Still my favorite pizza, period! I consider myself a pizza connoisseur for sure. My second favorite is an Italian restaurant with true Italian owners up in Dublin. Both have a thin, crispy crust and a sweet sauce but Sugar Bears wins out by a nudge. We had pepperoni pizza, Chef Salad, garlic bread with cheese tonight and it was just as good as I remembered. Everyone has a different opinion especially when it comes to pizza. The employees I spoke with and dealt with were very friendly. We haven’t been here for several years now, they were having staffing issues several years back after Covid. Their for a long time their hours were so sporadic and when they were open you couldn’t get through. I felt like a kid again in the 80’s when you would try to call the radio station to win concert tickets. You know back when you had to camp out outside of Buzzards Nest for a week to get a few seats. Haha! I highly recommend if you like quality ingredients, thin and crispy crust with a sweet sauce you will be a fan too. Can’t wait to go back, see you soon Sugar Bears!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Rice
Always nice people working and the food is great. I love the sweet sauce!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bobbie Kauffman
What happened to their pizza, it was cold, the sauce not as good, Very disappointed. Not the treat we were hoping for.
Food: 2
Service: 4
jimi anderson
Best pizza spot in Central Ohio
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Nick Huffman
Second time getting pizza from Sugar Bears and it was even better than the first..this pizza was slightly crispier and I’m a fan of that. The pizza is thin crust and cut patty style for anyone interested. The garlic bread and sauce is also really good, the sauce reminds me of Pizza Hut from back in the day. I’ve had the same cashier both times and she has always been really friendly. Definitely going to be going here more in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dawn Bininger (Dawnie72)
It's been years since I've been here. My schedule never seemed to align to their hours. Finally got to pick up today. Every bit as good as I remembered. Excellent friendly service. Piping hot pizza! And SUPER affordable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keith Brown
Great pizza. Best in Lancaster by far. Pretty much every single person is kind and friendly in there, but there is one lady that is extremely rude, on the phone and when you pick up. Everything is done with an attitude. She clearly hates working there and i think sugar bears should find someone to replace her.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Anna Duncan
Consistently delicious pizza!
Christine Megimose
Thus has got to be the best pizza I have ever tasted.
Best pizza in lancaster and ill die on that hill!!!
toxic_dragon55q
Only doing a 1 star simply bc they got no wings
James Singer
Food was good, make sure you call ahead and order it to go. Given how high the reviews were I was overall disappointed. The shop was not prepared for us to want to dine in, and the woman actually seemed annoyed that we hadn't ordered ahead when we wanted to dine in. Tables were dirty, and there was no table service at all beyond the kitchen staff bringing out the food. When we went back up to the register looking for napkins she said we walked away to soon for her to give us any. When we asked for a box for what we had not eaten the lady acted like it was a huge inconvenience and wanted to know what size we ordered and how much was left, eventually giving us a sized down box that was a bit of a pain to fit the leftovers in. TL/DR : Food good, the experience so/so at best.
Andrew Meador
We came in on our way back to Columbus from Hocking Hills. I had read about this place for years, and it was a true treat and privilege to get to try it finally! There are about five tables here that can accommodate four people each. The crust is thick enough to avoid the pizza being floppy, as is sometimes the case with thin crust, Columbus style pizza. The sauce has such a sweet flavor and pleasant texture that it's one of the best I've tried anywhere. This is an absolutely solid joint to eat at if you're around the area. The owner took our order and was very friendly, and told us about the history of the place as well. You owe it to yourself to try this place if you're in the area.
Still my favorite pizza, period! I consider myself a pizza connoisseur for sure. My second favorite is an Italian restaurant with true Italian owners up in Dublin. Both have a thin, crispy crust and a sweet sauce but Sugar Bears wins out by a nudge. We had pepperoni pizza, Chef Salad, garlic bread with cheese tonight and it was just as good as I remembered. Everyone has a different opinion especially when it comes to pizza. The employees I spoke with and dealt with were very friendly. We haven’t been here for several years now, they were having staffing issues several years back after Covid. Their for a long time their hours were so sporadic and when they were open you couldn’t get through. I felt like a kid again in the 80’s when you would try to call the radio station to win concert tickets. You know back when you had to camp out outside of Buzzards Nest for a week to get a few seats. Haha! I highly recommend if you like quality ingredients, thin and crispy crust with a sweet sauce you will be a fan too. Can’t wait to go back, see you soon Sugar Bears!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always nice people working and the food is great. I love the sweet sauce!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What happened to their pizza, it was cold, the sauce not as good, Very disappointed. Not the treat we were hoping for.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Best pizza spot in Central Ohio
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Second time getting pizza from Sugar Bears and it was even better than the first..this pizza was slightly crispier and I’m a fan of that. The pizza is thin crust and cut patty style for anyone interested. The garlic bread and sauce is also really good, the sauce reminds me of Pizza Hut from back in the day. I’ve had the same cashier both times and she has always been really friendly. Definitely going to be going here more in the future.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's been years since I've been here. My schedule never seemed to align to their hours. Finally got to pick up today. Every bit as good as I remembered. Excellent friendly service. Piping hot pizza! And SUPER affordable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza. Best in Lancaster by far. Pretty much every single person is kind and friendly in there, but there is one lady that is extremely rude, on the phone and when you pick up. Everything is done with an attitude. She clearly hates working there and i think sugar bears should find someone to replace her.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Consistently delicious pizza!
Thus has got to be the best pizza I have ever tasted.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza, not good reheated, though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza in lancaster and ill die on that hill!!!
Only doing a 1 star simply bc they got no wings
Food was good, make sure you call ahead and order it to go. Given how high the reviews were I was overall disappointed.
The shop was not prepared for us to want to dine in, and the woman actually seemed annoyed that we hadn't ordered ahead when we wanted to dine in. Tables were dirty, and there was no table service at all beyond the kitchen staff bringing out the food. When we went back up to the register looking for napkins she said we walked away to soon for her to give us any. When we asked for a box for what we had not eaten the lady acted like it was a huge inconvenience and wanted to know what size we ordered and how much was left, eventually giving us a sized down box that was a bit of a pain to fit the leftovers in.
TL/DR : Food good, the experience so/so at best.
We came in on our way back to Columbus from Hocking Hills. I had read about this place for years, and it was a true treat and privilege to get to try it finally! There are about five tables here that can accommodate four people each. The crust is thick enough to avoid the pizza being floppy, as is sometimes the case with thin crust, Columbus style pizza. The sauce has such a sweet flavor and pleasant texture that it's one of the best I've tried anywhere. This is an absolutely solid joint to eat at if you're around the area. The owner took our order and was very friendly, and told us about the history of the place as well. You owe it to yourself to try this place if you're in the area.
Best pizza in Ohio!!
Loading...