Sara's Sweets

435 S Eastown Rd, Lima
(419) 371-4745

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie

Assorted Half Dozen Cupcakes

Dozen Assorted Brownies Bars

Soft Frosted Sugar Cookie

Assorted Dozen Cupcakes

Assorted Dozen Cookies

Pecan Sticky Bun

Trail Mix Cookie

Buckeye Cookie

Birthday Cake

Photos

+47 photos

+46 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Sarassweetsonline

Recent Reviews

The only dessert my husband loves (and orders when we’re out) is cheesecake, so I ordered one for his 50th birthday. I ordered it plain with strawberry topping on the side (which he ended up wanting on it). They offer gluten free crust too! This is seriously the best cheesecake we’ve had. After a couple of bites my husband said, “this is better than any high end steakhouse.” It was well worth the drive to Lima, and we’ll definitely be ordering again. Well done...

February 2026

She was timely and very communicative. Delicious cake and always great treats when we come in. Got out wedding cake from her and now another one for a special occasion. I could rave on and on!

January 2026

Sara from Sara’s Sweets is amazing, and I honestly can’t say enough good things about her and her desserts. She made our wedding cake, cupcakes, and cookies, and everything was absolutely delicious. From the very beginning, she was so kind, patient, and responsive — no question was too small or silly, and she always answered clearly and thoughtfully. That really made me feel cared for and confident that everything would turn out beautifully.

When we came...

November 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Lima, OH

Sara's Sweets

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Sara's Sweets