Eliseo's Pizza

3352 Oberlin Ave, Lorain
(440) 282-8234

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sandra Moore

I found a hair in the pizza. I will not be getting any more pizzas from this place again.

Pete Morales

One of Lorain"s greatest pizza places

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mari B

The service is always so dry!! I have yet to visit this place & there's a friendly worker. They all got those miserable looks on their faces, it's odd but... this is definitely the best pizza in town. Just wish their customer service matched! I would buy from there more often

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Spraynard Kruger

Placed an advanced order to pick up pizza at 5:45 and showed up on time, but had to wait 20+ minutes in their cramped lobby with 10 other people because they accepted more orders than they could handle. One of my pizzas I received was lukewarm, the other was cold.I called in to see if they could help remedy the situation. They told me that the order was put in to be ready at 4pm and since I showed up late, there was nothing they could do. I asked to speak to a manager and they said they were too busy.I called back a bit later and spoke with the manager who told me the pizza was freshly prepared and was cut right before given to me. So which is it... was the order prepared for a 4pm pickup, or was it prepared right as I picked it up after 6pm? The manager kept insisting that the pizza was finished at the exact time I reached the counter, he was essentially calling me a liar for reporting that the pizza was cold. This is the worst customer service I've experienced in a long time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Bonny Bartlebaugh

I had a pep pizza with garlic butter, and it was so delicious, everyone needs to eat from Eliseos

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Travis Forshey

Awesome pizza and fresh ingredients! The owner, Frank, is very personable and takes pride in delivering a high quality pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

PrincessInArmor

We originally called Yala's only to find out they have thin-crust pizza, so we really wanted Eliseo's - which is now called Kate's. We ordered cheesy sticks and two pizzas. It was fun to pick up the pizza through the drive-thru window. On the phone, they told us the pizza would be "like Chicago pizza" with the toppings under the cheese. Once we got it home - it was good pizza - cheesy, good crust - but it's not anything like Chicago pizza at all. It's just regular hand-tossed pizza. We were surprised when they asked us what sauce we wanted for the cheesy sticks (garlic butter) that it was just a cup of sauce to dip on the side. We're used to pizzerias what put the sauce on the crust and bake it in.

kenneth barlow

Again the Eliseos Carne pizza is the best pie in Lorain county area.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brandi Y

My family loves this place we get Eliseo's on a normal once a week sometimes twice weekly. We love it, it is one of the best pizza places and Lorain County and in Lorain just in general!!

Vegetarian options: Anything that you want they can turn into something that is strictly for vegetarian options.

Kid-friendliness: They are very calm and nice people big area when you walk in and always kind to everyone including my children.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garden Salad

mick black

Great pizza. I get it well done, and the cheese gets nice and bubbly.

Heather Boone

Buckeye Community Bank loved this pizza!!!

Metro User

The best pizza I've had in years! The bone in wings could have been crisper and lacking flavor. Really liked the drive thru for pickup!

Wheelchair accessibility: Has drive thru

Russell Bryner

Awesome pizza. Not impressed with boneless wings. Too much breading

CC

Poor Quality - both pizzas were burnt. Called spoke to manager who was very rude. Said ok good bye. Said I could bring the pizza back, but we had already disposed in garbage disposal. Will not be returning - time to start ordering from another pizzeria. Manager needs to be thought Customer Service skills.

richardrP9614RC

ok pizza by far not the best pizza in town was supposed to be thin crust ,it was not and im not sure it was mozzarella chess

Loading...