Restaurants in Lancaster

“We are from out of town and found this local bar/restaurant online. The service was wonderful, the servers truly care about taking care of the customers, great drinks and the atmosphere of the restaurant is fun and welcoming. Would definitely be our go to spot if we lived here!”

“Such a blessing to the community. So involved and friendly. I highly recommend! Everyone should give them a shot!!”

“We made the best of a rainy day by visiting a couple new places we hadn't been before for a special occasion. This was our 1st stop on our way to a dinner reservation. The drive was pleasant even in the rain. Really cool place! Had a flight sampling 4 of their craft brews and shared a pint of their signature cider. The lovely bartender was so polite and chatty. We'll definitely be back during more favorable weather to enjoy the BBQ & upcoming Live Music events!”

“We were out to celebrate a special occasion and decided to make a dinner reservation at Alfonso's. So very happy we did! Love the vibes of a pastime meshed with the revamping they have going on! Background music was fun...Fly Me to the Moon, 4 Seasons, The Supremes! Waitress was fabulous! I had a Whiskey Sour, hubby a "Smoked" Old Fashioned. Then we started off with Stuffed Mushrooms...amazing! For our entrees, I went with the Chicken Marsala & he had the Chicken Parmesan. Both were so yummy! Everything was presented & displayed so well too! We ordered our desserts to go...Cheesecake & Bread Pudding, which we enjoyed later on at home. As with everything else we enjoyed earlier, the flavors were delicious! Thank you chef(s) & staff for making this a memory to cherish! We look forward to returning once again!”

“Amazing authentic Italian food! Owner and chef is super friendly. Great atmosphere. Will definitely be back!”

“Bootleggers of Lancaster is a perfect place to gather with friends, family or co-workers. Fun and relaxed atmosphere and the staff is great!”

“Food is always delicious, staff is friendly and quick and the atmosphere is relaxing…and let’s not forget those biscuits 😍”

“all I can say is Stu's Place is the best bar in town!”

“The chef we had and the bartender on Saturday March 29 were THE BEST two to ever chef/bartend. Agung and Karlene were the best hosts I've ever had at any restaurant, ever. I specifically asked for their names for this review. The entire time, my 3 kids, my boyfriend and I didn't want for anything. Entertained every single second, had something to eat from beginning to end and cannot think of anything they could have done better. The food was absolutely perfect, every one of us had something different and everything was made to perfection. My drink from the bar was a new choice for me and I will be thinking of that particular one for years to come, I'm sure. She made it perfectly for someone who doesn't drink a lot of sugar. They really know how to take care of their guests. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 bravo. The owner should cherish them, as it's hard to find happy employees let alone ones who want to spread the happy to those around them. Thank you for a fabulously memorable night with my children. I'll always be grateful. 🙏🏻”

“I just wanted to stop in a give a shout out, tonight we ordered 2 pizza, BLT and a large half pep and cheese. When hubby got home he realized we got our half pep and cheese and a supreme. We called was told to bring the other pizza in and they would make our BLT. My husband was presently surprised with the service and a 5 dollar coupon! Not only did they make it right they helped with our next order! You made him and the kids happy tonight! Thank you!!!”

“We stopped here while visiting from out of town and looking for a healthy food option, and this place was great! The staff was super friendly and the power bowls (custom made for our choices) were delish!”

“Google maps helped us find this lovely family owned “pizza shop”. We had a fabulous calzone and pizza. Quirky decor and plenty of activities (from checkers to air hockey).”

“delicious paninis. Will definitely go back”

“By far our favorite place in Lancaster. The food and service is always top notch.”

“These are the nicest down to earth people!!
You have to try the food if you haven't 😋. Everything I've tried so far has been awesome. Slopwish sandwish A+++ wrapsA+++
And the names 🤣 gator bait chicken and waffles .Lol!!! .You got to try them out”

“I’ve never had them, but my husband won’t stop saying things like, “You know what’s good? Donut World!”. Out of the blue….”I love Donut World”. The best yet, “Have you heard of Donut World?” 36 TIMES A DAY FOR THE LAST TWO WEEKS! Donut World you have made the husband truly happy. 😒 I’m not even jealous.”

“Have ordered many times through door dash, finally went inside today. The resteraunt was very clean and looked nice. Food was delicious as always. Had good margaritas.”

