Cold Stone Creamery

2387 Elida Rd, Lima
(567) 712-6349

Recent Reviews

Cyndi Huffman

Stopped in for some ice cream. Haven’t been here since they opened as we’ve moved. Wow - what happened??? Looks a mess inside. Dirty. Tables not wiped. Plenty of employees working given they were not busy at all (4 of them) - but no one tending to tidying the dining room. All hanging out in the office. They waited on us decently while at counter. Sad to hear they no longer carry waffle products??? WTH??? Every signage in the building has waffle cones on it. Guessing they went bad too quickly given low turnover. Sad. They ice cream was not really chopped and mixed - was more like blended to a runny mess. Sad it’s gone downhill so much. Guessing it won’t be around long….

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 5

Brian Jenkins

We were given gift cards for this business and went there on two different occasions over a few weeks only to be told their equipment to accept the gift cards was not working. I called and talked to the manager about this today and got an apology and was told I could order online And pick it up there well, if that is the case why not the worker have done that for me when I was in there on two occasions, and save me the disappointment of being turned away I think it is a breach of an agreement to take somebody’s money and not be able to honor the purchase And they told me there was no way to refund my money on two occasions as well very disappointed in this business .

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Jodi Lee

This place sucks. Put an order in for a cake for a Sweet 16 and no cake. Yet I heard they had plenty of time to make it and still didn’t. Only have 1 baker but called off. Need another person doing it not just one. I definitely got my refund and offered a discount on an ice cream next time we come in. There definitely won’t be another time.

Ian M.

Heads up: this is not open 24/7!! I got there at 9:20 on a Friday night, excited for my upcoming hand-tossed cold-stone ice cream and was sorely disappointed to see all the lights off. They closed at nine! Great ice cream but not good hours or communication!

That one Metalhead XD

So, I was in the mood for some ice cream so I decided to go to Coldstone. The girl working behind the counter said,”hello,” and that was it. I took 3-4 minutes to decide what I want. I walked up to the counter and she didn’t say anything like,”what would you like.” I told her what I want, and she actually didn’t say anything till she told me my total. The ice cream was pretty good in my opinion. She kind of gave the vibes that she was annoyed and didn’t want to be there, though. And I decided after I ate my ice cream that I wanted a drink from Tim Horton’s. I stood there for 5-7 minutes and no one came over. I saw another employee, but still no one came to take my order

tabs

Not good service, all the employees seemed annoyed to be here, bleh period. Don't come if u don't want an attitude from the employees. Ik working with the public is hard but c'mon.....?

Laurita Cross

What happened to Cold Stone????They used to chop and mix. On our latest visit….. nothing was chopped into the ice cream or mixed. Just chunks of brownie and candy bars. I thought the experience was supposed to be the mix of all the ingredients at once.

Ben Clark

Dining room isn’t open, and they don’t serve ice cream through the drive thru. All on a Saturday afternoon. Unbelievably poor management

Daniel S.

would give one star but there was an employee who did his best to remedy my issues. The manager failed to confirm my order of a cake for my dear friends birthday. i placed my order 30 hours in advance and when i called to check on my order, the staff had no idea about it and once they found my order they informed me that not only do they not have my cake ready, they won't be able to make my cake. had a whole party of dissatisfied guests

malaynah moore

went here yesterday with my fiance to get ice cream and went thru drive thru and they said “we dont serve icecream thru the drive nomo” so i was upset, i was happy to go inside. when i went inside there were two young girls, and one said “dude everytime i try to clean up and it gets close to closing, hella people come in here and im trynna go home” saying that to the other employee. and my fiance were in shock, they continued to roll their eyes at us when taking our order. definitely wont be coming back.. :(

Sage Mabry

There's always an issue here. It's excuse after excuse. How hard is it to get some ice cream around here?

Braxton Hammons

Close at 9. Went in at 825 and was refused service because "we Close at 830 now" Do you job.

Michael S.

Use to be 24/7, then open till 11pm, now it's 9pm, and the lobby is always closed. Constantly out of ingredients. When receiving ice cream through the drive through they put ice cream all over the side of the cups. Needs new management.

Nichole Field

Absolutely terrible. I ordered a Oreo ice cream cake for a birthday in my family. Everything was great until I looked at the writing. In a messily and rushed looking icing the message that I wished: "Happy Birthday Grandma" was scribbled as if a 4 year old was able to write on the cake with crayons. I understand that the employees at this business are busy and working hard but this is unacceptable. The writing shows that they do not care and are lazy about their job.

E K

Drive thru was open yet ice cream orders not accepted through drive thru. Two staff members at ice cream counter had incredibly poor attitudes, complained loudly about having to close, and were very rude to customers. Out of numerous ingredients when ordering so have a back up plan. “Clean spoons” in canister had chocolate all over them and when asked for clean spoons, staff were visibly annoyed. Offering i individually wrapped spoons for sanitation reasons would help this issue.Lastly, this location does not accept Coldstone gift cards.

Load More