Cleveland Pizza Co

8510 Mentor Ave, Mentor
(440) 266-0800

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tom Williams

Ordered the medium build your own pizza with Pep and bacon it was Awesome! Also got a Meat Stromboli with fresh Basil added and it was equally Awesome! Got side sauces I got the Cleveland pizza company Ranch and the Burnt River Ranch both sauces are Amazing! First time customer I will be back!

Ruth Kulis

Beware, their online app may look likes it's working but it might not be. I placed an order on Saturday night for Sunday afternoon pickup on their app and received a confirmation email. When we arrived to pickup the 3 sheet pizzas the girl working said we could not have placed the order because their server was down. I showed her the confirmation email and they still kept saying the server was down. They never apologized or tried to offer a solution. Only after I asked what can we do now, did they offer to make the pizzas right then but they would need my credit card. I showed her my credit card app where it clearly shows the charge, but they wouldn't do anything unless I gave them my card. I left and will go to Jet's pizza in the future. Very disappointed in the lack of customer service.

Debbie Gregory

We had the NY style pizza and cheese bread, both where good. Definitely will order from them again!

Liz Swain

Pizza barely had any cheese on it. Delivery took over an hour and when we did get it, it was cold

River Valley

Just dirty dirty pizza. Nasty, filthy pizza.

Karen

The worst 2hours for delivery cold soggy pizza

Joan Wells

Good pizza

Unpleasant Karma

Fantastic pizza quality. I'm not a crust person, I ste all the crust.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jim Alves

Great pizza, mediocre website, only takeout.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Gillespie

Love their Stromboli

Ang Herzog

Placed a pick up order by phone with Makahla (or however it's spelled). I arrived to pickup and all the people in there just looked at me like I was crazy. Makahla proceeds to say you "you order from the other location" I got back into my car and called the number I originally called and she answered. I explained the issue, was placed on hold and when she got back on she says "fine I'll make it now" in the snottiest tone ever. I told her to forget it and let her know that all she had to do was say sorry I'll fix it and dead silence. Don't bother with this place if she's working. She rude and doesn't understand how to apologize. I will tell everyone to avoid them that I can. A simple sorry goes a million miles!!!!

Matt Matheny

The best pizza in all of Cleveland. Go here!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gary Anderson

Great place to eat at. Plenty of parking and food is outstanding.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breaded Mushrooms, Cinnamon Breadsticks

Gianna Foxx

Grilled cheese pizza was super dry with barely any cheese on it and sandy breadcrumbs on top. 2 parts of our order were ordered in correctly, given the wrong sandwich and pepperoni pizza wasn’t thin crust as ordered. Rest of order was good but grilled cheese pizza was super disappointing. Needs way more cheese on it.Manager called back right away and made it right. Great customer service!

Food: 3

Service: 5

Alan Degidio

The service was absolutely horrible. The pepperoni Stromboli had 1 piece of pepperoni. The salad had only onions . And did I mention the service is horrible. Sorry they lost a customer

Loading...