Food is great really enjoyed this local stop fast and friendly. Don’t be afraid to stop and try sometime.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
W.M. Weikart
Oh, what a pretty hair, baked into the side of my pizza crust. Blonde and thin.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jacqueline Howard
Consistently great pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paula Grunkemeyer
Do not eat at the Lancaster location. Rude employees, rude manager. Manager had greasy long hair not contained and no beard cover. I will never eat there again. I guess you pay for mouth anymore with your food.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Troy Barton
The pizza is Great!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lacy Dowell
Been going here since they opened in lancaster and the one in Carroll we have our family reunion there every year still even after almost 20 yrs great food service and people
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Buckeye Bug Services
Lancaster’s best, but that is not saying a lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cody Benedict
Upon entering the person who I assume to be the manager told our group that they “the restraint staff” can’t handle a larger group and turned away our business
Service: 1
squirt man
I been going since 1989 in Carroll they moved to Lancaster so haven't been in 20 years. Still awesome tastes like it was back then. Thin and crispy how I love pizza 🍕. It tastes like pizza cottage also my other favorite pizza 🍕. I used to stop in Carroll before visiting my friends in Lancaster. Then they sold it n made it crappy pizza 🍕 so quit going to Carroll. N found by accident in Lancaster and Logan. Was so happy they didn't die. So got extra to take home in Marion. Marion sucks for pizza 🍕. I only have green camp pizza a town over that's good for pizza. But still no where as good pizza crossing or pizza cottage. Still the best two pizza places.
The first two times I ordered from this place was amazing. Today was my 3rd time and I drove 35 minutes out the way. I was so disappointed. Both pizzas had very little to no sauce and it was so dry we had to throw it out. Every piece we lifted the cheese and the sauce was nearly nonexistent. Spent $30+ dollars 😒
Melody Rose Dreher
Love love love this place! It reminds me of childhood memories, the all the way pizza is phenomenal! Not to mention, the employees are amazing also! Highly recommend!
G C (ShrillBird)
They really know how to overcharge for a bowl of spaghetti, $14. Friend bought it for me but I think it's wrong to charge people half a box of $1 spaghetti noodles $3 jar of sauce with 4 mediocre meatballs. Don't buy pasta unless it's at a nice plwc3 and you're sitting down. Pizza is the only thing to ever order out
Trista Turner
We love pizza crossing!! Especially the bbq chicken pizza. It is so very good. Tonight their computer was having issues and a mistake was made. But they corrected it and even walked it out to our car. Mistakes happen but it's how they are handled is what matters. Thank you for such good food.
matt Burris
Great pizza! 1st time we tried it! Will come back. Only thing is it took an hour to get our food
Their bread sticks are hot dog buns
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food is great really enjoyed this local stop fast and friendly. Don’t be afraid to stop and try sometime.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oh, what a pretty hair, baked into the side of my pizza crust. Blonde and thin.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Consistently great pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Do not eat at the Lancaster location. Rude employees, rude manager. Manager had greasy long hair not contained and no beard cover. I will never eat there again. I guess you pay for mouth anymore with your food.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza is Great!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been going here since they opened in lancaster and the one in Carroll we have our family reunion there every year still even after almost 20 yrs great food service and people
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lancaster’s best, but that is not saying a lot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Upon entering the person who I assume to be the manager told our group that they “the restraint staff” can’t handle a larger group and turned away our business
Service: 1
I been going since 1989 in Carroll they moved to Lancaster so haven't been in 20 years. Still awesome tastes like it was back then. Thin and crispy how I love pizza 🍕. It tastes like pizza cottage also my other favorite pizza 🍕. I used to stop in Carroll before visiting my friends in Lancaster. Then they sold it n made it crappy pizza 🍕 so quit going to Carroll. N found by accident in Lancaster and Logan. Was so happy they didn't die. So got extra to take home in Marion. Marion sucks for pizza 🍕. I only have green camp pizza a town over that's good for pizza. But still no where as good pizza crossing or pizza cottage. Still the best two pizza places.
Restaurantji Recommends
The first two times I ordered from
this place was amazing. Today was my 3rd time and I drove 35 minutes out the way. I was so disappointed. Both pizzas had very little to no sauce and it was so dry we had to throw it out. Every piece we lifted the cheese and the sauce was nearly nonexistent. Spent $30+ dollars 😒
Love love love this place! It reminds me of childhood memories, the all the way pizza is phenomenal! Not to mention, the employees are amazing also! Highly recommend!
They really know how to overcharge for a bowl of spaghetti, $14. Friend bought it for me but I think it's wrong to charge people half a box of $1 spaghetti noodles $3 jar of sauce with 4 mediocre meatballs.
Don't buy pasta unless it's at a nice plwc3 and you're sitting down. Pizza is the only thing to ever order out
We love pizza crossing!! Especially the bbq chicken pizza. It is so very good. Tonight their computer was having issues and a mistake was made. But they corrected it and even walked it out to our car. Mistakes happen but it's how they are handled is what matters. Thank you for such good food.
Great pizza! 1st time we tried it! Will come back. Only thing is it took an hour to get our food
Loading...