17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Pickerington

Grapevine Pizza & Cafe Pizza • $
8581 Refugee Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Medium Pepperoni Pizza
Traditional Wings
Baked Spaghetti
Buffalo Chicken
Fried Pepperonis
Hawaiian Pizza
Fried Mushrooms
Meatball Pizza
Onion Rings
White Pizza

“We ordered a monster sub and the meatballs with cheese yesterday about 730pm. We were next door for pool league, she told me 25 min for a sub and meatballs, I figured they were backed up for 25 min, I set timer and walked down 2 min before it went off, food was on rack, it obviously was sitting there for some time as the sub meat was COLD. My husband was so upset lol. The meatballs were the size of spaghettiO’s meatballs. The taste was there but the toddler size meatballs were shameful. We’ve gotten these a few times before and never ever were they this tiny To charge $9’for 6 of these is sinful lol Def turned off for awhile , be back at a much later date I sent a message last night before writing this. It’s still unanswered“

4.4 Superb94 Reviews
MOD Pizza Pizza • $
1301 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Custom Bacon and Tomato Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Mad Dog
Salad
Pesto

“Man, this visit today blew me away. I’ve been to a couple MODs thru out the country but this place was a step above the rest. Alex said he was new but it didn’t show at all. He was amazing from the moment we walked in the door and I can’t say enough good things about him. He actually seems to love his job and it was almost infectious. He provided suggestions and even got us to add some things I would normally not even try. The food came out perfect and the store was spotless. Whoever is running this store is doing a great job and it shows! Will be back for sure and would highly recommend.“

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
Gionino's Pizzeria Pizza • $
12983 Stonecreek Dr, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pep Pizza and Jo's Jo's
Medium Pepperoni Pizza
Salad Dressing
Boneless Wings
Specialty Pizza
Fried Chicken
Buffalo Wings
Extra Cheese
Cheese Pizza
Deluxe Pizza

“Pepperoni Piccolo....OMG....one of the best pizzas my husband and I have eaten! My husband was waiting for me at Pickerington Kroger and googled pizza and saw the Pic and ordered. Real thing was just as the pic. We loved it so much we ordered another a few days later. Hubby gave some to our neighbor from NY and he said it reminded him of NY. This our new go to place for pizza!“

4.4 Superb62 Reviews
Pizzeria New York Pizza • $
833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

6in Grilled Chicken Sub
Teriyaki Chicken Wings
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Extra Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Sticks
Stuffed Shells
Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots
Breadsticks

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

4.4 Superb58 Reviews
Cardo's Pizza & Tavern Pizza • $
7897 Refugee Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Cheese Extra Cheese Pizza
Sausage Onion and Pepperoni Pizza
Fish Sandwich and Fries
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Wings
French Fries
Gondola Sub
Taco Pizza

“Good food Good service Pizza was awesome!! I would highly recommend!!“

4.3 Superb68 Reviews
Flyers Pizza Pickerington Pizza • $
8220 Refugee Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“Great tasting pizza. I really like the taste, but they don't glue the toppings on with the cheese like they are supposed to. The cheese is under the pepperoni, and the rest of your toppings just fall off. I feel like they should put some cheese on the bottom and then put the rest on top to glue the toppings on. You don't pay 3$ per topping to have it fall off.“

4.4 Superb42 Reviews
Pizza Cottage Pizza • $
1000 Old Diley Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Small Pizza
Loaded Baked Potato Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Breadsticks with Cheese
Chicken Philly Pizza
Cauliflower Pizza
Fried Mozzarella
Personal Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Meatball Sub

“We have eaten at a few others and you are up there with the best . Certainly much better than Lewis Center.“

4.1 Good79 Reviews
IL Forno Pizza • $
1146 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Stromboli not a Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Meat Pizza

“Very good tasting pizza. HOWEVER: The hand tossed pizza is very thin and almost classifies as New York style. Crust could have been done a little more. ALSO: be advised that even if you are ordering a topping for only half of your pizza you will get charged full price. Did I get a full serving for my half? No way of knowing.“

