Tiberio's Pizza
416 N Columbus St, Lancaster
(740) 808-8222
Customers' Favorites
Stromboli and Fried Ravioli
6 Fried Cheese Ravioli
Garlic Bread w Cheese
Traditional Stromboli
5 Mozzarella Sticks
All the Way Pizza
16 Pizza X-Large
Pepperoni Pizza
8 Pizza Personal
14 Pizza Large
Menu
Photos
+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I am not sure what happened during some of the other reviews but we just ate at Tiberios two nights in a row ! The food was good, came out hot and everything tasted great. LOVED the Garlic Parmesan sauce! The service Wayne provided was absolutely stellar. Everyone was so friendly. Samara did an awesome job when Wayne was with other clients. The two of them went above and beyond for us! And when the manager, Erin, checked on us to make sure everything was perfect, we had nothing...
My family and I ABSOLUTELY LOVE this place. Quick and Amazing service. My favorite servers are Myah and Emma they are awesome. The manager Erin always makes sure we have everything we need. I come here 2 times a week. Best pizza in town!!
The best pizza! Worth going if you want to wait over an hour to get your food. They burnt it and had to put in another order. Not enough help in kitchen? She said the owner showed up so what? Help out and take care of your customers.
You May Also Like
Donut World - 601 N Broad St
![]()
Bakery, Vegetarian
Crenos Pizza - 620 N Memorial Dr
![]()
Pizza, Vegan, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Pizza Hut - 632 N Memorial Dr
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Fast Food