Pizza Cottage

1961 E Main St, Lancaster
(740) 277-6289

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese Additional Cost
Bread Sticks with Cheese Additional Cost
Spicy Thai Chicken
All the Way Pizza
Fried Mozzarella
French Fries
BBQ Chicken
Italian Sub
White Pizza
We Seek Out

Menu

Featured items
Spaghetti (Dinner)
Philly Cheesesteak Sub
Garlic butter bun with provolone cheese, Philly steak, grilled onions and mushrooms. Topped with lettuce, hot peppers and mayo.
Single Topping Large (14")
Single Topping Small (10")
Fettuccine Alfredo (Side)
A generous portion of fettuccine topped with our creamy alfredo sauce.
Calzones
Our freshly made pizza dough filled with pizza sauce, cheese and your choice of up to three toppings.
Single Topping Medium (12")
Fried Mozzarella
Lightly seasoned and breaded wedges, made from fresh Mozzarella and fried until golden brown. Served with a side of our signature pasta sauce.
P.L.T Sub
Signature dish. Crispy pepperoni, Provolone cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Jalapeño Poppers
Onion Rings
Thick-cut onions beer battered for that extra flavor and crunch.
B.L.T Pizza
Cheese, bacon, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayo. Topped with a second dough, eats like a sandwich.
Italian Sub
Deli sliced ham, salami, jumbo pepperoni, Provolone cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes, hot peppers and Italian dressing.
Cheddar Steak Sub
Tender steak loaded with our Cheddar cheese blend, grilled onions, lettuce and 1000 Island dressing.
Chef Salad
Crisp iceberg and romaine lettuce blend, Provolone cheese, bacon, eggs and Roma tomatoes. Your choice of ham or chicken.
Boneless Chicken Tenders (Small)
Traditional Wings (5 Pieces)
Served with your choice of Blue cheese or ranch.
Ham & Cheese Sub
Deli sliced ham, Provolone cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Ruthie's Way Steak Sub
Signature dish. Tender steak loaded with Provolone cheese, grilled onions, mushrooms, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Whole Hog
If you love meat, this is your pie! Provolone cheese, pepperoni, ham, bacon and sausage.

Appetizers
Bread Sticks
Garlic Bread
Loaded Fries
Our Golden Delicious Fries topped with our white cheddar cheese sauce and bacon crumbles
Fried Mozzarella
Lightly seasoned and breaded wedges, made from fresh Mozzarella and fried until golden brown. Served with a side of our signature pasta sauce.
Fried Pickles
Dill pickle chips coated in a light cornmeal breading with a hint of spice. Served with a side of ranch
French Fries
A generous portion of golden deliciousness, enough to share.
Jalapeño Poppers
Onion Rings
Thick-cut onions beer battered for that extra flavor and crunch.
Appetizer Platter
Jalapeno poppers, onion rings, mozzarella wedges and fried pickles. The perfect way to start your meal is here!
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Deliciously dippable and incredibly indulgent! Our spinach and artichoke dip is made with a blend of parmesan, Swiss and American cheeses for a truly reach and creamy taste.
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Our bold and flavorful buffalo chicken dip is made with tender, all white meat chicken blended into a creamy cheddar cheese sauce with hot sauce, bleu cheese and seasonings.

Salads
Chef Salad
Crisp iceberg and romaine lettuce blend, Provolone cheese, bacon, eggs and Roma tomatoes. Your choice of ham or chicken.
Garden Salad
Crisp iceberg and romaine lettuce blend, Provolone cheese, Roma tomatoes and red onions.
Italian Salad
Crisp iceberg and romaine lettuce blend, pepperoni, Provolone cheese, red onion, hot peppers, bacon and roma tomatoes.

Wings
Traditional Wings (10 Pieces)
Served with your choice of Blue cheese or ranch.
Traditional Wings (5 Pieces)
Served with your choice of Blue cheese or ranch.
Traditional Wings (25 Pieces)
Served with your choice of Blue cheese or ranch.
Boneless Chicken Tenders (Small)
Boneless Chicken Tenders (Large)

Create Your Own Pizza
Single Topping Large (14")
Single Topping Medium (12")
Single Topping Small (10")
Dessert Pizza
Our delicious sicilian crust with crumbled cinnamon streusel topping and icing. Plenty to share! Serves 3-4 people.
Single Topping Personal (7")

