12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Reynoldsburg

“Tyler’s is amazing! If I could have it everyday I would!“

“super pizzas! lots of variety what is really interesting to me is the great consistency that Vick's has with the number of specialty pizzas that they offer. if you order a specialty pizza this week and then order it, the following week....it is the same great pizza and the same great taste...that is hard to achieve in any business, and especially with food, but Vick's does a PHENOMENAL job...time and time again oh...did I mention....ALL of their STAFF is PHENOMENAL!!!“

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

“Saturday night was my first time ever having Romeo’s delivered. It was a great experience from the moment they answered the phone, to the pizza, to the cheese bread, leading to the exceptional Delivery Driver who delivered our order to us on my patio! 🥇 A great experience ALL around. What a Turn Key Operation they have on Lancaster Avenue! We will order again!“

“I don't usually eat in. I always go through the drive thru. The employees there are so nice. It's always the same group of people. The pizza is always fresh and hot. They do not skimp on toppings. I always get a cauliflower crust pizza, and it is one of my favorites. Highly recommend!

Dietary restrictions: They have very good cauliflower crust and gluten free crust options for pizza. Both very good.“

“Disappointed they are outsourcing their pizza delivery service through DoorDash. I’m not a DoorDash fan and never will be. We received the room temp pizza because they don’t use a pizza insulated carrier. Also our order wasn’t right. Very disappointed!“

“I'm DEFINITELY coming back if I'm remotely close. I carried out my Italian Sub, dressing on the side. The sub was fantastic and that Dressing is AMAZING. Best I can describe it is the best Italian dressing you've ever had, homemade, very tart in a good way, with an extra zippie zing to it. Really was outstanding. I wasn't able to finish all of it that night. So the next day after wrapping it in foil I put it on the turbo warming to warm back up. I sure did wish I had more of it to eat than the third of it I had left. Highly recommend. I'm definitely getting the sub & a pizza next time!!“

“I love Fazoli's, I think of it like the fast food version of the Olive Garden. The carbonara is really good., switch out for penne. I didn't think I liked cheesecake until I ate the triple chocolate cheesecake. I'm sort of craving it now.“

“The cauliflower crush was delicious. I'm vegan and it was yo find items I liked and can eat.Service was excellent.

Vegetarian options: Vegetables I like. Banana peppers, green olives, tomatoes, Spinach, white onion, and cauliflower crust was yummy.“

“Ordered delivery from here a few times, and it usually shows up hot about 35 minutes later, but one time, it showed up over 2 hours later, cold and pizza not cut.
No bad weather or anything, so Idk what that was about, but they made up for it by a future order on them, so that was nice! 🤙“

“We were greated as soon as we entered the restuarant. Counter guy was friendly and pleasant. Took our order and repeated to make sure he got it right. Food came out in a timely manner, was hot and very good. Dinning area was clean but a little chilly.“