Donatos Pizza
920 W Fair Ave, Lancaster
(740) 654-6444
Customers' Favorites
Founder's Favorite - 12 Gluten Free Crust
Italian Garlic Breadsticks - Full 6 PC
Mariachi Beef - 12 Gluten Free Crust
Chicken Spinach Mozzarella
Pepperoni Margherita Pizza
Hot Honey Pepperoni
Big Don Italian Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Cinnamon Bread
Mariachi
Featured items
Pepperoni
Loaded Edge to Edge with crispy heritage pepperoni and aged smoked Provolone, Romano!
Hot Honey Pepperoni
Pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, crushed red pepper and Mike's Hot Honey
Serious Cheese
Loaded Edge to Edge with real aged smoked Wisconsin Provolone, Romano.
Founders Favorite
Heritage pepperoni, family recipe sausage, shaved ham, banana peppers, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Cyo Pizza
Create your own pizza with up to six meat, veggie, and cheese toppings.
Full Bread Sticks Marinara
With marinara sauce for dipping.
Serious Meat
Heritage pepperoni, family recipe sausage, shaved ham, ground beef, hardwood smoked bacon, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Hot Chicken Pizza
Crispy hot chicken, pepper jack, jalapeno peppers, Romano, finished with dill pickles and a Ranch.
Pepperoni Calzone
Filled with heritage pepperoni and smoked Provolone cheese, and topped with Asiago, Romano. Served with marinara sauce for dipping.
Italian Side
Banana peppers, heritage pepperoni, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, smoked Provolone, Romano. Served with House Italian dressing.
Chicken Harvest Entree
Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, bleu cheese, honey roasted pecans, dried cranberries. Served with Apple Cider Vinaigrette.
Cyo Calzone
Filled with your choice of two toppings and smoked Provolone cheese, and topped with Asiago, Romano. Served with marinara sauce for dipping.
Works
Heritage pepperoni, family recipe sausage, freshly cut green peppers and yellow onions, fresh mushrooms, Romano.
Italian Big Don
Shaved ham, sliced salami, smoked Provolone, banana peppers, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, house Italian dressing.
Italian Chef Entree
Heritage pepperoni, shaved ham, sliced salami, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, green peppers, banana peppers, black olives, smoked Provolone, Romano. Served with House Italian dressing.
Big Ham And Cheese
Shaved ham, smoked Provolone, lettuce, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and yellow onions, house Italian dressing.
Mariachi Beef
Ground beef, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and jalapeno peppers, mariachi spice and a side of sour cream.
Margherita
Fresh mozzarella and Asiago, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, basil, olive oil (instead of red sauce).
Party Bread Sticks Marinara
With marinara sauce for dipping.
Ultimate 4 Cheese
Covered Edge to Edge with smoked Provolone, fresh mozzarella, Asiago, and Romano cheeses.
Signature Pizzas
Serious Meat
Heritage pepperoni, family recipe sausage, shaved ham, ground beef, hardwood smoked bacon, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Works
Heritage pepperoni, family recipe sausage, freshly cut green peppers and yellow onions, fresh mushrooms, Romano.
Mariachi Chicken
Sliced chicken breast, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and jalapeno peppers, mariachi spice and a side of sour cream.
Founders Favorite
Heritage pepperoni, family recipe sausage, shaved ham, banana peppers, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Very Vegy
Freshly cut Roma tomatoes, green peppers and yellow onions, fresh mushrooms and baby spinach, green olives, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Chicken Spinach Mozzarella
Sliced chicken breast, fresh baby spinach, fresh mozzarella, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, roasted garlic, Romano, olive oil (instead of red sauce).
Ultimate 4 Cheese
Covered Edge to Edge with smoked Provolone, fresh mozzarella, Asiago, and Romano cheeses.
Margherita
Fresh mozzarella and Asiago, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, basil, olive oil (instead of red sauce).
Classic Trio
Heritage pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, family recipe sausage, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Hot Chicken Pizza
Crispy hot chicken, pepper jack, jalapeno peppers, Romano, finished with dill pickles and a Ranch.
Hawaiian
Shaved ham, pineapple, sliced almonds, cinnamon.
Mariachi Beef
Ground beef, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and jalapeno peppers, mariachi spice and a side of sour cream.
Hot Honey Pepperoni
Pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, crushed red pepper and Mike's Hot Honey
Quattro Italiano
Family recipe pepperoni and sausage, salami, ham, and smoked Provolone. Topped with shaved Parmesan. Delizioso!
Classic Pizzas
Serious Cheese
Loaded Edge to Edge with real aged smoked Wisconsin Provolone, Romano.
Pepperoni
Loaded Edge to Edge with crispy heritage pepperoni and aged smoked Provolone, Romano!
Create Your Own Pizzas
Cyo Pizza
Create your own pizza with up to six meat, veggie, and cheese toppings.
Shareables
Side Bread Sticks Marinara
With marinara sauce for dipping.
Full Bread Sticks Marinara
With marinara sauce for dipping.
Asiago Cheese Bread
Fresh baked artisan pull-apart bread topped with Asiago and Romano, served with marinara sauce for dipping. Full size serves 4.
Garlic Asiago Cheese Bread
Fresh baked artisan pull-apart bread topped with garlic, Asiago and Romano, served with marinara sauce for dipping. Full size serves 4.
Meatball Shareable
Meatballs with marinara sauce, smoked Provolone and Romano. (Serves 3-4)
Party Meatball Shareable
Meatballs with marinara sauce, smoked Provolone and Romano. (Serves 15-20.)
Party Bread Sticks Marinara
With marinara sauce for dipping.
