Sexton’s Pizza

5460 Franklin St, Hilliard

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Mushrooms and a Smokey Robinson' Speciality Pizza
Sausage Pepperoniabd Mushrooms Pizza
Pepperoni Bacon Banana Pepper Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks and Fried Pickles
Coliflower Crust Pizza
East Village Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
BBQ Chicken Pizza
In Queso Emergency
Pizza Margherita

Menu

Apparel
NEW Tshirts
Sexton's Hat

Build Your Own Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
NY style = 16 inch, 8 large slices (triangle) Motown= deep dish, 8 slices (square)

Specialty Pizza
Just Cheese
614
Pepperoni, bacon, banana peppers
Half Pep Half Cheese
Dairy Air
Ezzo pepperoni, cream cheese, Mike's hot honey
Bee Bee Q
Garlic Sauce Base, Fried Chicken, Onion, with a Hot Honey BBQ and Ranch Drizzle.
Cheese W/ Basil
Cheese pizza topped with fresh basil.
Ezzo Pepperoni
Cup and burn Pepperoni, whole milk mozzarella
I'M VEGAN
Follow Your Heart Mozzarella Cheese, Beyond Vegan Sausage Crumble, Tomato, Garlic Oil.
Kevin Bacon
Candied bacon and pepperoni.
MIKE!
7/11 ground tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, cup and burn pepperoni, mikes hot honey
Nashville Hot Chic
Garlic base, fried chicken, pickles, Nashville hot & ranch drizzle
Smokey Robinson
Ezzo cup and burn pepperoni, fresh jalapeño, whole milk mozzarella, parmesan cheese, mikes hot honey
What The Dilly Yo!?
Garlic base, cheese, pickles, parmesan cheese, Italian seasoning
Hakuna Ricotta
Ezzo sausage crumble, fresh whipped ricotta, whole milk mozz, fresh mozz, fresh basil
East Village Pepperoni
fresh sliced mozz, Ezzo pepperoni, fresh basil OWNER FAVORITE
White Pizza
garlic base, whole milk mozz, fresh sliced mozz, fresh whipped ricotta, parmesan

12" Cauliflower Crust
12" Cauliflower Specialty
12" Cauliflower BYO

Xtra Sauces
Garlic Sauce
Homemade Ranch
Jar of Sexton's Ranch
Side Of Mikes Hot
Mikes Hot Honey Bottle
Italian Dressing
Pizza Sauce
Buffalo Sauce
BBQ
Nashville Hot

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+13 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+12 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

When we first came here over a year ago, pizza was outstanding. Appearance, perfectly cooked all spot on. Pre-ordered pizza and went to bar to eat this past weekend. Pizza overdone, ingredients looked like they were just thrown on, not sauced or cheesed as usual and pepperoni randomly spread around. Hopefully this is a one time occurrence.
January 2025
Had a wonderful time at this location, last night was my first visit and will not be my last. This pizza is so good, I love pizza that the crust is not floppy. I got the NY style dairy air and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time. The music was great, the service was great, the food was impeccable and I can’t wait to go back!
January 2025
Got the classic cheese pizza, really really good, so far the best I've had in Columbus, if you want a benchmark I'd say it's about 40% better than Donatos. Learn from my mistake, let the pizza cool. Currently writing this with the roof of my mouth scalded, wasn't worth it but it's my own fault. Anyways, great pizza, will definitely come back more than a few times.
December 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Crooked Can Brewing Co. - 5354 Center St
Brewpubs, Specialty Food, Pet Friendly
Meatball Mafia - 5354 Center St
Food Trucks, Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian
Pitabilities Street Food - 5354 Center St
Mediterranean, Food Trucks, Caterers, Fast Food

Sexton’s Pizza

5460 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH 43026