Miss Mel's Bakery

2545 Sherwood Dr, Lima
(419) 333-1767

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Amy Wiechart-Bayliff

Mel was so helpful to ensure my order was right. She created a custom cake for us and it tasted delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aimee Brendle

Thank you Mel for the decorated cookies and the chocolate chip cookies for our “Holy Cow, We’re having a baby” themed shower! They were packaged adorably and absolutely delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookie

Sarah Kill

I definitely recommend Miss Mel's! I ordered custom macarons for my dad's retirement party and they were delicious and cute too. He loved them and they were a hit at the party (hence the late photo after a few had already been gobbled up). Miss Mel's was great to work with and also accommodating with pick-up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Macaron

Taylor walker

I ordered my cookies about 2-3 months in advance for my brothers baby shower and they came out perfect! I sent a few inspiration pictures and chose the colors for what we needed and they turned out amazing!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley Barman

Mel’s sugar cookies were delicious! She personalized them for our niece’s graduation party and they were just perfect!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sugar Cookie

Melinda Haberman

Miss Mel’s Bakery creates the BEST cookies made to order for any celebration! Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alicia Diehl

I ordered macarons for a bridal shower. I told Miss Mel the theme and gave her complete creative freedom. She absolutely exceeded my expectations and they were even better than I could have imagined! If you need a sweet treat for any occasion, I HIGHLY recommend Miss Mel’s Bakery!!

Misty Mathews

She was great to work with. Even on short notice she was able to bring my unique idea come to life. It was delicious and huge hit.

Angel Tatad

We first reached out to Miss Mel for macarons, cookies and cake pops for my baby shower last year and we loved it all so much we had her do more treats for my little ones first birthday! Mel is so kind, easy to work with and extremely talented. Her macarons are my favorite! Will definitely continue to use her for more special occasions in the future. Highly Recommend!

Austin Siefker

Mel responded very quickly and was extremely pleasant and easy to work with. Absolutely great cake and cookies. Absolutely worth the money to see the joy on our daughters face when she saw her Marshall cake for her birthday.

Carrie Dixon

Mis Mel went above and beyond with my son's 2nd Birthday cake. It turned out amazing! She is easy to work with and reaches out with ideas that will work for your cake. Easy to contact and to talk to. This is my second time working with her and will definitely have more orders in the future!

Kimberly Moore

We ordered cookies for my son's memorial event. They were absolutely stunning! Everyone loved them. This place is a 12 out of 10! Highly recommend!

Megan Meyer

I ordered cookies for my daughter’s 6th birthday and i couldn’t have asked for anything better. They were absolutely beautiful. And better yet they tasted wonderful.

Stacey Bowsher

Mel was a blessing and super easy to work with! From ordering to pick up, everything was a breeze! I'm looking forward to my next event so I have an excuse to order another delicious cookie cake! She also made custom cookies that were a hit.

Alysha Huebner

Cake, cookies, macarons oh my! She does it all, not only do they look fantastic but they taste amazing! Thanks so much Mel for making the process seamless, xoxo will always call you for my bakery needs!

Loading...