Tiberio's Pizza
416 N Columbus St, Lancaster
(740) 808-8222
Customers' Favorites
Stromboli and Fried Ravioli
6 Fried Cheese Ravioli
Garlic Bread w Cheese
Traditional Stromboli
5 Mozzarella Sticks
All the Way Pizza
16 Pizza X-Large
Pepperoni Pizza
8 Pizza Personal
14 Pizza Large
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I'm from Columbus and am a picky pizza snob. This place is delicious! We travel two hours round trip just to enjoy. Service is great with a cool sports bar atmosphere. New owners stepped it up!
The restaurant was extremely busy the night we dined, but from the moment we stepped inside, our waitress-Carrianne (sp?)- was courteous and helpful. She didn't keep us waiting, and was nothing but attentive even with the full house. Her personality actually made our evening extra nice!!! We had a great time and a wonderful meal!
Food was good.. pizza was good. The dough was ready good. Sauce is on the sweet side.. do not get the
Cannolis though.. jersey girl here and these were not good..first of all they were flavored?? Like chocolate with sprinkles ? Yuck ! and extremely hard.
Cannolis though.. jersey girl here and these were not good..first of all they were flavored?? Like chocolate with sprinkles ? Yuck ! and extremely hard.
You May Also Like
Donut World - 601 N Broad St
![]()
Bakery, Vegetarian
Crenos Pizza - 620 N Memorial Dr
![]()
Pizza, Vegan, Pet Friendly
Pizza Hut - 632 N Memorial Dr
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Fast Food