“They have the best chicken tenders I’ve ever tasted and the burgers are incredible. However they fry the fries makes them so good but then the BBQ seasoning on top makes them unbelievable. The food is all affordable and with the flavor I’d pay more for sure. The staff were all really friendly.”

“Ashley was great. Not just a wonderful server, she also has a sparkling personality. Made for a memorable experience. I’m the guy from North Carolina who teased her about charging extra for an English muffin instead of toast.”

“Bourbon chicken is awesome here !! Recommend %1000!!”

“Went to L-City today to support local and everyone there was so friendly. It was clean and the drinks were amazing. ❤️. This will be my new coffee place.”

“I love their Pizza Subs the best in town. There brownies are slammin too!”

“Food was good (a little cold) and our bartender was attentive and nice.

Lots of people standing around in the back however talking and playing on phones while food needs ran and the bar was asking for help.”

“Best pizza around! Nice sweet sauce like I like, great crust & toppings. Always fantastic!”

“These girls have done an awesome job! The food service and atmosphere is amazing!! We will be back”

“Love the new bakery items! The taste and quality are wonderful!! Excited to try more!”

“The food is always great and the staff have never gotten our order wrong. The small mom and pop places are the best”

“I am so glad we stopped in during our trip to Hocking Hills for a long weekend (we stayed in Lancaster). This is a local gem! So much so that we ate dinner here both nights. Both evenings we sat at the bar and had outstanding service from the owner (think Judy was her name). Drinks were great, I had an espresso martini one evening and it was one of best I’ve had. My boyfriend loved the beer selection. Wine was also good, a go-to for me. We had the bangers and mash with a salad the first night and loved it. Second night we split a burger, tried Irish nachos- sides were minty mashed peas and the cabbage and potato mix (forget proper name)- both were fabulous! Both evenings we splurged and split cheesecake which is house made. Chai then peach cobbler flavor. Outstanding. I will miss this place now we’re back home. Highly recommend a stop in. Service was friendly and fast. Atmosphere was cozy. Thank you for your hospitality!!”

“I went here today 2/15/25 for the first time for my birthday. It had an amazing time!! Place was very inviting and staff were so friendly & helpful. So many different pieces to choose from and so many paint colors! 10/10 recommend and I will 100% be back again.”

“Best slushies and Coney dogs in town!”

“What's for supper? When I don't know what I want or don't want to cook, I just make a call in to Wangs and order take out of my favorites. The Chicken on a stick is so good, don't know what they marinate the chicken in but yum. Then no matter what else I get I always get an order of their House fried rice. I can always save it for another night. And can't remember what she said the names of the dessert cakes were but was a great end to the meal. Here is what I got Sunday.”

“They have the absolute best subs at prices that can't be beaten. I order from there every time I am in the area. My favorite is the Italian sub but they are all well worth it.”

“Very good food and friendly staff. Food came fast and wasn’t very expensive for all that we got. Definitely would recommend if you are in lancaster and looking for quality Bbq.”

“Looooove the bartenders, great food and good conversations!!!”

“Love the pizza it really good”

“I got fried shrimp..fried oysters s and coleslaw..everything was awesome..”

“awesome spot to hangout! awesome bartender and good atmosphere”

“We ordered two party packs with brisket and several sides for our son's graduation party. Lots and lots of positive praise. We had hardly any leftovers. Everything was hot and in trays ready to set up. Very happy! I would definitely recommend for a large gathering!”

“We hosted a post funeral dinner for 24 people and they handled it very well. Food was hot and delicious, servers were awesome, and we all left happy. We always eat here when we come to town, so I would definitely recommend it to others.”

“I haven't had anything bad from there . We were promptly seated with chips and salsa. All the staff are friendly.

Dietary restrictions: My family has Celiac and they can swap out most flour tortillas for corn tortillas if you ask.

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair access is in the alley behind the building”

“The fun atmosphere the fabulous food and of course the wonderful bartenders.”

“Great service & great pizza!”

“My boyfriend and I went up over the weekend and they were packed! We had to wait for them to clean a table but we didn’t mind. Food came out so fast we couldn’t believe it since they were so busy. We will definitely be back! Sad it took us so long to find this hidden gem.”

