Fantasy Diner and Ice Cream Parlor

5873 Hamilton Middletown Rd, Middletown
(513) 360-7097

Recent Reviews

Brian Honerlaw

Took my step daughter there for a morning breakfast and shopping day together and the food was amazing. She is picky eater and she ate everything. Will go back

joseph borovich

For the price you can’t argue that this may be one of the best breakfast spots around. I haven’t tried the lunch or dinner options but I can say for sure that the Fantasy breakfast is sure to please. I have tried other options, which I enjoyed, but for a great well-rounded breakfast go for the Fantasy. Service and atmosphere are great. The place is decorated with nostalgia revolving around the amusement park that once operated near the diner.

Mark Redmond

Excellent burgers and memories of Lesordsville Lake and Fantasy Farm!

Samantha Keys

Absolutely love this place, the atmosphere, and the owner and workers! Food is great, never had a complaint, and you don't leave hungry.

Ginny Jones

Food was amazing came out hot an fresh my server was great loved all the memobroilla they had hanging up as well. Will be going back ASAP

Lisa M.

It is a small town feel diner. Service was wonderful. We overheard several people come in and the staff knew their name and their order. They are not huge portions but food was good! Very interesting atmosphere as they have pictures up of long ago Americana Amusement Park.

jimmie barron

Service wasn’t very good, super slow. Food came out cold and extremely bland. I wouldn’t recommend to anyone. We won’t be going back. I even told them my food was cold and the lady just glared at me and stayed silent

Kheira

It was very good and such a nice server! The turkey club was amazing with the spiral potato fries. The sweet tea is so good. I would definitely recommend this place! It is nice and cozy.

DiAnna Himes

Family owned diner that has AMAZING food and pies. Just recently discovering this gem that has been right around the corner from my house. Coming every so often to try lots of different things from the menu. Haven’t had anything I didn’t like. If you’ve never been here, you’ve gotta stop in! You’ll be so pleased you did!

Richard Alcocer

My kids and I stumbled into this place kind of by accident. It seemed clean, and the staff was very friendly, and the menu had a lot of variety. On first impression, the napkin dispenser at our table was empty, so I had to ask for napkins. Secondly, we were not given a service (forks, knives and spoons). Thirdly, I ordered a hamburger and it came out on sliced bread instead of a bun, which made it sloppy and messy to eat. Also, I ordered french fries, and I got a pile of spiral cut fried potatoes - not what I wanted or expected. Not sure what they're trying to accomplish here.

Alicia Rice

Great food and service. peanut pie was my favorite part. really like the old pictures and pieces from Americana.

Stephen Francia

Absolutely perfect little "diner". Good food that comes out hot and fresh. Great service. Incredible selection including "special" blue plate type meals and pies. Known for their chicken "balls" as well. Menu items that are "fried" have incredibly no "grease/oil" around them - a good thing! The outside looks rough - almost abandoned, but don't let that deter you. Side entrance on the right of the building, and is handicap accessible. Go and enjoy!

Darren Copley

The servers were nice and really great. My kids loved it, but my food was cold and not fully cooked. Food is a little pricy too but that's not a huge deal for a small diner.

Crystal Fordyce

Cute diner with a homey feel. The servers are sweet and do an excellent job. The food is good and the pie is awesome. Really a great hidden gem!

Keith O.

Stopped for lunch for my first visit there. My opinion is this is what you hope for when stopping at a diner for the first time. Very friendly service and great food made this a great lunch. I had the pork tenderloin sandwich and my wife had the open face roast beef and mashed potatoes. Portions were generous and tasted great. Can't wait to go back and next try a piece of pie from their huge selection of pies.

Load More