19 Best Pizza Restaurants in Grove City

“only pizza I will eat!!! getting ready to order now“

“I order no contact delivery. The driver was standing in front of the door waiting for us to open the door for maybe a minute. He then texted me and told me to get my order or it would be canceled. After we got the order he had to come back to have us sign the receipt. The text was unnecessary.“

“Last night we tried Cattleman’s Pizza. We were greeted by 3 people as we walked through the door. We waited as they prepared our order! Everyone was so kind! Liz, the owner, has been in the business for 50 years! Talking to her for that short time, I could feel her passion and pride! We walked in as customers and left as friends! Highly recommend!“

“Our pizzas are always really delicious and any additional food we order is too. This time I ordered 3x pineapple on my Hawaiian pizza and it didn't seem like there was much more than the normal amount. The pizza was still delicious, but I would have liked more pineapple. We'll still keep coming back, we love Flyers on Hoover Rd.!“

“Food is consistently fantastic and probably some of the best pizza around. The only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is the new app. The previous app was much better and easier to use. The new interface feels like a downgrade, and not being able to track when your order is ready is really frustrating. Hope they improve the app because the food itself is still great.“

“Hello

My name is January. I was just there a little bit ago and ordered a small pizza and a small garden salad.

I just happened to be on that side of town and haven’t had your food in a while so decided to stop in. I just wanted to give praise to the young lady that took my order... it's says Ariel on my receipt.

She is the epitome of what customer service is. As soon as I walk through the door, she immediately greeted me with a smile and a hello.. she offered me the hand menu which had more items on it. She was very informative about what I was ordering, and she just had the most pleasant demeanor about her.. She literally is what customer service should be.

From my home, it is a 35 minute drive to your establishment and I would just like you to know that from now on I will drive that 35 minutes just to experience her 10 minutes of absolute excellence in customer service.

She is a very lovely young lady, and I cannot express enough how much I appreciated my experience with her from the minute I walked into your establishment to the moment I walked out.

She is an excellent worker.

I will also make it a point to tell my friends the experience that I had with that young lady over there. It has been many many years since I have experienced any type of customer service like hers. And I can probably count on one hand in my entire life how many times I've experienced an employee at an establishment who conducted their self the way that she did.

That was the first time I was ever in that specific jet's location but I guarantee you it will not be the last.

And please tell her thank you.. I actually had kind of a stressful day. I work in a field, where I am disrespected by people all day long (detox center) and she changed my whole day around just by coming in there and being treated so kindly and friendly with a smile by a complete stranger.“

“It’s become a family tradition to visit when we can for many years now. The food has always been good when we’ve gotten it, service & staff have always been very nice to us. Highly recommend trying the pizza & salad seems fresh and delicious every time, everything we’ve tried here has been good. Some in our family Love the breadsticks & others the sub sandwiches too. I really hope this pizza shop is able to keep going for many, many more years because we Love it so much! The dining room isn’t usually too crowded, perfect for those who don’t Love a crowd, yet enough space to still feel private enough even when others are there. Feels a little like you step into an old fashioned shop but in a really good way:) Thank you for everything you all do to keep offering fresh salads & delicious pizza (& so many other delicious options too) everyday❤️“

“We love the spaghetti & breadsticks.🍝 We do miss the caesar salads though.“

“One of the best pizzas in Columbus. Great crust, delicious sauce, loads of tasty cheese and spicy well cooked pepperoni. I couldn't ask for anything more. I first tried Tammy's years ago and it is just as good today as it was then.
The strip mall location doesn't do justice to this hidden gem. You will not regret trying this pizza and if you like flavor, it will be your go to pizza going forward.“

“We tried Zanzis for the first time tonight! Finally an affordable pizza place for larger families! The food was absolutely amazing and we will definitely be ordering more 🍕 🧡“

“Joseppies is the best pizza (our favorite) in GC. This is my opinion and also my Wife’s. We also really enjoy Cardo’s, Ange’s, Cattleman’s, Tammy’s, Plank’s, etc. AND Zamarelli’s (RIP) 🪦 use to be our go-to. Now it’s Seppies.

One of the great things about Grove City is the diversity in pizza. You can basically get any style. Whether it’s a local spot or a chain restaurant.

As far as Seppies, I see a lot of people complain about the placement of their pepperoni. As far as it being cooked under the cheese versus on top. I completely understand that someone might not like this. But I’m sure if you ask them to put the pepperoni on top, they would accommodate. Idk, call me crazy. 😵‍💫

Also, you have to remember, this place is a pizza joint that’s a hole in the wall. You can’t dine in there. So who cares if there’s dust or dirt on the windowsill. They have chairs. So use them.

Now for the downside of my review. My biggest problem with Seppies is the consistency or lack of. I get it though. It seems like a lot of younger kids work here. So it is, what it is.

But this is one area that I really wish they would work better at. It’s not a big enough problem to cause us to not want their pizza. But at the same time, when you eat at a place so much on a regular basis. It can kind of start to become a problem.

One other thing that I wanted to address; Is ordering a large pizza versus ordering an extra large. The dough on the extra large pizza is way thicker than the dough on a large. Which doesn’t really make sense to me. And by the extra large having that excess dough, it completely changes the entire Pizza. Not in a good way.

Normally, we would want the extra large. But we only ever order a large because of this issue. So hopefully somebody sees this review and can correct this issue.

