Cristy's Pizza Lancaster West

Pizza sauce was changed and it was not good.

Food: 1

Service: 5

I have been coming to Cristys to get an Italian sub for about 5 years now. I have never once had a bad experience. This place is phenomenal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Usually no issues with cristy's but I ordered 2 salads for my wife and I. We both ended up sick after eating them. I checked what was left of our salads and the lettuce had black spots all over them and smelled awful

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Delicious pizza. The person behind the counter seemed annoyed that I came inside to order, and even more annoyed that I wasn't familiar with the menu and didn't know what to order

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 2

Best Pizza and in that town. 🍕

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Picked up pizzas to go. They were fantastic. Thank you.

Food: 5

Service: 5

I don't know, everyone seems to love Cristys, but I find it very very greasy. Like stain my seat because the pizza grease leaked through the box, onto my seat. It was disgusting and just unappealing. The girl seemed as if I was bothering her when I went inside to pick it up. We won't be back. It was sooo expensive as well!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Always friendly and respectful service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

THE BEST SALAD, now it may sound like I'm glazing but I love this salad. I'm autistic and a big struggle is finding food I actually like. The ONLY complaint I have is that I ordered croutons and you get a very small bag with like 6 smal croutons. I suggest just using your own if you want more than that. But I love the salad without the croutons! :3
❤

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

It was crap

Always love their salads!

Was to get a credit on my pizza as I had ordered a LG pep x cheese and mushrooms. I got mushrooms on half. Who knows about the rest it's always good but very heartbroken to not get mushrooms on the whole pie. I rarely get them so when I do I try to find help to eat it and I had asked my mother. Needless to say I had to call her and say, Sorry Mom just Joking! But will do next time. I had talked to the manager and she said would credit me something but when I ordered next time there was -0-. So 😔 we will still be coming back when we are in town. Just disappointed over it.

Consistently inconsistent!
We order regularly, and regularly they can't seem to get it right. Always order a well done pie with light sauce. Usually only with certain items on half. They can't even get this right about a third of the time.
We spend at least $30 each time we order. WE ARE DONE! If you like doughy pizza then this is the one for you. Swimming in sauce and soggy crust is not what we order yet this is what we get. Attention to detail is key with any customer service based business. At this point I'm really surprised that they haven't closed the doors and filed for unemployment. I can't count how many free pizzas they have given us over the years due to the mistakes. The remake is always right so why can't it be prepared to order the first time? I hate to call and complain about it for reasons they could probably sue if I posted it here. Sometimes when we complain management is nice but mostly kind of snotty. Is it good flavor wise? Usually. Is it worth what they charge? Hardly. The only thing they have going for them is how close they are to my house. The convenience. I will from now on order from somewhere else. I will drive to a further pizza place on the other side of town from now on. At least I know what I'll get there and won't have to finish the baking process once I get home.

I love Cristys pizza. It does tend to be on the greasy side and is not consistent (in terms of how greasy) but I order from here regardless. Flavor is good and usually fast. I always do pick, and have not dine in.

Just moved to Lancaster a few months ago. We tried some of the competitors around us, but we Love Cristy's pizza. I recently was diagnosed with Diabetes and my wife told me to order a salad. Wow... I got a chef salad with a few extra toppings and it was delicious. I don't like lettuce but with all the yummy toppings on it I could barley taste the lettuce! Pizza dough is wonderful. I am half Sicilian and this will be our go to spot. It's also a bonus that I live down the road from Cristy's.