The hotel that we stayed at recommended this place. The food was delicious, great prices, and the inside was extremely clean. Jessica and the other lady were extremely nice. I would definitely recommend Angie’s Pizza in Lancaster, Ohio!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amber Williams
This place is the caviar of pizza and subs. Massey's no way2 overpriced now Angie's is a little more pricier than most but not as much as Massey'.you're going to get a cheese pizza always go double cheese. Their Italian subs are wonderful they don't use that cheap ham. Instead they use capicola They have the white Italian dressing the kind that you can never seem to find in stores.
Like you know how some pizza places have good pizza but their subs aren't good or some of their salads are okay it's just never everything is great. Like this place everything is good from chicken wings to the salads garlic bread with cheese get the three cheese always go extra cheese on your cheese pizza cuz there's not enough I will tell you that you just do not get enough cheese if you get all cheese pizza which is kind of disappointing I do honestly feel that the double cheese pizza when you get extra cheese that's how a cheese pizza should be here it just really should be it just seems like it just should be so always go extra cheese. No I will tell you that the turkey sub is so good when you add bacon mayonnaise Italian dressing of course lettuce tomatoes hot peppers and onions give that a try it's really good.
Their point system though to earn free pizza it's deceiving maybe they just don't have it together yet I don't know but I mean it's the least they could do is get their system up and going to where it matches what it says cuz it's very unsettling when they don't even know what points you have but you get emails saying that you have points but come on but you know what honestly I don't even care I mean it would be nice but and it's not a really big dine-in area there's like the Lancaster one there's a couple seats now East Dublin Granville road location they have more of a dine in area it's not really a dine in place and the Lancaster one but has a couple chairs and and small tables . I used to love it that you could get cans of pop I know the karl road location you could get cans of pop here at the Lancaster one you can't cans of pop just go with pizza places man.
They're salad I believe comes with their large salad one possibly two packets of dressing but it literally their large salads literally needs four packets. I love their food I've been eating it for 20 years and it never lets me down I mean there's going to be things that you might have to do like how I said put extra cheese on the cheese pizza but I made it work for me and it's so good I'm not going to go somewhere else and get extra cheese and not get this taste this taste is the bomb
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
john miller
Their pizza is as good as ever. Still using the good ingredients unlike most pizza places that seem to be all using the same stuff....glad to see some pride in a finished product
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick A
The price raise is a bit ridiculous honestly especially on the wings either get fatter wings to make the price worth it or drop your prices back down your asking for way to much for everything now!!! Me and my family order from here regularly but will no longer be ordering from here!!! Sad to see a place with decent food become all about the money they can squeeze in their pockets!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Alyssa S
I can only speak on the pepperoni pizza as that’s what we always order but it’s very good. Crunchy, slightly sweet sauce, crispy cupped pepperoni. They run specials on their Facebook page which make it very affordable. They do charge a fee to use card so pay cash if possible
Bert Shearer
Great pizza!
Food: 5
Christina drummonds
Very good food 😋😋
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leroy Wertz
6/13/25 we were staying at the Hampton. We had Ange’s delivered. I was amazed how delicious these pizzas are. I like to rate pizza where ever I go Vt.Nh,fl,Il. Etc. my home state of mi,has had my favorite 2 for many years until today. Ange’s pizzas are/were amazingly good! Not to mention they had it at the door sooner than expected. And by the way I rarely give 5 stars!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kenneth White
Best pizza i ever had got hit delivered it was hot and tasted awesome thanks for the delicious pizza I will definitely order from here again great job
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shawn Love
The food is great the people are awesome I grew up with Angie's Pizza in groveport Ohio
Hands down best pizza in Lancaster and there consistent cooked the same with the same amount of toppings as the last time and taste is great!!! They are a little more expensive then other pizza shops in Lancaster but well worth it in my opinion
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
David Holley
Great pizza in a pizza rich town. The best I have had delivered to my house in 30 years.!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve khoury
Finally, a great pizza shop literally some of the best pizza ever Lancaster you’re lucky
The hotel that we stayed at recommended this place. The food was delicious, great prices, and the inside was extremely clean. Jessica and the other lady were extremely nice. I would definitely recommend Angie’s Pizza in Lancaster, Ohio!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is the caviar of pizza and subs. Massey's no way2 overpriced now Angie's is a little more pricier than most but not as much as Massey'.you're going to get a cheese pizza always go double cheese. Their Italian subs are wonderful they don't use that cheap ham. Instead they use capicola
They have the white Italian dressing the kind that you can never seem to find in stores.