Regardless, this is our favorite pizza place here and we eat it at least once a week.“

“Okay. First time ordering delivery from this location. Possibly last time with difficulties in ordering and delivery. We understand the Nation in Decline. Businesses are dealing with Democrat Induced RECESSION since stolen ELECTION. Businesses are short staffed... high gas prices... Good Customer Service is hard to find. This being written, a Monday Afternoon should still be a good time to place an order anywhere... no excuse for a Pizza to be thoroughly destroyed being delivered a quarter of a mile away... BEHOLD!! WOW!! This is how my Pizza was delivered to me... by a very nice driver. This November Trump must WIN to Make American Business Great Again... Thank me. 2nd. HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE LAST SUMMER... I ASKED FOR A 7IN. HAWAIIAN PIZZA. I RECEIVED AN ITALIAN SUB... HAWAIIAN PIZZA SOUNDS NOTHING LIKE ITALIAN SUB. PLEASE HIRE BETTER EMPLOYEES... MANAGEMENT CORRECTED THIS DINE-IN BAD EXPERIENCE... 3RD. STRIKE... 12 JANUARY 2025... I PLACED A SIMPLE TIMED DELIVERY FOR 11:30. JOSE FROM... DOOR DASH??... WAS LOST. LATE. DIDN'T READ INSTRUCTIONS. COLD PIZZA... MANAGEMENT AT THIS LOCATION EXTREMELY UNPROFESSIONAL, UNEDUCATED AND RUDE. "EVERY PIECE IS IMPORTANT"... PIECE MISSING UPON FINALLY RECIEVING THE PIZZA!! UNBELIEVABLE!! WOW!! LET'S MAKE PIZZA GREAT AGAIN. TRAIN YOUR EMPLOYEES TO BE POLITE, PROFESSIONAL, KIND AND CERTIOUS. THIS CURRENT INDIFFERENT, UNPROFESSIONAL, RELAXED TO ALMOST COMATOSE SHOULDN'T FLY... DONATO'S WAS ONCE A FAMILY FAVOURITE. NOW, IT'S OF THE HOOD, ON GATEWAY DRUGS... FILTHY... DONE WITH THIS LOCATION.“

“On 8/24/25 after spending the whole day doing wedding prep or getting married, anyone after ceremony was invited to get pizza/dinner afterwards with us. We went to Pizza Cottage, as it was the closest and best reviewed pizza place. I was not first at the business because we were the last to leave the farm. Despite the waiting for the entire party to arrive… my husband was the last to arrive… the staff was friendly and accommodating. They made sure the refills of drinks kept coming and the food was good and came out quickly. They were patient and did not make us feel rushed, despite us being there a little past closing. I am kinda surprised I did not take more pictures at dinner, but I was STARVING. Because we got married in the later evening, it made it trickier to have a venue for a “reception”. This however, turned out to be a great option and a good time was had with our friends and family and good food was had.“

“Oh my Dearest Wow!! Outstanding service!! Great Pizza!! Our Annual Christmas Party was a HULK SMASHING GREAT TIME AS ALWAYS!! THANK YOU.“

“Used to love going to this location and have been since they opened this store. Went in tonight and had the worst customer service EVER!!!! I will not be back to this location ever again. We drove 45 minutes to get here and was lied to not once but 2 times after waiting for a table for 30 minutes. Not going into all the details but i will NOT be back I'll drive over an hour to go somewhere else or another location next time. Our rating will be a negative stars if that was possible“

“Craving a dine-in experience? Here’s one of the few that are left.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Outstanding Service and Exceptional Food Quality!

I had an amazing experience at this location thanks to the manager, Chase, who truly went above and beyond to make sure my order was perfect! From the moment we spoke, he was attentive, welcoming, and genuinely committed to providing top‑tier customer service. He personally followed-up to ensure my order was accurate, the food was hot, and the quality met every expectation; and it absolutely did! The pizza was delicious, fresh, and clearly made with care.

What stood out most during our interaction was how valued he made me feel as a customer. His professionalism, kindness, and dedication to creating a great experience made a lasting impression. It’s rare to see someone take such pride in both their food and their service. His patience and thoughtful regard were truly outstanding, and I can tell by the spirit of our interaction that it was truly genuine. I really can’t overstate just how much he made my day!

I will ALWAYS consider Chase’s location for lunch or dinner, and I highly recommend this location to anyone looking for great pizza and even better hospitality. Not only will you leave with delicious food, but you’ll also feel better for engaging with such caring and thoughtful leadership. If you’re near the location, please show Chase and his staff some support.“

“23 March, 2024... Yeah. I had FOOD PIOSONING FROM THIS LOCATION. TOLD BY INEPT MANAGER TO CALL BACK WEDNESDAY WHEN THE GENERAL MANAGER WOULD SUPPOSEDLY BE THERE... A MANAGER IS AUTHORIZED TO DO A REFUND WITHOUT A GM. BOYCOTTING THIS LOCATION AS I WRITE BAD REVIEWS WHEREVER I CAN... August 22, 2023 Burnt. Pizza is normally Okay but it’s getting worse. Calling Corporate to Complain after poor service✔️Burnt pizza & dessert🔥 I will not order from this location again.“

“Kenna (I think is her name) is amazing!!!! Super sweet girl!!! Very nice customer service!!! Thats why we 💘 this place!!!!“