Tiberios use to be the best pizza place in Lancaster. Now that it has a new owner it is terrible. They said our pizza would be ready in an hour and a half when we got there to pick it up they hadn’t even started it. We were told it would be 20 min. More went back to pick it up the woman said she canceled our order. Very poor way to run a business.
Lukey Luke
Literally the best.Don't think this is some "gas station pizza " because of the locationThe recipes and the family that owns them go long ways back.You're doing yourself a disservice if you haven't been here yet
Celina Theophilus
We’ve only ever gotten their stromboli so I can’t speak to the rest of the menu but absolutely amazing!!
Melissa Grannon
No better pizza around. The crust is awesome and the sauce is great! Super pizza.
Jason Sharp
Food is always delicious and the staff very friendly. You won’t find a better Stromboli in Central Ohio
Melissa Mackey
Best Stromboli ever. Sauce is the cat’s pajamas. Breadsticks and chef salad are great too. We go here every May 7 to celebrate my husband’s birthday and anytime we pass through Lancaster.In one side of a Shell gas station. Don’t let that fool you. Delicious food!
adam lee
Best pizza and Stromboli in town!
pattyrU2513IN
Having eaten here for years I can say without a doubt that it's the best place in town and is a little known gem in this community. It's a family run business with a lot of heart and love in their food. They also deliver! No matter what you're craving this place has it but for me it's their chicken wings that steal the show. The prices are great and you get the best food with the best service.
Amy Buckholz
Yummy food. Love the garlic bread, forgot to order some though lol. Stromboli is huge though I can never finish one.
mike pompeo
Mamma Mia finally real Italian food and I hate to break the News to people who think Domino's Pizza or Pizza Hut is Italian food that's not Italian food that's garbage come to Tiberios if you want a real taste of Italy now all we need is a pizza joint who uses a brick oven just saying ??
Stromboli was over cooked then my garlic cheese bread wasn't fully cooked was cold in some spots so disappointed I've never had issues like this with them usually awesome food they wouldn't even give me a refund because the manger cooked it and he say's there wasn't anything wrong with it.
Kim Mathews Dexter
A little rude on the phone
Traci W
I loved Tiberio's when it was downtown, and I miss their full menu their fried zucchini was the best in town. They're still the best their pizza sauce is undeniable the best in town, like their pizza. My favorite dish is Chicken Parmesan, oh my goodness I could eat it everyday. not kidding!! The bread sticks are awesome (but not good the next day I've not figured out how to keep them great like they come) I always get a whole order not just 1 that comes with the meal that's not enough. They have more then Italian foods they also have the hamburger, fried bologna I think even fries and I've had their hamburgers and fries they're all really good.
T B
My 2nd time ordering pizza 1st time ordering the stromboli, Wow!!! The largest stromboli and best I've ever had and I ordered the medium. Incredible food and incredible service. You must try this place.
Valerie Bassett
Olive Garden dropped Linguine from their menu. If you are a diabetic, this would be sad to hear. Olive Garden does not offer meals for people that have health problems.
Tiberios use to be the best pizza place in Lancaster. Now that it has a new owner it is terrible. They said our pizza would be ready in an hour and a half when we got there to pick it up they hadn’t even started it. We were told it would be 20 min. More went back to pick it up the woman said she canceled our order. Very poor way to run a business.
Literally the best.Don't think this is some "gas station pizza " because of the locationThe recipes and the family that owns them go long ways back.You're doing yourself a disservice if you haven't been here yet
We’ve only ever gotten their stromboli so I can’t speak to the rest of the menu but absolutely amazing!!
No better pizza around. The crust is awesome and the sauce is great! Super pizza.
Food is always delicious and the staff very friendly. You won’t find a better Stromboli in Central Ohio
Best Stromboli ever. Sauce is the cat’s pajamas. Breadsticks and chef salad are great too. We go here every May 7 to celebrate my husband’s birthday and anytime we pass through Lancaster.In one side of a Shell gas station. Don’t let that fool you. Delicious food!
Best pizza and Stromboli in town!
Having eaten here for years I can say without a doubt that it's the best place in town and is a little known gem in this community. It's a family run business with a lot of heart and love in their food. They also deliver! No matter what you're craving this place has it but for me it's their chicken wings that steal the show. The prices are great and you get the best food with the best service.
Yummy food. Love the garlic bread, forgot to order some though lol. Stromboli is huge though I can never finish one.
Mamma Mia finally real Italian food and I hate to break the News to people who think Domino's Pizza or Pizza Hut is Italian food that's not Italian food that's garbage come to Tiberios if you want a real taste of Italy now all we need is a pizza joint who uses a brick oven just saying ??
Restaurantji Recommends
Stromboli was over cooked then my garlic cheese bread wasn't fully cooked was cold in some spots so disappointed I've never had issues like this with them usually awesome food they wouldn't even give me a refund because the manger cooked it and he say's there wasn't anything wrong with it.
A little rude on the phone
I loved Tiberio's when it was downtown, and I miss their full menu their fried zucchini was the best in town. They're still the best their pizza sauce is undeniable the best in town, like their pizza. My favorite dish is Chicken Parmesan, oh my goodness I could eat it everyday. not kidding!! The bread sticks are awesome (but not good the next day I've not figured out how to keep them great like they come) I always get a whole order not just 1 that comes with the meal that's not enough. They have more then Italian foods they also have the hamburger, fried bologna I think even fries and I've had their hamburgers and fries they're all really good.
My 2nd time ordering pizza 1st time ordering the stromboli, Wow!!! The largest stromboli and best I've ever had and I ordered the medium. Incredible food and incredible service. You must try this place.
Olive Garden dropped Linguine from their menu. If you are a diabetic, this would be sad to hear. Olive Garden does not offer meals for people that have health problems.