Made Fresh Daily Salads
Italian Side
Banana peppers, heritage pepperoni, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, smoked Provolone, Romano. Served with House Italian dressing.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Entree
Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, Asiago, Roma tomatoes, and served with ranch dressing.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Party
Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, Asiago, Roma tomatoes, and served with ranch dressing. Serves 10 as a side.
Chicken Harvest Entree
Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, bleu cheese, honey roasted pecans, dried cranberries. Served with Apple Cider Vinaigrette.
Chicken Harvest Party
Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, bleu cheese, honey roasted pecans, dried cranberries. Served with Apple Cider Vinaigrette. (Serves 10 as a side)
Party Chef
Heritage pepperoni, shaved ham, sliced salami, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, green peppers, banana peppers, black olives, smoked Provolone, Romano. Served with House Italian dressing. (Serves 10 as a side)
Italian Chef Entree
Heritage pepperoni, shaved ham, sliced salami, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, green peppers, banana peppers, black olives, smoked Provolone, Romano. Served with House Italian dressing.
Party Garden
Freshly cut Roma tomatoes, and green peppers, banana peppers, smoked Provolone. Served with House Italian dressing. (Serves 10 as a side)
Wings
Traditional Wings
Chicken wings hand-spun with your choice of Signature Donatos wing sauce or dry rub.
Boneless Wings
Breaded all white meat chicken hand-spun with your choice of Signature Donatos wing sauce.
Oven Baked Subs
Marinara Big Don
Shaved ham, sliced salami, smoked Provolone, banana peppers, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, marinara sauce.
Italian Big Don
Shaved ham, sliced salami, smoked Provolone, banana peppers, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, house Italian dressing.
Hot Chicken Sub
Crispy hot chicken, pepper jack, jalapeno peppers, dill pickles, Ranch dressing.
Big Ham And Cheese
Shaved ham, smoked Provolone, lettuce, freshly cut Roma tomatoes and yellow onions, house Italian dressing.
Italian Big Don W/sausage
Shaved ham, sliced salami, smoked Provolone, family recipe sausage, banana peppers, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, house Italian dressing.
Marinara Big Don W/sausage
Shaved ham, sliced salami, smoked Provolone, family recipe sausage, banana peppers, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, marinara sauce.
Meatball Sub
Family recipe meatballs with marinara sauce, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken breast, hardwood smoked bacon, smoked Provolone, freshly cut Roma tomatoes, lettuce, ranch dressing.
Vegy
Freshly cut Roma tomatoes, green peppers and yellow onions, fresh mushrooms and baby spinach, green olives, smoked Provolone, Romano.
Desserts
Cinnamon Bread
Fresh artisan loaf of pull-apart bread topped with sweetened cinnamon spread, streusel topping, oven-baked and drizzled with vanilla icing. (Full Size serves 4.)
Buttercream Cookie
Buttercream Frosted Cookies. All proceeds benefit Nationwide Children's Hospital. For a limited time while supplies last.
Party Twists
Sweet and delicious pull-apart twists, served warm, drizzled with vanilla icing, and topped with rainbow sprinkles. Serves 4.
Triple Choc Brownie 1
Belgian bittersweet chocolate chips, semi-sweet chips and milk chocolate chips, pure cane brown sugar and pure Madagascar bean vanilla.
Triple Choc Brownie 10
Belgian bittersweet chocolate chips, semi-sweet chips and milk chocolate chips, pure cane brown sugar and pure Madagascar bean vanilla.
Chocolate Chunk Cookie 1
Belgian bittersweet chocolate chips, semi-sweet chips and milk chocolate chips, pure cane brown sugar and pure Madagascar bean vanilla.
Chocolate Chunk Cookie 12
Belgian bittersweet chocolate chips, semi-sweet chips and milk chocolate chips, pure cane brown sugar and pure Madagascar bean vanilla.
Beverages
Dr Pepper
Dr. Pepper
Starry
Starry
Pepsi
Pepsi
Pure Leaf Sweet Tea
Premium iced tea brewed from real tea leaves.
Mountain Dew
Mountain Dew
Diet Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Aquafina
Aquafina Bottled Water
Miscellaneous Extras
DRESSING PACKETS
Dressing Packets
SAUCE CUPS
Sauce Cups
CHIPS
Chips
Calzone
Pepperoni Calzone
Filled with heritage pepperoni and smoked Provolone cheese, and topped with Asiago, Romano. Served with marinara sauce for dipping.
Cyo Calzone
Filled with your choice of two toppings and smoked Provolone cheese, and topped with Asiago, Romano. Served with marinara sauce for dipping.
Photos
+68 photos
+67 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Pizza, subs, salads and extras. Always fast service, dining in or delivery. Pizza made to order. These guys are awesome.
Parking: An entire lot to park in. Plenty of parking.
Parking: An entire lot to park in. Plenty of parking.
April 2024
Some of the best Columbus style pizza you can buy.If you don't know what it is try it, get a thin crust pepperoni, well done. The meatball subs are also fantastic.
Wheelchair accessibility: The main level is accessible, But it does have stairs to a basement and upper level. Which are usually reserved for parties..
Wheelchair accessibility: The main level is accessible, But it does have stairs to a basement and upper level. Which are usually reserved for parties..
July 2023
You May Also Like
Cristy's Pizza - 914 Pierce Ave
![]()
Pizza, Gluten-Free
Thimmes Fish Shack - 619 W Fair Ave
![]()
Seafood, American
Dairy Queen - 602 W Fair Ave
![]()
Fast Food
Vegetarian options: They have all veggie pizzas and subs. From what I saw.