Cousin Vinny's Pizza

3433 Pendleton Cir, Middletown
(513) 422-2300

Recent Reviews

Sort by
S Ratliff

If I could give no stars I would, terrible food and service

Pinky B

I love this place! They have The Best Pizza around! 🫶🫶 and they just proved they care about their customers! 🫶🫶

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Lago

I hate to leave a bad review but I feel they deserve it. I had the pizza delivered $8.30 for delivery plus that didn't include the tip. I get it it was 6 miles not worried about it. The pizza was probably an hour instead of the 45 minute time that I was quoted. I get it it's Sunday they must be super busy. I mean I placed the order at 8:00 so yeah really busy Sunday night right?
So the pizza looked like a good pizza It had decent amount of toppings more on the right half than the left pizza sauce must be a shortage because I couldn't taste any could really see it either. There was a red substance under the cheese but very very thin. For the price there's no way I would ever waste my money on that. It was kind of like a pizza from Chuck e cheese. Or something you might find at a truck stop. I kind of just felt like I was so hungry I had to eat it. However I just ate enough to curve my starvation. I would recommend cousin Vinny's Pizza maybe for like a kid's birthday party because the prices seem fair if you're going to get a special. But as far as two adults that want to enjoy something that cost a little bit extra to get something a little extra special definitely not cousin Vinny's Pizza I've tried a lot of different pizzas so I thought I'd give this a chance. Never again! Sorry Cousin Vinny's Pizza, no good. So we also ordered extra blue cheese dressing make sure you put the lid on it all the way next time!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

OhioFoodie_

The pizza came out looking PERFECT, breadsticks sticks were good amd that cheesecake was amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Breadsticks, Cheese Bread, Full Order Chicken Wings, Chicken Bacon Ranch, Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza with Parmesan Cheese, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Meaty Hawaiian, Side Banana Peppers, Sausage Pizza, Spinach Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, BBQ Chicken, Cheese Bread with Mushrooms and Fetta Cheese with 2 Sides of Marinara Sauce, American Pizza, Pizza Meat Lovers, Philly Cheese Steak

Cassie Graves

Ordered a cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza. The cheese pizza was burnt and kids couldn’t eat it. The crust on pepperoni pizza was like chewing cardboard. Normally love the pizza but this time was not good.

Food: 1

Service: 5

Nikki

Staff is very friendly and helpful

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tommy

Used to order from Cousin Vinnies weekly, but too many times has my thin crust pizza come to me completely inedible because it's nearly burnt to a crisp and cold. So I stopped ordering thin crust and just get the regular, after probably 3/4 months of not ordering thin crust I try once more to order it and guess what :-) cold and inedible.. You've lost a customer because someone cannot cook on nights.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

cassie Carpenter

Very friendly staff and calzone was great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracy Lynn

I’ve tried a lot of veggie pizzas from a lot of different places so I finally found one that I actually love

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

angela keane

i usually dont ever complain about food, but i ordered a chicken alfredo and it came with no sauce or chicken?? :/

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Billie Barnes

My husband placed a delivery order this evening and was told delivery would be in 45 minutes to an hour. A little over an hour later, we received a call apologizing that the order was late and informing us that it would be here in 3 to 4 minutes. Half an hour later we stood in our driveway still waiting. When it was finally delivered, our food was cold. Imagine that. I called in to speak to the manager about the situation and he proceeded to call me and my husband liars over and over again. He claimed to be the general manager, so I asked for owner or corporate contact information and he told me he could not give me personal information and hung up on me. We work hard for our money and I don't think anyone should have to be treated so horribly while spending it. I think from now on I will make sure we spend where it's appreciated.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Debra ā€œDeb Da Celebā€ Sparks

I ordered a pizza from here while working a double shift..door dash was supposed to deliver it and didn't i contracted both cousin Vinny and door dash and the restaurant told me doordash has to rectify the issue before they can remake my pizza. We'll they didn't and I am out of 27.00+ with no money to order food from elsewhere and two companies refusing to make it right for me can you say pissed off..but that's okay because I am not going to stop here even if I have to have the police track down the doordash driver Carly and see what she did with my pizza!!

Brie Reed

I love vinnys but this place has gone down hill since we started ordering and this is the last time we order, ever.. Our pizza and cheese bread were barely cut, the tots portion size for $6.99 is a rip off, our sauce was missing as well. I also ordered buffalo chicken tots and they gave me chicken bacon and ranch. Im not even bothering contacting them, as nothings been done before when we have. Our orders always have something missing or something incorrect. I spent over 60 dollars for something that was barely worth 30 at best.

Food: 2

Service: 2

Joe Buchanan

It was just pizza. , better than the cardboard box pizzas. Brownie was a little overcooked. Breadsticks were extra dry

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Jess

Absolutely disgusting food i had delivered. The parm garlic was very sour, the nacho cheese dip was old and runny, the peanut butter pie was also gross. It smells and tastes like spearmint. Will not order again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...