Specialty Pizzas
B.L.T Pizza
Cheese, bacon, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayo. Topped with a second dough, eats like a sandwich.
Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo wing sauce, chicken and Provolone cheese. Served with choice of blue cheese or ranch dressing on the side.
All the Way
Provolone cheese, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and sausage.
White Pizza
Garlic butter, Provolone cheese, oregano, pasta sauce on the side for dipping.
Loaded Baked Potato Pizza
If you like potato skins, you will love this! Garlic butter, Cheddar cheese blend, roasted redskin potatoes and bacon topped with chives. Serves with sour cream on the side.
Whole Hog
If you love meat, this is your pie! Provolone cheese, pepperoni, ham, bacon and sausage.
Veggie
Provolone Cheese, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, green olives and Roma tomatoes.
Mexican
Taco meat or grilled chicken, refried beans, salsa, Cheddar cheese blend, lettuce and Roma tomatoes. Sour cream and jalapeno peppers on the side.
Spicy Thai Chicken
We start with our delicious Thai chili sauce and add Provolone cheese, chicken, bacon, red onion, jalapeno and pineapple. A combination bursting with sweet and spicy flavors you can't get enough of.
Chicken Philly
We start with our creamy alfredo sauce and top it with cheese, chicken, onion, green pepper and mushrooms.
Hawaiian
Provolone cheese, ham, pineapple and cinnamon.
BBQ Chicken
Barbecue sauce, chicken, bacon, red onion and Cheddar cheese blend.
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Cheesesteak in pizza form! White cheddar cheese sauce, provolone cheese, Philly steak, mushrooms, green peppers and onions.

Calzones
Calzones
Our freshly made pizza dough filled with pizza sauce, cheese and your choice of up to three toppings.

Hot Subs
Ruthie's Way Steak Sub
Signature dish. Tender steak loaded with Provolone cheese, grilled onions, mushrooms, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Ham & Cheese Sub
Deli sliced ham, Provolone cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Italian Sub
Deli sliced ham, salami, jumbo pepperoni, Provolone cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes, hot peppers and Italian dressing.
Pizza Sub
Pepperoni, Provolone cheese and pizza sauce. Available served open-faced.
P.L.T Sub
Signature dish. Crispy pepperoni, Provolone cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes and mayonnaise.
Cheddar Steak Sub
Tender steak loaded with our Cheddar cheese blend, grilled onions, lettuce and 1000 Island dressing.
Meatball Sub
Topped with garlic butter, Provolone cheese, Italian meatballs and our signature sauce.
Veggie Sub
Mushrooms, green peppers and onions topped with Provolone cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes, hot peppers and Italian dressing.
Philly Cheesesteak Sub
Garlic butter bun with provolone cheese, Philly steak, grilled onions and mushrooms. Topped with lettuce, hot peppers and mayo.

Burgers
DBL Smashburger W Fries
Two quarter pound patties topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickles on a brioche bun. Served with French Fries. Ketchup, mustard and mayo available upon request.
DBL Smashburger
Two quarter pound patties topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and pickles on a brioche bun. Ketchup, mustard and mayo available upon request.

Pasta
Fettuccine Alfredo (Dinner)
Ravioli (Dinner)
A generous portion of cheese stuffed raviolis topped with your choice of our signature sauce or meat sauce. Served with a side of garlic bread and a small garden salad.
Fettuccine Alfredo (Side)
A generous portion of fettuccine topped with our creamy alfredo sauce.
Ravioli (Side)
Spaghetti (Dinner)
Spaghetti (Side)

Beverages
2 Liters
2 Liters of Pepsi Products
20 oz Soda
20 oz Bottles of Pepsi Products
20 oz Bottled Water

Desserts
Triple Chocolate Cookie
Decadent to say the least! This cookie is made from David's famous chocolate chunk cookie dough, generously topped with Hershey's Mini Kisses, semi-sweet chocolate chunks and milk chocolate chunks!
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
Peanut Butter lovers unite! Peanut Butter cookie dough is loaded with peanut butter chips and topped with chunks of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+20 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+19 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Best experience yet. Misty, from Eastside Pizza Cottage, is an amazing server! Food on point as usual. Tried the gyros pizza, it was okay. It needed more Tzatziki sauce for one thing the other you can't help... each piece should have the exact amount so you can taste it all together. Hawaiian was amazing, and the signature chef salad was phenomenal per usual. The East Side Pizza Cottage now serves alcoho and beer. No tap ... yet... Love this community staple.
July 2025
Quite enjoyable. I had a quick vacation to Ohio and was wanting the old taste of Ohio style pizza. After going to the hometown pizza chain ,(Dona....) their pizza just wasn't the same as I remembered to trigger my memory of good Ohio pizza. I decided to give it another chance the next day and went to Pizza Cottage this time. Finally, finally my memery was satisfied. Service was great, taste was even better. Will be going again when I come back to town. Thank you Pizza Cottage...
April 2025
I always order a BLT pizza when I eat here. It is a little pricey but never disappoints! I highly recommend getting the cheesy garlic bread as well. The staff were friendly and our waitress did a fantastic job handling our table of 7.
April 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

OX-B's - 1730 E Main St
Chicken Wings
Taco Bell - 1643 E Main St
Fast Food, Mexican
Tim Hortons - 1621 E Main St
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee

Pizza Cottage

1961 E Main St, Lancaster, OH 43130
(740) 277-6289