Tommy's Old Fashioned Subs

7671 Mentor Ave, Mentor
(440) 975-1570

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Justin Fulmer

Excellent subs I always get the Philly Steak sub every time I go! *** Update *** I use to order a pickup at least twice a month but my last 2 subs have gone down hill unfortunately. The protein portion has become very skimpy to where the bread touches each side and unable to see any meat and hardly any cheese last time I ordered my Philly sub was mostly onions they put so many I don't want to order from there anymore. $13 for a skimpy sub guess it's back to crummy subway for a mediocre one I'm not driving outta my way to get ripped off. I tossed 1/4 of it out it was all onions. The homemade bread was still great šŸ‘ only reason I didn't lower to 1 star. I was a 5 star review now down to 2 stars after my last 2 visits its well deserved.

Timo Kovacic

very fine dining, local buisness, stop by often after work. Workers are very kind and treat you with respect.

Melissa Perry

Stopped here to pick up a quick dinner for our family right before closing. The two young men that were working were so sweet and helpful, and most importantly showed such good customer service, despite it being close to closing time when I stopped in. Good customer service is hard to come by these days, but these two guys were top-notch. The sandwiches did not disappoint either. Will definitely be back!

TJ Schumacher

Fabulous Subs !!!!!

Zach Grant

Very friendly people, and absolutely delicious subs with fresh toppings (I got the cold Italian). Better than the chains, 100%. Will be returning while in the area.

G\u0026G

I ordered this on DoorDash as I was stuck in meetings all day. I got a buffalo chicken sub, which I was nervous to get delivered because I don’t live super close and didn’t want a soggy mess, but really wanted it! And an Italian sub for later for dinner (pictured). I also ordered Mac salad and pasta salad. The buff chicken sub wasn’t soggy at all, and it was good! Not the best over ever had (here’s looking at you Charley’s). Now the Italian sub was AMAZING. So so good. The Mac salad was not to my personal taste (pretty sweet), but I’m sure people love it, and the pasta salad was good. Please give them a try!!

Dwayne Workman

Changed the bread and cheese steak has a smokie taste. If I wanted smoked food I would go to Smokey bones!!!! Why would they mess with a great thing?

Food: 2

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Philly Cheesesteak

Craig

Best subs in the area. Hands down. Place has been around for a long while, and I always look forward to that Super Philly when I'm feeling I need a good cheesesteak! I highly recommend the food here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Super Cheesesteak

Stacy Perry

Absolutely the freshest ingredients and delicious tasting sub I have had and for 2 people, including 2 bags of chips and 1 drink, VERY inexpensive.

Vegetarian options: You create the sub.

Parking: Plenty of parking in a free parking lot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Super Chicken Philly

Javier Blaze

Reminds of the old fashioned sub shops in Philly. Amazing food and very friendly guys working there. Get the Philly out the Italian!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian, Philly Cheesesteak

Mason

Basically this place is one of the best sandwich shop in all of Northeast ohio, it's basically the closest thing to a mom-and-pop owned Jersey Mike's or east coast deli.
They make some of their meats in house that they put on the sandwiches, all the toppings are always extremely fresh and they have their own house made vinaigrette to put on any good Italian sub.
The place on its face does not look very impressive, it really is the closest thing to a hole in the wall sub shop. It's owned by the same people for years and is a pillar of the mentor community. A lot of businesses and they typically will deliver if you are ordering a significant amount of sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Philly Cheesesteak

Grant Gebhardt

solid shop! thanks guys, you all rock.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William Michal

Always friendly service and great sandwiches !!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian

James K

I'm from the east coast of pa. so we like our cheesesteaks. I was looking forward to trying one here, but was highly disappointed. I thought they forgot the meat and I had to open the sandwich just to see if it had any on it. If you're expecting philly style look elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Doreohn Saddler

I came here to order the Super Chicken Philly one of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time, great customer service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Super Chicken Philly

Loading...