24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lancaster

“I love their Pizza Subs the best in town. There brownies are slammin too!“

“Love the pizza it really good“

“They finally got Sunday sales for beer , best pizzas and subs on the corner of St.22 and Lake Rd . Just a little ways out of Lancaster going toward Rushville in Little Town called Colfax. And you can buy Bay's meat there and a sort of candy and pop.“

“My boyfriend and I went up over the weekend and they were packed! We had to wait for them to clean a table but we didn’t mind. Food came out so fast we couldn’t believe it since they were so busy. We will definitely be back! Sad it took us so long to find this hidden gem.“

“Really clean bathroom. Will visit again.“

“Took my family to the e Restaurant and all the staff was very friendly. They made sure the food was out as soon as it was ready and our drinks were always filled. Love love love Cristy's East!!!“

“I just wanted to stop in a give a shout out, tonight we ordered 2 pizza, BLT and a large half pep and cheese. When hubby got home he realized we got our half pep and cheese and a supreme. We called was told to bring the other pizza in and they would make our BLT. My husband was presently surprised with the service and a 5 dollar coupon! Not only did they make it right they helped with our next order! You made him and the kids happy tonight! Thank you!!!“

“Best pizza around“

“We ended up at Massey’s pizza on a whim while in town this past weekend for Winter Guard Competitions, and when I tell you this is by far the BEST pizza and service we have had in a long time that doesn’t even begin to describe it! The staff was wonderful and the food!!! We can’t wait for another competition in Columbus just so we can go to Massey’s!“

“The worker was super friendly. Pizza and breadsticks were very good. Will definitely eat there again.“

“Absolutely great food, great people, and great service!!“

“Haven't been inside yet, but delivered twice, Very good ! fast delivery !“

“Good very good food ppl nice“

“My family orders creno's often the food never disappoints especially the cheesy garlic flatbread.. however the reason I decided to post a review today is my delivery driver.... I didn't actually get his name but I felt that people should know this driver in particular is the most kind patient understanding man... At the very last minute I realized my mistake that I didn't have correct change and I know delivery drivers do not carry it.. so I ran to the gas station next to my house got a few necessities and broke my $100 bill so that I had proper change and tip to give to my driver... He called while I was at the gas station I explained what I was doing and he was nothing but kind he sat on my porch patiently waiting for me to return was not mean or grumpy he even thanked me for being nice... It's a sad day when somebody has to thank you for being a decent human but I digress I just wanted to say Creno's has great food and excellent service“

“Best pizza around! Nice sweet sauce like I like, great crust & toppings. Always fantastic!“

“Delicious food! I am thrilled we discovered this little gem and surprised it’s not the talk of the town. Go see Chris and he’ll not only cook the most amazing meal for you but he’ll also make you feel as though you’re the most important person in the room. It’s that Italian family way that really brings it home. Go!! You’ll be so glad you did !“

“Extremely funny waitress Christiana. You can't train her personality. Very pleasing and enjoyable. Will visit again.“

“Great subs and the cristys classic is awesome.“

“Stopped in tonight with a few friends. I had the shrimp, scallops and crab pasta dish and it was awesome. I will be back to try some other dishes and the pizza“

“My favorite pizza period. It is amazing. No other pizza like it. I will say last time I got it with the fam it tasted off a bit. It just didn't seem like the cheese and sauce was their standard. But that was 1 time out of many. I recommend this place above all other pizza joints. Hands down!!!!

Vegetarian options: They have all veggie pizzas and subs. From what I saw.“

“we have been going to Tiberos pizza for years, and have always loved it so much, we went this evening, and I was so disappointed in the service, they have a new young girl and she dropped my pizza and I had to wait almost a hour for it to be remade, I still got charged for it, our service was horrible, I have never been to any restaurant who didn't give u a free meal or a discount on their mistake, and especially waiting a hour, I don't know if we will be back.“

“Best pizza ever!!“

“Small town atmosphere and friendly staff“

“I just want to acknowledge Holly, at this location. The other night I waited for over 2 hours for my food, I guess it got sent to doordash because they had no drivers. At this point I was frustrated and annoyed. Holly went above and beyond to make sure we got taken care of. In the mist of me calling and she was replacing my order the door dasher finally showed up ; Holly sent out my order but also created a fresh order (no charge) and had it here within 20 mins and also placed a credit on our account. Thank you Holly ! It’s things like this that provide good customer service even in the worst situations !“