Central Pastry Shop

1518 Central Ave, Middletown
(513) 423-4431

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Heather Cranert

Everything is delicious 😋

Suzanne Werk

Came from Florida to come back to my roots in Ohio. I'll be 55 next month, came in after at least 25 years to grab a little birthday cake for myself. The cake that I had the other day was the freshest most delicious cake and tasted just like it did when we were kids. Maybe even better! I will always have a place in my heart for central pastry because it really made our childhood for our birthdays! For this cake to taste just like it did almost 50 years ago is saying something! Thank you for keeping the quality after all these years and making my vacation to Ohio an amazing highlight. You guys just came back from vacation too! I would have been so bummed if I wouldn't have got my cake, but I did!

Jon Lanham

Old school from flavors to interior. Good donuts, classic cakes and sweets. It is somewhat outdated with not taking gpay or apple pay. Cash or above 5 for card. A little slow, but delicious. The ugly donut is by far the best

Lorretta Kendrick

The packzi (pooch-key). The lemon. Only Jan - Easter. The best thing on earth.

Perry Baldwin

Got a beautiful birthday cake. Best ever!

Crystal M

If you love Danish pastries this is the place for you. I think they had around 10 flavors of Danish. I had the pineapple, it was very good. The donut holes were also very good.

Madison Miguire

Great service

Katie McKee

Incredible Cakes, Beautiful People

Mike Staples

This used to be my favorite bakery and my absolute favorite chocolate cake and buttercream icing! Sadly, I am giving up on it. Last July I ordered my son a SpongeBob cake and the icing slid off the cake before he could even blow out the candles, then I ordered a cake for my birthday and it was dry inside and didn’t taste at all like the quality cake I knew and loved. Two strikes for me is too many.

A Burman

Sweet people, sweet place and most importantly sweet donuts.

Eric Van Hoose

Great local pastry shop, service with a smile and a chuckle. They were hooking up customers with birthdays with free cookies. Place looked clean and smelled even better. Stopped for a coffee and a doughnut and left with a no special occasion cake and the softest Vienna bread I've ever had. Owner was there personally and sincerely thanking everyone for their patience and support. Truly great experience.

Kid-friendliness: Several children were present during our visit and were welcomed warmly by both staff and patrons.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cake, Doughnut

Leslie L

Drove a hour to get paczkis after seeing this bakery on aTravel Butler County email. Totally worth it, They had paczkis in every flavor imaginable as well as beautiful danish pastry, donuts and cakes. I bought a dozen paczkis which the family deemed as awesome! Service was excellent, too. I’ll be making this trip again.

Parking: Parking lot in rear of store with access through back door.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hazelnut Danish Cherry Danish, Doughnut, Enormous Cinnamon Roll and Apple Fritter

Debra Rogers

The best cakes in the world..i tried the carrot cake for the first time it was delishous ..it was my birthday cake for this year..it truely was awesome

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beth Ennis

The donuts were hard and dried out. Not normally what I've experienced here. I used to get my kids birthday cakes here and those were good

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Ronnie Reynolds

Always a joy to visit

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loading...