4.2 Good47 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
1745 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico
Steak and Cheese
Build Your Own
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Cinnasquares
Deluxe Pizza
Italian Chef
Cheezybread
Italiano

“I had been looking for a great pizza place since moving back to Ohio 11 years ago. I had settled on Marcos because when they 1st opened, it was wonderful. I guess they’ve become complacent, or they have so much turnover, that they can’t provide good service anymore. I don’t know what has happened to this place. I have stopped patronizing the restaurant because of messed up orders, pizza boxes stuck to the toppings, and just a general lack of attention to detail. The app is way too unreliable, and you miss out on half of your rewards. When I did order, it was always for delivery. I’m my wife’s caregiver, and we don’t go out much anymore.“

4.1 Good51 Reviews
Donatos Pizza Pizza • $
1214 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Big Don Italian with Sausage
Boneless Wings Side
Hot Honey Pepperoni
Medium the Works
Pepperoni Pizza
Create Your Own
Vegy Sub

“I've been ordering online and I have to say that the service has been wonderful and the delivery time much better as well as the quality of food. ..“

4 Good46 Reviews
Romeo's Pizza Pizza • $
80 W Church St, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Veggie Deluxe Specialty Pizza
Romeo's Deluxe Pizza
Boneless Wings
Stuffed Pizza
Italian Salad
Capone Sauce
Premium Subs
Breadsticks
Pizzas

“Pickerington’s Romeo is THE best!! Jazelle knows us by name and always is so sweet, polite and serves her customers with a smile on her face. We especially love ordering through the app and the ability to change the sauce from the Romeo’s sauce to marinara.“

3.8 Good59 Reviews
Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian • $$
1755 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread Basket with Marinara Sauce
Chicken Parmesan and Angel Hair Pasta
Chicken Penne Carbonara
Lobster Bisque Soup
Italian Wedding Soup
Fettuccine Alfredo
D Lobster Ravioli
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Francaise
Chicken Milanese

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

4.4 Superb85 Reviews
Omezzo pasta bowl + Rice & Curry Halal Bistro Italian • $$
1757 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

4.7 Superb21 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza • $
201 Clint Dr, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Chocolate Brownie
Wings

“There is a fabulous deal going on with Jets and the Columbus Blue Jackets hockey team. 50% off on only the pizzas the next day when the team scores 2 or more goals. I do online orders for pick up. Note there is NO place online to put in a tip for the kitchen folks. I always tip cash (at a percentage as if there were no discount) when I pick up the pizzas. I asked the last time I went why tipping isn't on the website and the employee said that option was removed from the website. They do 4 kinds of pizza - Detroit, New York, hand tossed and thin (cracker crust).

Parking: Lots of space“

3.4 Good37 Reviews
MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub American • $
1281 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Rise and Shine Burger and Fries
California Chicken Flatbread
Yellowstone Flatbread
Treasure State Tacos
Chocolate Brownie
Reuben Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza
Artichoke Dip
Spicy Chicken
Cowboy Nachos

“I have celiac disease and have hard a time finding food that isn’t contaminated, especially pizza. The staff reassured me that they checked with kitchen multiple times to make sure nothing was being contaminated. It was by far the most delicious gluten free pizza I’ve had so far !“

4 Good115 Reviews
Twin's Tavern Pubs • $
1128 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

“If you are looking for a fancy place with a big menu full or fine dining foods and pinkies-out cocktails, this is not it.If you are looking for a corner bar where everyone knows each other by name, plays pool and darts together, shares pizza, and does shots until closing time, Twins is definitely worth checking out.“

4.7 Superb10 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
810 Refugee Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Lover's Melt
Pepperoni Pizza
Boneless Wings
14 Large Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks
Honey BBQ
Marinara

“When I tell you this is the Pizza Hut I’ve ever been to hands down the manager Nathan service is top tier I’ve never had this type of service at any fast food these guys rock forsure #1 global ❤️ It’s a must try I will always come here no matter how for I live..“

3 Average66 Reviews

You May Also Like