“Was able to see multiple tvs to watch March Madness from anywhere. Clean. Staff was polite. Food was average, nothing bad just wouldn’t make a trip just for the food. Tried multiple pizzas and subs. Was there for a party and it was a great location. Rained so couldn’t play corn hole, but it was set up. Everyone had a GREAT “
“I’m so sad the broccoli cheddar mac was discontinued! I’ve been under the weather, I was craving it! I settled for the broccoli ched soup, another one of my favs! I’m not sure of the store manager’s name, but he made my day today! Super kind and energetic! This man deserves a raise!“
“I have read all the lukewarm reviews for this place. However, HANDS DOWN, their pizza was awesome. Buckeye Pizza's thin crust was PERFECT. It was NOT overly greasy, it was crunchy and just GREAT. The Pan was a DREAM. I ordered both. Their wings were pretty good.. OVERALL.. GREAT dinner. I ordered it over the phone, they said it'd be done in 25 mins. I got there 5 mins early, and my pan pizza was still in the oven. They had order in front of me and behind me, but my order was ready when they said it would be. I know that Plain City has ALOT of pizza places, but Buckeye is one of my go to for a while.“
“Visiting the area on business and found this place rated well so gave it a try! Food was great, I had a meatball sub, beer was cold, and staff were very friendly. I saw some pizza's others were eating and looked really good! We all ate and had a beer for about $11 bucks, can't beat it!“