll. Shout out to Cierra. I'll give them a second chance just on GP.“