Like you know how some pizza places have good pizza but their subs aren't good or some of their salads are okay it's just never everything is great. Like this place everything is good from chicken wings to the salads garlic bread with cheese get the three cheese always go extra cheese on your cheese pizza cuz there's not enough I will tell you that you just do not get enough cheese if you get all cheese pizza which is kind of disappointing I do honestly feel that the double cheese pizza when you get extra cheese that's how a cheese pizza should be here it just really should be it just seems like it just should be so always go extra cheese. No I will tell you that the turkey sub is so good when you add bacon mayonnaise Italian dressing of course lettuce tomatoes hot peppers and onions give that a try it's really good.
Their point system though to earn free pizza it's deceiving maybe they just don't have it together yet I don't know but I mean it's the least they could do is get their system up and going to where it matches what it says cuz it's very unsettling when they don't even know what points you have but you get emails saying that you have points but come on but you know what honestly I don't even care I mean it would be nice but and it's not a really big dine-in area there's like the Lancaster one there's a couple seats now East Dublin Granville road location they have more of a dine in area it's not really a dine in place and the Lancaster one but has a couple chairs and and small tables . I used to love it that you could get cans of pop I know the karl road location you could get cans of pop here at the Lancaster one you can't cans of pop just go with pizza places man.
They're salad I believe comes with their large salad one possibly two packets of dressing but it literally their large salads literally needs four packets. I love their food I've been eating it for 20 years and it never lets me down I mean there's going to be things that you might have to do like how I said put extra cheese on the cheese pizza but I made it work for me and it's so good I'm not going to go somewhere else and get extra cheese and not get this taste this taste is the bomb
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Their pizza is as good as ever. Still using the good ingredients unlike most pizza places that seem to be all using the same stuff....glad to see some pride in a finished product
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The price raise is a bit ridiculous honestly especially on the wings either get fatter wings to make the price worth it or drop your prices back down your asking for way to much for everything now!!! Me and my family order from here regularly but will no longer be ordering from here!!! Sad to see a place with decent food become all about the money they can squeeze in their pockets!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
I can only speak on the pepperoni pizza as that’s what we always order but it’s very good. Crunchy, slightly sweet sauce, crispy cupped pepperoni. They run specials on their Facebook page which make it very affordable. They do charge a fee to use card so pay cash if possible
Great pizza!
Food: 5
Very good food 😋😋
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
6/13/25 we were staying at the Hampton. We had Ange’s delivered.
I was amazed how delicious these pizzas are. I like to rate pizza where ever I go Vt.Nh,fl,Il. Etc. my home state of mi,has had my favorite 2 for many years until today. Ange’s pizzas are/were amazingly good! Not to mention they had it at the door sooner than expected. And by the way I rarely give 5 stars!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza i ever had got hit delivered it was hot and tasted awesome thanks for the delicious pizza I will definitely order from here again great job
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is great the people are awesome I grew up with Angie's Pizza in groveport Ohio
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Hands down best pizza in Lancaster and there consistent cooked the same with the same amount of toppings as the last time and taste is great!!! They are a little more expensive then other pizza shops in Lancaster but well worth it in my opinion
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Great pizza in a pizza rich town. The best I have had delivered to my house in 30 years.!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Finally, a great pizza shop literally some of the best pizza ever Lancaster you’re lucky
Best pizza around
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza tastes like cardboard
Food: 2
Loading...