My favorite pizza!! I always stop here on my way to Michigan from Georgia...and the return trip too!
Brian Newland
Ordered a 4 item pizza Saturday March 1, 25. After eating 5 pieces. I was sick to my stomach, I should have stuck my finger down my throat, to get rid of the mild case of Food Poisoning!!!!! It was 1 of 2 things.... 1, the pizza sauce, or 2, the sausage!!!! I would not recommend this place to Homeless person!!!!! Terrible, God Awful. Thank you for a wonderful Saturday night!!!! Smfh
Jeramie Ryan
terrible service last three times I've been there messed up my order , how hard is it to read a ticket. This is terrible all your kitchen staff is on there phones walking around doing nothing. who's running your kitchen? they need to be fired I understand if y'all was busy but it's slow and I understand you got teens working for you but there's no excuse I'm a restaurant manager and I deal with teenagers also.This is the Spencerville road location by the way y'all used to be amazing id hop on indeed and find new management.
Ronald Conway
Good local pizza. Staff supper nice. Would stop by again when in town.
Rick Adkins
Do not recommend...
Brock Hartman
I have been away for years, but one thing is constant. That is the taste of a Fat Jack's pizza. The first bite brought back so many good memories from growing up in Lima, Ohio.
Karyl Corson
Staff are very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Heather H
Ordered pizza and wings. As we pull in to pick up, my 4 year old had to use the restroom. Took her in as she is dancing holding her pee, the lady states that "they" aren't allowed to let anyone use the restroom because the door is broke. I pay for the pizza and tell my 4 year old that we will stop at the gas station down the road as she is wiggling away. Then she sarcastically tells me to have a good night. Ummm yeah, when she pees all over the seat it will be great. Right there tells me, they dont care about their paying customers as then I had to make another stop making dinner cold and a child who is holding herself crying on the way to the gas station. If my child didnt have her heart set on pizza I would have told them to keep it and not purchase because she had to use the bathroom and they wouldnt allow her to use theirs. Then I get home and my wings with extra mild sauce were bare, no sauce at all. Awful customer service, no sympathy for a child who has to use the bathroom and can't get the order right. Won't be going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Robert Lewis
Great pizza and subs. The staff is always friendly.
My favorite pizza place sometimes they make them amazingly sometimes they taste like a 3 year old made them been really hit an miss lately but it's still the best in town
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 21 Pizza
Benjamin Doviëre
The food here is always amazing, never fails to exceed my expectations of a good pizza. This pizza always brings back fond memories at my grandparent’s house.
Dietary restrictions: I am gluten free and this place is a life saver. It’s gluten free sausage pizza was to say the least, amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathan Branim
*This is delicious, hot, CLASSIC Ohio pizza! Ohio pizza, for those who don't know, is a relatively thin crust pizza, piping hot, round pizza cut in squares. It's the smack-dab-middle of Detroit and New York styles. Fitting for a Midwest pie.Fat Jack's epitomizes this genre of pizza. The facilities proper are older but well kept. And the cashiers are pleasant enough. As far as the pizza, they have all the types of toppings you could want and can have it out to you in short order. We don't typically get anything besides pizza but they have sides such as cheese bread and wings. JUST GET THERE.*This location is carryout only. It is a party store with no seating.
Always yummy, even my job orders them everyday.
My favorite pizza!! I always stop here on my way to Michigan from Georgia...and the return trip too!
Ordered a 4 item pizza Saturday March 1, 25. After eating 5 pieces. I was sick to my stomach, I should have stuck my finger down my throat, to get rid of the mild case of Food Poisoning!!!!! It was 1 of 2 things.... 1, the pizza sauce, or 2, the sausage!!!! I would not recommend this place to Homeless person!!!!! Terrible, God Awful. Thank you for a wonderful Saturday night!!!! Smfh
terrible service last three times I've been there messed up my order , how hard is it to read a ticket. This is terrible all your kitchen staff is on there phones walking around doing nothing. who's running your kitchen? they need to be fired I understand if y'all was busy but it's slow and I understand you got teens working for you but there's no excuse I'm a restaurant manager and I deal with teenagers also.This is the Spencerville road location by the way y'all used to be amazing id hop on indeed and find new management.
Good local pizza. Staff supper nice. Would stop by again when in town.
Do not recommend...
I have been away for years, but one thing is constant. That is the taste of a Fat Jack's pizza. The first bite brought back so many good memories from growing up in Lima, Ohio.
Staff are very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ordered pizza and wings. As we pull in to pick up, my 4 year old had to use the restroom. Took her in as she is dancing holding her pee, the lady states that "they" aren't allowed to let anyone use the restroom because the door is broke. I pay for the pizza and tell my 4 year old that we will stop at the gas station down the road as she is wiggling away. Then she sarcastically tells me to have a good night. Ummm yeah, when she pees all over the seat it will be great. Right there tells me, they dont care about their paying customers as then I had to make another stop making dinner cold and a child who is holding herself crying on the way to the gas station. If my child didnt have her heart set on pizza I would have told them to keep it and not purchase because she had to use the bathroom and they wouldnt allow her to use theirs. Then I get home and my wings with extra mild sauce were bare, no sauce at all. Awful customer service, no sympathy for a child who has to use the bathroom and can't get the order right. Won't be going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great pizza and subs. The staff is always friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 21 Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
My favorite pizza place sometimes they make them amazingly sometimes they taste like a 3 year old made them been really hit an miss lately but it's still the best in town
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 21 Pizza
The food here is always amazing, never fails to exceed my expectations of a good pizza. This pizza always brings back fond memories at my grandparent’s house.
Dietary restrictions: I am gluten free and this place is a life saver. It’s gluten free sausage pizza was to say the least, amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
*This is delicious, hot, CLASSIC Ohio pizza! Ohio pizza, for those who don't know, is a relatively thin crust pizza, piping hot, round pizza cut in squares. It's the smack-dab-middle of Detroit and New York styles. Fitting for a Midwest pie.Fat Jack's epitomizes this genre of pizza. The facilities proper are older but well kept. And the cashiers are pleasant enough. As far as the pizza, they have all the types of toppings you could want and can have it out to you in short order. We don't typically get anything besides pizza but they have sides such as cheese bread and wings. JUST GET THERE.*This location is carryout only. It is a party store with no seating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pie. Friendly staff. Fast service
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 21 Pizza
Best pizza in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: 21 Pizza
Loading...