14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lancaster

Tiki Bowling Lanes Pizza • $
1521 Tiki Ln, Lancaster

“My husband and I went for a bowling tournament this weekend. First time bowling here. House is clean, staff friendly, beverage, and food costs reasonable. Only downfall was the tackiness of the approaches. Suggest using a slide cover on your shoe. Overall nice enviroment.“

4.7 Superb68 Reviews
The Dog House Tavern Bar • $
701 Reese Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Slim Jims
Pizza

“This place is totally a cute, divey corner bar. Definitely not the place that has the hottest new IPA on tap, but the regulars know your name. Very endearing, and super cheap. Also worth a visit just for the super hot smokeshow bartender Nate.“

4.6 Superb79 Reviews
Nick's Restaurant & Pizza Pizza • $
702 W Wheeling St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Small Cupping Pepperoni
Large Pizza and Cheese Bread
Big T Tenderloin Sandwich
Sunday Morning Breakfast
Ham and Cheese Sub
All the Way Pizza
Half Regular Sub
Cheeseburger
Garden Pizza
Bread Sticks

“This is my favorite pizza place in town. Love the fact they use old world pepperoni so hard to find a pizza shop using that. Staff is always nice and courteous a rarity these days. Will be returning.Dietary restrictions: They do offer gluten free pizza“

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Osteria Alla Romana Italian • $$
1453 Tiki Ln, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Bruschetta with Chopped Fresh Tomatoes Basil and Oregano
Pennette All'Arrabbiatta with Spicy Tomato Sauce
Italian Chocolate Dessert I Can
Spaghetti Pomodoro E Basilico
Fettuccine Bolognese
Mushroom Ravioli
Lobster Ravioli
Lemon Truffle
Caprese Salad
Garlic Bread

“We visited today for the first time based on a friend's recommendation. I'm certainly glad we did. The food was excellent and we enjoyed talking with the owner/chef. He grew up in Italy and brings authentic dishes to his restaurant.We enjoyed everything we tried and appreciated his recommendations. I'm a vegetarian but my wife isn't and there were plenty of choices for each of us. I'm anxious to return and try other items on the menu.“

4.5 Superb59 Reviews
MOD Pizza Pizza •
1854 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Pizza
Pizza Salad

“So,... don't just drive by this one over and over again thinking its just another pizza joint... this is delicious and straight-forward pizza (with LOTS of toppings)! Give it a go!!! Yummy! PS. Flat pricing regardless of toppings selected.“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Donatos Pizza Pizza • $
765 E Main St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Salty Caramel Apple Pie
Serious Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Boneless Wings
Meatball Sub

“Used an online deal Ordered and when I went to pick up the order it got changed but they were SO nice to help me get it fixed bc of course it was just before they were to close for Christmas Eve. So Thank you VERY much for helping fix it so we had dinner!!! ??“

4.4 Superb25 Reviews
Glass City Pizzeria Pizza •
1635 River Valley Cir N, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Your Way

“This is possibly the best pizza out I've had in a long time. The toppings are delicious and fresh, the sauce is nicely seasoned, the cheese is stretchy and melts well, and the crust while it is premade, it is high quality. The owner is incredibly nice, even under pressure, and is beyond polite. Please, if you want a fantastic pizza from a local vender and to support the only local food vender in the River Valley Mall, come to Glass City Pizza!“

4.3 Superb30 Reviews
Sugar Bears Pizzeria Italian • $
147 Cedar Hill Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread w Sauce
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Chef Salad

“I have lived in Lancaster for 10 years now and I remember the first time I ate sugar bear. My wife's late grandpa (R.I.P) favorite place was there and he got some and I was hooked ever since. My family likes the spaghetti and bread sticks from there too.“

4.2 Good44 Reviews
Pizza Cottage Pizza • $$
2223 W Fair Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Loaded Baked Potato Pizza
Pepperoni Sausage
Cauliflower Crust
Jalapeno Poppers
Specialty Pizzas
Buffalo Chicken
Garlic Bread
Bread Sticks
All the Way

“They have a great lunch special 9.99 entree side and drink. Fresh salad,hot fries,pizza is fabulous and boneless tenders are great. Me and my husband get a different one and share for a variety. Lancaster is great.been to one in another City wasn't as good. But Lancaster is always good.“

4.1 Good78 Reviews
King’s Grand Central Pizza • $$
2610 N Columbus St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Pizza
Cheesy Garlic Strips
Specialty Pizzas
4.6 Superb13 Reviews
Pizza Crossing Lancaster Pizza • $
1407 Tiki Ln, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sub All the Way
Grilled Chicken Salad
Supreme Meat Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Bread Sticks
French Fries
Baked Wings
Lasagna

“This Is The Best Pizza In Town, Down In Lancaster..I Love That It's Family Oriented & Get Your Bang For Your Bucks..My Favorites That I Order Are..The Meat Lovers Pizza, The Banana Peppers With Italian Saugage, With Pepperoni & Chesse..Another Favorite IsThe BQ Buffalo Wings, The Italian Subs & The Chicken Salad Very Very Good & So Many Others I Have Purchased For Me & My Family..If Your In Lancaster Don't Forget To Stop Here & Grab A Box Of Pizza, Salad Or A Sub..Shout Out To The Staff As Well❤️❤️I Be Back Again...This Is My Go To Spot Pizza Place In Lancaster..They Never Miss“

4.1 Good46 Reviews
Massey's Pizza Pizza • $
1229 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Specialty Pizzas
Pepperoni Pizza
Boneless Wings
Cheeseburger
Taco Salad
Lasagna

“Today stopped in for lunch ordered a Pepperoni Pizza they accidentally forgot the pepperonis which I was OK with ,I get things happen. The pizza was really good! When I went to leave they gave me a pepperoni pizza which I really appreciated! It’s means a lot to me to make something right. I will definitely be back. Staff is great and kind and food is great! I will be back!“

4.1 Good37 Reviews
Pink Cricket Restaurant Pizza • $
929 E Main St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti w Meat Sauce Garlic Bread
Thin Crust Pizza
Chicken Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza
Sandwiches

“Great evening of live music by "Off The Grid"! Very pleasant atmosphere and great service! The servers and I'm sure the kitchen as well were energetic, friendly and definitely on top of everything and on the ball. The bar and restaurant itself inside was very cozy and inviting and the outside back patio was just as nice. Seemed like all the patron's were just as nice and respectful of one another. Definitely will be going back ?“

4 Good66 Reviews
Cristy's Pizza East Pizza • $
1436 Tiki Ln, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Cristy's Famous Cheesy Breadstix
Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Steak Submarine Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak
The Italian Pizza
Cristy's Classic
Salad Your Way
Big Meat Pizza
Cheese Bread
Four Cheese

“Ordered my food ahead, and then couldn't get there on time because I was stuck waiting at the vet office. Didn't get there until an hour after my food was ready and was unsure whether they would have my food still. They did, and it was kept in the warmer. Food was nice and warm and surprisingly didn't taste like it hadn't just come out of the oven. The pizza bites are delicious! Very happy with the service and food after what was a stressful day at the vet.“

4 Good54 Reviews
Loading...
map Map