Cristy's Pizza Lancaster East

I am from the Southside of Chicago where we love and pride ourselves on deep dish pizza thats 2nd to none. However, Cristy's Pizza in Lancaster, Ohio has sets itself apart for me  with thier focus on fresh ingredients, a unique crust that is baked to a beautiful golden buttery brown with a perfect consistency of thick and doughy., Although it is in a class of its own I could described as being in the group of others that included a Sicilian or Detroit-style pizza. For our first visit we ordered a med size Goliath Pie with an extra 3 cheese blend and pepperoni that was as big asy hand. It was absolutely incredible, we were seated fast, the staff was so friendly, it was really clean, our order came out fast and the quality of all the above easily surpassed our expectations given the value of how little the charged for a freshly made product. Just to top it off they also offer gluten-free options, including a cauliflower crust and a thick gluten-free crust. This being only the tip of the iceberg though they have a very extensive menu with something for everyone. I know we will be visiting many more times to come and Christy's Pizza is a place we would recommend as a must visit for anyone I'm sure they will shot up to one of your top five-star favorites too.

Cracker crust the last few time I ordered hopefully it will go back the way it was i miss ordering my cristys pizza

My favorite pizza place. I've never had a bad item or bad service here. Everything is always great and they never bat an eye when I order my meatball and green pepper pizza. Weird, but it's amazing.

The food was good and it wasn't expensive. I'd order from Cristy's again.

Seriously one of my absolute favorite pizza places. Food is amazing and service was good.

Got order wrong, remade it and looked pathetic. Wouldn't recommend.

Cristy's Pizza was awesome! And I wanna thank my uncle, Bob Heston, who paid for it. I love you, Bob! And thank you, Cristy's Pizza East! God bless y'all!

Edit: Now that my Uncle Bob passed away on Memorial Day 2023, I have that memory with him... Once again, thank you, Cristy's Pizza East, and God bless y'all!

We have been getting pizza at Cristy's Tiki since it opened. We have always been happy and our family and extended family happy.

But the last two times we have done carry out, the pizza has been terrible. The pizza has been flat, over cooked, like it is a cracker now and barely any toppings or sauce. The dough is not the same. WHAT happened? New owner? It's like everything else in the USA, cheapening of food products. So sad. You have seen the last of us Cristy's after all these years.

Terrible experience just picking up my takeout order. My calzones were ready, but just had to wait for the salad. No big deal. Eighteen minutes waiting in the lobby, calzones in hand, and finally here comes my salad!! A nice cold salad with my now cold calzones! Oh and they also forgot the side cup of marinara :)

Order two pizzas for take out got home to find how over cooked to much sauce and very little mushrooms not one of the better pizzas differently had better from them

Awesome pizza wonderful service and very nice atmosphere 👌

Great pizza!! Everything we have tried has been very good.

Fast service

Always hot 🔥 classic pizza served with a smile

One of the best pizza's in the Lancaster area!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Double Cheese