“Went there for the first time today the biscuits and gravy was very delicious and our waitress was very nice and good super friendly place I’ll go back there”

“Very gracious hosts. Excellent food. Not much in the atmosphere department, but still, an excellent dining experience. Truthfully, they don't pretend to be a fine dining establishment. It's walk up and order. But the order was ready quickly; and they are friendly. And they brought my dinner out to me!”

“Shocked to see Mark Pi's close but Yummy house has served just fine as replacement. Easy to order, great service, great prices, and high quality food !”

“I ordered Christmas goodies for my daughter who is 2 who has celiac. They were delicious! My daughter loved them and you couldn't tell a difference.”

“Always a good time! Great outdoor Patio!”

“If you want the best and biggest fish sandwich, this is the place to be. They have other sandwiches as well. They have fries, cole slaw, mushrooms and the list goes on. They also have the friendliest workers that makes you feel right at home. So keep in mind Madison famous fish. They also have their trailer business that travels to various fairs and other festivals.”

“The food is always as fresh as it comes! The people are always so happy to see you and serve you and they give you more then you need in YumYum 🤤 if the WAS a complaint it’s that it’s to much 😅 I’d eat there very night if possible, 5 Stars hibachi on the strip by the mall!”

“Delicious! Friendly service! Best Hibachi in town.”

“Ribs were hot and delicious, smothered chicken was cold and dry. peighton the waitress wasn't impressive. She didn't bring our appetizer until after our meal arrived. She checked on the table next to ours 3 times and refilled their drinks before she got to ours. No veterans discount even though I wore a vet hat and Army polo shirt. poor. just poor this time. usually very good.”

“The best Mexican food in Lancaster! The food is delicious and they have all the Mexican staples but also some more unique menu offerings. The atmosphere is very cool and all around good vibe. I recommend the street corn; it is fantastic!”

“Such a good and relaxing place! Feel very welcoming!”

“great divee bar. server was friendly and taking care of everyone all by herself in the front if the house. great wings. but I had the nachos and they were the best I ever had. seriously they fry their own tortilla chips and they are awesome.”

“The bartender was awesome and she chatted and had complete understanding and a good sense of humor. I wish I had her name, the beer (Yingling) was only about 2 dollars. So I tipped her three dollars every beer. She had about 9 bucks in tips lol.”

“LUNCH WAS AMAZING!!! AS ALWAYS!! Thank you so much for being awesome!! And those key lime shortbread cookies are divine!!! And your chicken salad is the best I’ve ever had (shhh…don’t tell my mom! Lol). Gosh I wish I lived closer!! Everything I’ve ever had there is just delicious, and what makes the food even better are the smiling faces, great customer service, and attention to detail from those behind the counter. ❤️”

“Pretty sure I keep this place in business with how many times I order a week. I've tried the other hibachi places and nothing compares to Hibachi Express. I always order online/ahead to avoid waiting, staff is friendly, can dine in or to go. Absolutely amazing food.”

“Still as great as I remember it”

“Great food been a fan for about 18 years. Had bad pregnancy cravings for original jawbreaker and blue raspberry lemonade”

“No new tale to tell. It's usually a nice joint to grab a beer and spend time with friends and family. Historically, the food has been good, at the price point. No food on my last visit.”

“We are finishing up for lunch and let me tell ya —- I could not stop raving about their Grilled Chicken Taco Salad. I was a little nervous at first because I always get the same thing, fajitas. This salad was so good! The queso is what really did jt for me. So good and they give you a good amount of it too. Full of chicken, guac, lettuce, etc and served in a warm shell. It’s my new favorite and our two year old kept wanting to dip her fries and chicken nuggets in my queso. :)”

“We took advantage of the pick up service. We enjoyed the Classic Steak and Cheese Sub as well as the Ham and Cheese. Also a child's Turkey Sub. The items we ordered were ready for pick up when we arrived.

Parking: Ety Rd, Lancaster, Ohio”

“Cash only, I’ve been frequenting this establishment for several years. Beers is cold and karaoke is always entertaining. Especially good when the bartenders sing!”

“Even more fun when older people sign on karaoke nights. They actually know the songs.”

“I definitely recommend this location”

“David was the best person there”

“Took my family to the e Restaurant and all the staff was very friendly. They made sure the food was out as soon as it was ready and our drinks were always filled. Love love love Cristy's East!!!”

“Got 2 awesome pizza from Whitehall Massey's on Wednesday! Perfectly baked and excellent!”

“what happened to your chicken??? I'm getting flat pieces of crust I pay 25+ for 2 meals and shakes unacceptable for what you charge. this has been at least 5 times. I should clarify im talking of main street, just seen someone sayb this was fair”

“Best pizza around”

“Came here for a birthday party. Drink prices were ridiculously cheap. Bartender, Krysta (sp?), was absolutely fantastic. She kept her bar in order and the drinks flowing. Parking was a bit tight & location is a bit shady, but otherwise a fun, local place to have a drink.”

“I ordered cookies for delivery for a rehabilitation patient. Wonderful over the phone help.”

“My family orders creno's often the food never disappoints especially the cheesy garlic flatbread.. however the reason I decided to post a review today is my delivery driver.... I didn't actually get his name but I felt that people should know this driver in particular is the most kind patient understanding man... At the very last minute I realized my mistake that I didn't have correct change and I know delivery drivers do not carry it.. so I ran to the gas station next to my house got a few necessities and broke my $100 bill so that I had proper change and tip to give to my driver... He called while I was at the gas station I explained what I was doing and he was nothing but kind he sat on my porch patiently waiting for me to return was not mean or grumpy he even thanked me for being nice... It's a sad day when somebody has to thank you for being a decent human but I digress I just wanted to say Creno's has great food and excellent service”

“I absolutely love the late.My daughter I caught a blue gill within 10 minutes. The man running the place was helpful and caring. I called to ask him to check on my Father-in-law that stays down there because he wasn't answering and i was really worried about him.He went down and checked on him and responded within five minutes. I highly recommend this campsite.”

“Fast, friendly service! Amazing food with a variety of vegetarian options! If you want sushi in Lancaster, this is the place!”

“This is the BEST Subway I’ve ever been to. If it wasn’t for this location I wouldn’t eat Subway at all. The food here is always fresh and the employees are always so nice! I’ve never had a bad experience here at this location. I feel like it’s family owned because the service is always amazing here and that usually means the employees are treated well!! Keep it up!”

“Haven't been inside yet, but delivered twice, Very good ! fast delivery !”

“Best French Cruelers! Love them!”

“Went through the drive thru, awesome ice cream <3 pumpkin, play dough, spiderman and peanutbutter doughnuts❤️ !!!! Staff is friendly and have good attitude very helpful and smiling 1000% recommend”

“Very clean 👌 Got my sliders in 1 minute. The lady at the register helped me with my app and was so nice.

Parking: The employees were not loud and were very welcoming”

“The worker was super friendly. Pizza and breadsticks were very good. Will definitely eat there again.”

“Enjoy the atmosphere and food!”

“1 of the Best pizzas I've ever eatin 👍👍!!!”

“First time at Arby's in years and it reminded me why if had always been my favorite fashion food restaurant. The double beef & cheddar was excellent - unfortunately, the curly fries were the 'feashest', but still better than the burger places.”

“A great place to go to get ice cream from.”

“Great subs and the cristys classic is awesome.”

“Extremely funny waitress Christiana. You can't train her personality. Very pleasing and enjoyable. Will visit again.”

“dinning in was good hot food friendly, but do rush the bill a little. Food is delicious 😋”

“This place looks like a little dump from the outside. Plain brick in a stip mall. But the interior is very nicely decorated, the food is delicious, and the service is good. I enjoy the great daily specials as well.”

“Not sure if they got new staff, but service and food was great today! Our waitress, Dawn, was outstanding. She helped us along with others tables when they needed help and the front register. She was professional, sweet and checked all the food before bringing it out to customers. She’s definitely management material in our eyes!”

“we have been going to Tiberos pizza for years, and have always loved it so much, we went this evening, and I was so disappointed in the service, they have a new young girl and she dropped my pizza and I had to wait almost a hour for it to be remade, I still got charged for it, our service was horrible, I have never been to any restaurant who didn't give u a free meal or a discount on their mistake, and especially waiting a hour, I don't know if we will be back.”

“Wendy's Just went thru drive through & had the best service from newbie, Allison.. nothing like the 5$ JBC meal deal .... juicy fresh sandwich, chicken nuggets, baked tater & sweet tea!! Also, picked up a couple frosties, 5$ gift card & 1$ Coupon book for 5 tricker-treaters � for jr. frosties. Yum �”

“Best pizza ever!!”